Design Could Improve Highway Guardrail Safety

March 29, 1999

MADISON -The guardrails along America's highways haven't changed much since the 1960s, when the familiar W-shaped steel beam began reassuringly bordering the dangerous twists and turns.

Yet that reassurance has taken a hit recently, with evidence that traditional guardrail designs fail to protect some vehicle classes such as sport utility vehicles and four-wheel-drive trucks.

A University of Wisconsin-Madison engineer has developed a potentially safer replacement made from composite materials. The unique design made from glass fiber-reinforced polymers is meant to better "capture" the wide range of vehicles on the market, from hulking 4-by-4s to the tiniest compact cars.

After years of perfecting the design through computer simulation, civil engineer Lawrence Bank has just run his prototype gray beams through a battery of stress tests in the laboratory. So far, Bank says they exhibit their intended qualities of better strength and flexibility.

The beams are scheduled this spring for full-scale automobile crash tests, a key step for Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) endorsement.

"This is a perfect application for this type of material," says Bank. "Our emphasis has been on a lighter, more durable and rust-proof alternative to steel."

Bank and co-inventor Russell Gentry have a patent pending on the beam's unique geometry, which helps solve one of the major problems with current guardrails. Unlike the narrow depression of W beams, Bank's guardrails have a much wider "capture area" where the bumper impacts in an automobile crash. The capture area essentially helps control the vehicle, keeping it from climbing over or being forced under the guardrail.

That's a limitation with traditional guardrails. In October 1998, the FHWA banned any further installations of two of the most common metal guardrails, when crash tests showed they caused pickup trucks to flip over on impact. Safety experts now advise drivers of pickups and SUVs to use caution on bridges and sharp curves.

Bank says the problem is that while vehicles on the road have changed in the past 30 years, guardrails are from a time when car frames were more universal. Bumpers of trucks and SUVs run higher than the "capture area" of the rails, making them more likely to climb up and over the beams.

"We're hoping our design might be at the right place at the right time," Bank says.

"The crux of our patent is in how we make the composite fail in a very progressive fashion," he says. "These beams are designed to be pushed back three feet and still have their tensile capacity and connectivity."

The beams, made up of a series of rectangular cavities, break one layer at a time rather than all at once. Bank says the design absorbs more energy before failing, which can lessen the severity of impact.

Since the material is lighter, Banks says the beams can be produced in 25-foot sections that are twice as long as typical steel beams. Bolts for traditional beams would be replaced by a connecting rod and pin system, making installation faster and cheaper.

Cost may be an issue, Banks adds, because fiberglass composites run about $8 per foot compared to $4 per foot for steel. But add installation costs and Bank says traditional guardrails approach $15 - $20 per foot. With the savings in installation costs, Bank estimates that his design will be competitive.

Drivers probably give guardrails little thought, unless they're negotiating a hairpin curve or passing a steep drop-off. But about 15,000 Americans die each year after their vehicles careen off the road, the FWHA reports, making roadside rails a crucial part of highway safety.

The design work and creation of prototypes was supported by a Phase 1 grant from the Small Business Innovative Research program, a Department of Commerce initiative to promote university technology transfer. Small business partners include the Pennsylvania firms Creative Pultrusions and Technology Development Associates.
-- Brian Mattmiller, 608-262-9772

NOTE TO PHOTO EDITORS: High-resolution images of the new guardrails and engineer Lawrence Bank are available for downloading at:

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Related Composite Materials Articles from Brightsurf:

New composite material revs up pursuit of advanced electric vehicles
Scientists at Oak Ridge National Laboratory used new techniques to create a composite that increases the electrical current capacity of copper wires, providing a new material that can be scaled for use in ultra-efficient, power-dense electric vehicle traction motors.

Analyzing pros and cons of two composite manufacturing methods
Airplane wings and wind turbine blades are typically created using bulk polymerization in composite manufacturing facilities.

Visualization of functional components to characterize optimal composite electrodes
Researchers have developed a visualization method that will determine the distribution of components in battery electrodes using atomic force microscopy.

Study suggests polymer composite could serve as lighter, non-toxic radiation shielding
A new study suggests that a polymer compound embedded with bismuth trioxide particles holds tremendous potential for replacing conventional radiation shielding materials, such as lead.

Scientists develop stable luminescent composite material based on perovskite nanocrystals
An international team of scientists that includes researchers from ITMO University has developed a new composite material based on perovskite nanocrystals for the purpose of creating miniature light sources with improved output capacity.

Composite metal foams take the heat, move closer to widespread applications
Engineering researchers have demonstrated that composite metal foams (CMFs) can pass so-called 'simulated pool fire testing' with flying colors, moving the material closer to use in applications such as packaging and transportation of hazardous materials.

Using holograms helps in studying the quality of composite materials
Composite materials have a complicated structure and specified mechanical or physical properties.

Scientists develop a composite membrane for long-life zinc-based flow batteries
Researchers led by Profs. LI Xianfeng from the Dalian Institute of Chemical Physics (DICP) of the Chinese Academy of Sciences recently developed a composite membraneĀ for long-life zinc-based flow batteries.

An early warning system for damage in composite materials
A team at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has developed a tool to monitor changes in widely used composite materials known as fiber reinforced polymers (FRPs), which can be found in everything from aerospace and infrastructure to wind turbines.

Novel composite antimicrobial film could take a bite out of foodborne illnesses
A novel composite film -- created by the bonding of an antimicrobial layer to conventional, clear polyethylene plastic typically used to vacuum-package foods such as meat and fish -- could help to decrease foodborne illness outbreaks, according to researchers in Penn State's College of Agricultural Sciences.

Read More: Composite Materials News and Composite Materials Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to