Employers 'routinely discriminating against stammerers'

March 10, 2014

Employers are routinely discriminating against people who stammer, rejecting them because of concerns about possible negative reactions from customers or team members, new research suggests.

A study by Dr Clare Butler, of Newcastle University Business School, published in the journal Work, Employment and Society says that people who stammer experience widespread prejudice in the jobs market.

Thirty-six men from England and Wales, ranging in age from 21 to 65 years, were interviewed and all reported routine discrimination. Some had been immediately rejected at interviews because of their stammer and others could only find jobs where they were over-qualified.

Dr Butler said two-thirds of those who were successful in gaining employment believed they were appointed because "the nature of the job meant no-one else would stick it, which often indicated a lonely or repetitive job". As a result, the men often described their workplace experiences as "mindless" or "frustrating".

"Many participants were told not only of their mismatch for the specifics of the job or the likelihood of a detrimental impact on customers, but also of the possible negative impact on team dynamics if they were appointed," said Dr Butler.

One man in his 20s who applied for an administrative post described to her how his interviewer told him "to go and look for something more suitable. He said that office work was definitely not for me because I wouldn't be able to get on with people in the office because they work hard but they also have a laugh and I wouldn't be able to join in.

"He said I could do the job mostly. He said he'd have to warn the customers about me and that most would probably understand - but he said I should look for something more suitable. When I asked 'like what?' he said outside work like gardening or something where I was on my own. I mean, can you imagine how I felt?"

Despite enduring frequent prejudice, none of those interviewed reported challenging their prospective or current employers. Dr Butler said: "This is in contrast to the movement for those with other impairments, such as dyslexia, where employees now expect, and employers are expected to make, adjustments to facilitate full access at work."

Even when they had found work they could face discrimination. A civil servant in his mid-40s reported that his manager asked him to stay away from key partnership meetings because his speech "upset the flow of the meeting".

The widespread discrimination was worsened by the changing nature of work. Dr Butler said: "More than 70 per cent of participants discussed the changing work context where they thought the roles that are, or would be, available to them are reducing. They referred to the lack of technical skills training, practical work, apprenticeships and the declining manufacturing industry. The growth of employment in service and retail has further decreased the career opportunities for people who stammer."

Reflecting on the current work climate, one man in his late 40s told her: "This voice is not what they [organisations] want."

However, this was not always the case, employers were supportive and responsive when "participants had an increased level of skill in an area where that skill was scarce or speech was not considered integral to the job requirements," said Dr Butler.

She said that many interviewees thought that their having a stammer meant they had become better listeners, and that was an important skill for the workplace. One man in his 40s told her: "Best bloody training ever for listening is having a stammer, as a kid what did we used to do but listen? I used to follow-up the meetings with emails sometimes to clarify questions that were asked in a quiet or an unspoken way and obviously missed by those trying to outsmart each other. I think every meeting should have a stammerer."

Around one per cent of the population has a stammer, 80 per cent of those are men.
-end-
Dr Butler's article 'Wanted - straight talkers: stammering and aesthetic labour' is published online in Work, Employment and Society, published by the British Sociological Association and SAGE. The research was funded by the Dominic Barker Trust.

For more information, please contact:

Tony Trueman
British Sociological Association
Tel: 07964 023392
tony.trueman@britsoc.org.uk

Notes

1. Newcastle University Business School is:

Reputable

The Business School is one of the largest, most diverse schools in Newcastle University, with over 3000 students from over 80 countries and over 170 full-time staff. Part of the UK's 24 elite 'Russell Group' Universities, it is a research-intensive institution, delivering programmes of the highest quality and one of only 144 business schools, worldwide, to receive accreditation from the European agency EFMD under its 'EQUIS' scheme. Many of academic programmes are accredited by professional bodies.

Relevant

All programmes are designed with the global business community in mind and students are encouraged to think entrepreneurially. Research expertise are focused on influencing current business policy and practice - as well as core aspects of management, it specialises in knowledge, innovation, technology, and enterprise through the dedicated KITE research centre, which is currently developing its research in the field of entrepreneurship.

Networked

The Business School's graduate employment rates are well above the national average: in 2010, 96 per cent of employment-seeking graduates secured jobs within six months. Ninety-seven per cent of students who undertake 12-month placements achieve a 1st or 2:1 degree, and all students have access to one of the best careers services in the UK, as well as a variety of workplace initiatives with leading global brands. The School also has an extensive, international network of university partnerships.

Challenging

The School strives to create the best environment for high-calibre students and faculty to be intellectually challenged and rewarded. Its brand-new £50m building hosts networking spaces where students and staff collaborate. Professional accreditations ensure it takes a critical approach to the relevance of our teaching, and is committed to recruiting the best minds in business to our academic faculty.

Vibrant

Newcastle has twice been voted the best university-city in the UK. It is renowned for its architectural beauty, cultural scene, and lively nightlife, as well as its friendliness. Surrounded by some of the UK's most unspoilt countryside and coastline, Newcastle also offers excellent value for money, making it an affordable destination for students of all backgrounds.

2. SAGE is a leading international publisher of journals, books, and electronic media for academic, educational, and professional markets. Since 1965, SAGE has helped inform and educate a global community of scholars, practitioners, researchers, and students spanning a wide range of subject areas including business, humanities, social sciences, and science, technology, and medicine. An independent company, SAGE has principal offices in Los Angeles, London, New Delhi, Singapore and Washington DC. http://www.sagepublications.com

3. The British Sociological Association's mission is to represent the intellectual and sociological interests of its members. The BSA is a Company Limited by Guarantee. Registered in England and Wales. Company Number: 3890729. Registered Charity Number 1080235 http://www.britsoc.co.uk

SAGE

Related Employment Articles from Brightsurf:

Employment insecurity linked to anxiety and depression among young adults during COVID-19
Young adults may be less susceptible to the serious adverse health effects of COVID-19, but they have not been absolved from economic and employment downturns -- and there has been little research on how employment insecurity has affected them.

Study examines cancer's effects on young women's employment and finances
Cancer and its treatment can impact an individual's ability to work, and employment disruptions can lead to financial hardships.

Perspective on employment rates after spinal cord injury - 30 years after the ADA
Thirty years after the passage of the ADA, planning for return to work is often a low priority during rehabilitation for spinal cord injury, The authors emphasize that vocational rehabilitation services, when delivered soon after injury and integrated into the medical rehabilitation plan, contribute to better employment outcomes.

Study: Student debt may hurt chances at full-time employment
A recently published study led by The University of Texas at Arlington says that student debt may hurt students' chances of securing full-time employment due to added pressure in their job search.

Kessler survey shows education paves the way to employment for youth with disabilities
The 2020 survey collected a wealth of information, including details of college majors and occupations, finding that students with disabilities were more likely to pursue career paths focused on helping people, and less likely to choose STEM majors, or to work in STEM disciplines.

Ethnic minorities' employment prospects lag behind white majority
The employment prospects of some ethnic minorities in the UK have improved since the 1970s but still lag behind the white majority because of 'persistent racism', a major new study says.

Promoting temporary contracts fails to have the desired effect of increasing employment
A study by the UPV/EHU and University of Cambridge explores the actual effect of the labour reforms applied between 1988 and 2012 in countries throughout Europe.

Extra payments motivate sobriety and employment among people recovering from addiction
After a yearlong study of people with opioid dependence, Johns Hopkins Medicine researchers report evidence that adding $8 an hour to their paychecks may help those in recovery stay drug free longer, as well as encourage them to get and hold regular jobs.

Blacks' views on racism affect likelihood of self-employment
Working blacks who believe racism has a major impact on their lives are more likely to seek self-employment than those who feel less strongly about its effects, according to new research from Rice University.

Place-based tax incentives stimulate employment in remote regions
A place-based payroll tax incentive can be effective in stimulating employment in remote and underdeveloped regions, helping to address regional inequalities, according to a new UCL and University of Oslo study.

Read More: Employment News and Employment Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.