UC research: Women tend to run more sophisticated political campaigns

March 18, 2020

Women run more sophisticated campaigns for office than men, says David Niven, a leading political researcher and associate professor of political science at the University of Cincinnati.

In research accepted for publication in the upcoming June issue of Political Research Quarterly, Niven analyzed 1,351 candidate responses to detailed questionnaires provided by the League of Women Voters in races across the nation in 2016. Those races ranged from local school boards and city councils all the way up to the U.S. Senate.

What he and his graduate students found was that women tend to run more sophisticated campaigns even when the odds are against them.

Niven's study reinforces the importance of pursuing research that highlights inclusion and prepares the next generation of leaders, one of the primary goals of Next Lives Here, UC's strategic direction.

According to Niven, "Women tend to take the prospect of a political campaign more seriously, and their campaigns reflect that. Even when a woman is running in a difficult district, she is likely to make a serious effort." By contrast, Niven said, "Men will run for office at the drop of a hat. In long shot circumstances, men's campaigns tend to be very amateurish."

Niven's measure of campaign sophistication is based on how many details candidates provided in their responses. Niven found that more successful candidates tended to answer questions with general, thematic responses, while less successful candidates wallowed in specifics.

As an example, Niven pointed to campaigns in Texas where one of the issues candidates faced was traffic congestion. "One woman who won her race spoke generally about her goals and the shared reality that 'we all sit in traffic together.' One unsuccessful male candidate got himself trapped in the confines of the questions and went into great detail, including discussing his hope for developing moving sidewalks like on the Jetsons."

"Overall, we found that women candidates are less likely to get caught up in details that, quite frankly, can lose votes and get in the way of the candidate's message."

Niven says it's not surprising that pundits who are reviewing Sen. Elizabeth Warren's campaign for president are saying that she ran a very smart campaign, and yet she didn't win any states.

Senator Elizabeth Warren with a group of African-American students on the campaign trail

Sen. Elizabeth Warren on the campaign trail for the 2020 presidential election. Photo: senate.gov/newsroom

"The bottom line here is that women run more sophisticated campaigns in general, but that doesn't mean they are rewarded commensurately by the voters."

Niven is continuing his analysis of the League of Women Voter guides from the 2018 midterm elections and will also analyze the guides and outcomes from the 2020 elections. Working with Niven on this soon-to-be-published research were graduate students Alexis Straka and Anwar Mhajne.

University of Cincinnati

Related Associate Professor Articles from Brightsurf:

Children associate white, but not black, men with 'brilliant' stereotype, new study finds
The stereotype that associates being 'brilliant' with white men more than White women is shared by children regardless of their own race, finds a team of psychology researchers.

UM professor co-authors report on the use of biotechnology in forests
University of Montana Professor Diana Six is one of 12 authors of a new report that addresses the potential for biotechnology to provide solutions for protecting forest trees from insect and pathogen outbreaks, which are increasing because of climate change and expanded global trade.

New nurses with bachelor's degrees feel better prepared than nurses with associate degrees
Nurses with bachelor's degrees report being very prepared in more quality and safety measures than do their peers with associate degrees, finds a new study by researchers at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing.

USU Executive Associate Dean Lisa Berreau named AAAS Fellow
A respective inorganic chemist, Utah State University professor Lisa Berreau, named an AAAS Fellow, leads an active research program, which includes mentorship of graduate and undergraduate students.

OU professor recognized by AAAS as new fellow
Michael Kaspari, a University of Oklahoma biology professor, has been named a Fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science for innovative studies linking biogeochemistry to the geography of ecological communities.

New international recognition for professor Federico Rosei
Professor Federico Rosei, who is also the director of the INRS Énergie Matériaux Télécommunications Research Center, has been elected a member of the World Academy of Art and Science for his outstanding contribution to scientific research and technological innovation in the synthesis and characterization of multifunctional materials and their integration in devices.

QUT professor honored with prestigious award
A QUT professor has become the first Australian since Professor Ian Frazer to receive the prestigious West Lake Friendship award.

University of Tennessee extension Associate Dean named ASABE fellow
Dr. Robert Burns, P.E., Associate Dean, UT Extension, has been named to the Class of Fellows with the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers (ASABE).

Do think-tanks matter? A UBC professor says 'think again'
Carey Doberstein, an assistant professor of political science at UBC's Okanagan campus, recently published an experimental study of public sector workers and determined that many give a written report or study purported to be from a university more credibility than one from a think-tank or advocacy group.

India to become second EMBC Associate Member State
The Government of the Republic of India, EMBO and its intergovernmental funding body, the European Molecular Biology Conference, have signed a Cooperation Agreement to strengthen scientific interaction and collaborative research between India and Europe.

Read More: Associate Professor News and Associate Professor Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.