Hidden quota for women in top management: UMD study

April 08, 2015

COLLEGE PARK, Md. - Companies work fairly hard to place one woman -- but only one -- in a top management position, according to research by Cristian Desző, an associate professor at the Robert H. Smith School of Business, and two co-authors. The article found evidence of a "quota" effect: Once a company had appointed one woman to a top-tier job, the chances of a second woman landing an elite position at the same firm drop substantially -- by about 50 percent, in fact.

The study's design did not allow a conclusion about whether the quota was the result of conscious discrimination or subconscious thinking. Desző and his co-authors, David Gaddis Ross and Jose Uribe, of Columbia Business School, looked at the top officers at 1,500 firms from 1991 to 2011. Drawing on data from a Standard and Poor's database, supplemented with other sources, they looked at the top five most highly compensated managers at those companies.

Diversifying top management has become a significant priority for businesses -- or, at least, it gets talked about a lot. While women make up nearly half of the workforce, 8.7 percent of top managers were women in 2011, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, up a bit from 5.8 percent who held such positions in 2000.

One possibility that the authors explored was that the hiring of one woman would lead to a snowball effect at a given company. "In fact, what we find is exactly the opposite," Desző says. "Once they had appointed one woman, the men seem to have said, 'We have done our job.'" This may be because the men feel that such an appointment already puts them ahead of most companies (which is true).

Or they may feel that there are diminishing returns to hiring more women: One is enough to attract media attention, represent the company at "diversity" events, and satisfy activists pressuring the company. Or the men may perceive the first, pathbreaking women as off-the-charts exceptional, and subsequent female employees do not measure up, somehow.

In any case, one implication of the study is that such activists interested in promoting the presence of women in executive suites -- whether those activists are board members, investors, or non-profit watchdogs -- can't move on from a given company after one woman is hired, Dezső says: "They need to keep up the pressure or even apply more pressure."

The quota effect was especially strong when a woman was hired into a high-paid professional position--say, head of human resources. Those positions hold less power than "line positions," like division heads. In other words, companies that promote a woman into a top professional job were especially unlikely to appoint another female executive.

Desző and his colleagues used mathematical simulations to study the distribution of top female executives across the companies in their sample. If hiring one women eased the path for others, women should cluster together; if hiring a woman had no effect on future hires, you'd see a random distribution of female executives. But the authors found that the data best reflected a third possibility: Top female executives were isolated, repelling one another.

The authors considered and rejected the possibility of a "queen bee" effect -- the idea that the first executive-level women hired would perceive other women as rivals, and work against hiring more. But if that were true, the authors said, the strongest evidence would be seen at those few companies with a female CEO (since a female CEO would have more say over executive appointments than other female executives would). But in fact, companies with female CEO's did slightly better at hiring a second woman than companies with a woman in a different senior position.

The data suggest that hiring dynamics are different at the very elite ranks of firms than they are lower down. Other studies, for instance, have found that the presence of female middle managers leads to more hiring of women. But at the most rarified, highly paid levels of corporations, male managers may perceive more of a zero-sum environment. And so they protect their turf.
-end-
"Is There an Implicit Quota on Women in Top Management? A Large-Sample Statistical Analysis," by Cristian L. Dezső, David Gaddis Ross, and Jose Uribe, is forthcoming in Strategic Management Journal.

University of Maryland

Related Data Articles from Brightsurf:

Keep the data coming
A continuous data supply ensures data-intensive simulations can run at maximum speed.

Astronomers are bulging with data
For the first time, over 250 million stars in our galaxy's bulge have been surveyed in near-ultraviolet, optical, and near-infrared light, opening the door for astronomers to reexamine key questions about the Milky Way's formation and history.

Novel method for measuring spatial dependencies turns less data into more data
Researcher makes 'little data' act big through, the application of mathematical techniques normally used for time-series, to spatial processes.

Ups and downs in COVID-19 data may be caused by data reporting practices
As data accumulates on COVID-19 cases and deaths, researchers have observed patterns of peaks and valleys that repeat on a near-weekly basis.

Data centers use less energy than you think
Using the most detailed model to date of global data center energy use, researchers found that massive efficiency gains by data centers have kept energy use roughly flat over the past decade.

Storing data in music
Researchers at ETH Zurich have developed a technique for embedding data in music and transmitting it to a smartphone.

Life data economics: calling for new models to assess the value of human data
After the collapse of the blockchain bubble a number of research organisations are developing platforms to enable individual ownership of life data and establish the data valuation and pricing models.

Geoscience data group urges all scientific disciplines to make data open and accessible
Institutions, science funders, data repositories, publishers, researchers and scientific societies from all scientific disciplines must work together to ensure all scientific data are easy to find, access and use, according to a new commentary in Nature by members of the Enabling FAIR Data Steering Committee.

Democratizing data science
MIT researchers are hoping to advance the democratization of data science with a new tool for nonstatisticians that automatically generates models for analyzing raw data.

Getting the most out of atmospheric data analysis
An international team including researchers from Kanazawa University used a new approach to analyze an atmospheric data set spanning 18 years for the investigation of new-particle formation.

Read More: Data News and Data Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.