Electronic alerts may do more harm than good for kidney patients

February 25, 2015

New Haven, Conn. -- The use of electronic alerts by hospitals treating patients with acute kidney injury may increase interventions without improving care, a study by Yale researchers found.

The study was published Feb. 25 in The Lancet.

Acute kidney injury (AKI) is a serious condition that can lead to dialysis and even death in hospitalized patients. To prevent these adverse outcomes, some hospital systems have proposed using electronic alerts to detect the condition at an early stage. To test the effectiveness of an alert system, first author F. Perry Wilson, M.D. assistant professor of medicine at Yale, and his co-authors conducted a randomized trial with 2,400 patients at the Hospital at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia.

The researchers randomized patients into one of two study groups: an AKI alert group and a "usual care" group with no alert. When a patient tested positive for AKI -- determined by serum creatinine values -- the provider and a pharmacist received an alert in the form of a text page informing them of the diagnosis and encouraging them to take appropriate steps. The message also included a link to a website with guidelines for managing AKI.

The researchers reviewed outcomes of the alert system at 7, 14, and 30 days after hospital admission. At the end of the eight-month study period, they were surprised by their findings.

"Our hypothesis was that it would improve outcomes," said Wilson. "But we found that, overall, there was no effect. Informing the doctors did not change behavior, and it did not change outcomes in terms of dialysis or death."

One reason may be because AKI is a condition with no clear-cut treatments, Wilson suggested. "I think we put this tool into the clinicians hands and didn't teach them how to use it."

While the alert system did not improve outcomes, in a subset of patients it did increase interventions, including more renal consultations and dialysis. These interventions, however, did not correlate with higher-quality care. "For acute kidney injury, more treatment is not necessarily better," Wilson noted.

The study findings are notable because hospital systems, including the National Health Service in the United Kingdom, are moving toward increased use of electronic alerts. "We concluded that for AKI the alerts are ineffective," Wilson said.
Other Yale authors Jeffrey Testani M.D., Chirag R Parikh M.D.; additional authors are Michael Shashaty M.D., Iram Aqeel M.D., Yuliya Borovskiy, Susan Ellenberg, Harold I. Feldman M.D., Hilda Fernandez M.D., Yevgeniy Gitelman M.D., Jennie Lin M.D., Dan Negoianu M.D., Peter P Reese M.D., Richard Urbani, and Barry Fuchs M.D.

This work was funded in part by K23DK097201 and a Penn Center for Healthcare Improvement and Patient Safety Pilot Grant to FPW, K23HL114868 and L30HL115790 to JT, T32DK007006 to JL.

Citation: The Lancethttp://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(15)60266-5/abstract

Yale University

Related Dialysis Articles from Brightsurf:

Immediate dialysis no better than wait-until-necessary approach, researchers find
In the largest international study of its kind, researchers at the University of Alberta and Toronto's St.

Predictors of 5-year mortality in young dialysis patients
The analysis published in NDT [1] evaluated for the first time the association of a large number of demographic, HD treatment and laboratory variables with mortality in patients on chronic hemodialysis treatment since childhood.

COVID-19 mortality alarmingly high in dialysis patients
Analysis of a Spanish experience shows that COVID-19 is frequent in hemodialysis patients, who appear to be at risk for worse outcome.

Survival following switch from urgent in-center hemodialysis to home dialysis
Few patients who start urgent and unplanned dialysis in clinical centers switch to home dialysis.

Is ownership of dialysis facilities associated with access to kidney transplants?
An analysis that included data for nearly 1.5 million patients with end-stage kidney disease looked at whether ownership of dialysis facilities was associated with patients' access to kidney transplants.

At-home dialysis improves quality of life
The rate of people starting voluntary at-home peritoneal dialysis rose from 15% to 34% over 10 years at Kaiser Permanente in Northern California, providing a convenient and safe way to manage advanced-stage kidney disease compared with center-based hemodialysis, according to research published today in JAMA Internal Medicine.

Hydration sensor could improve dialysis
Researchers from MIT and Massachusetts General Hospital have now developed a portable sensor that can accurately measure patients' hydration levels using a technique known as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxometry.

Uncovering possible role of polyphosphate in dialysis-related amyloidosis
Researchers from Osaka University found that the low concentrations of the naturally occurring biopolymer, polyphosphate (polyP), induces amyloid formation from β2 microglobulin under both acidic and neutral conditions but by different mechanisms.

Study compares dialysis reimbursement around the globe
Dialysis reimbursement policies in most countries are focused on conventional in-center hemodialysis, although home hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis might contribute to quality of life and cost savings.

Elderly patients on dialysis have a high risk of dementia
Older kidney disease patients who are sick enough to require the blood-filtering treatment known as dialysis are at high risk of dementia, including Alzheimer's disease, according to a study led by scientists at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.

Read More: Dialysis News and Dialysis Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.