Rice and Michigan State build database on State Supreme Courts

April 28, 2005

For political scientists and other scholars hungering for information on state supreme court decisions, Rice University's and Michigan State University's State Supreme Court Data Project is a free all-you-can-eat buffet.

The project boasts an online analysis of every state supreme court case heard from 1995 through 1998 in all 50 states. Each of the more than 30,000 cases in the database has been coded to facilitate an extensive variety of searches, such as biographical information about a judge, the judge's vote in a case, the outcome of a case, legal issues raised and characteristics of litigants.

"The states have an awesome responsibility for resolving the vast majority of the nation's legal disputes," said Paul Brace, the Clarence L. Carter Professor of Political Science at Rice and principal investigator for the project. "Unfortunately, our knowledge of state courts, including courts of last resort, is quite limited."

With nearly $1 million in grants from the National Science Foundation, Brace and co-principal investigator Melinda Gann Hall at Michigan State spent the past six years collecting and coding data on state supreme courts to meet the need for such pivotal details.

State courts decide more than 99 percent of the litigation in the U.S., interpreting not only state laws but also federal laws. "With increasing state discretion over matters of public policy, the power of state courts should be increasing, making studies of these institutions particularly timely," Brace said. "Without understanding the nature of these institutions and the states, we are left with a very incomplete understanding of American politics."

Brace noted that unlike the unique U.S. Supreme Court, whose justices are appointed for life and don't have to worry about decisions being reversed, most state supreme court judges are elected and linked directly with voters and public opinion.

"Whether or not judges are elected has an impact on the kinds of decisions they make," Brace said. Using the State Supreme Court Data Project, scholars can study the effects of judicial elections on judicial behavior by comparing the dockets of appointed versus elected supreme courts, how the composition of a court reflects a state's liberal or conservative tendencies and how public opinion affects judicial decisions.

Brace and Hall trained and employed undergraduate and graduate students at Rice and Michigan State to do the coding for the project, which entails more than 200 details for each case. One of the biggest challenges during the project's early phase was how to develop a template that systematized the collection of data to reduce mistakes. "Inter-coder reliability was incredibly high," Brace said, noting that the software included hint buttons to guide coders through the cases and help them look at the information they needed to enter in the database. The data entered by coders on the software template went straight into a spreadsheet, which avoided errors that might have resulted from copying data manually from paper.

Biographical information on more than 400 state supreme court judges is contained in the database, and although the database ends with court cases from 1998, Brace is hopeful that private funding will support extension of the project on an ongoing basis. "This would allow longitudinal studies of how state supreme courts change over time," he said.

"We want this to be a permanent data archive that can serve as infrastructure for addressing fundamental questions about law and politics," Brace said. "These data will be of interest not only to academicians, but also to government officials, practicing attorneys and concerned citizens interested in the activities of the states' highest courts."
-end-
To view the State Supreme Court Data Project, go to http://www.ruf.rice.edu/~pbrace/statecourt/index.html.

Rice University

Related Rice Articles from Brightsurf:

C4 rice's first wobbly steps towards reality
An international long-term research collaboration aimed at creating high yielding and water use efficient rice varieties, has successfully installed part of the photosynthetic machinery from maize into rice.

Rice has many fathers but only two mothers
University of Queensland scientists studied more than 3000 rice genotypes and found diversity was inherited through two maternal genomes identified in all rice varieties.

Rice rolls out next-gen nanocars
Rice University researchers continue to advance the science of single-molecule machines with a new lineup of nanocars, in anticipation of the next international Nanocar Race in 2022.

3D camera earns its stripes at Rice
The Hyperspectral Stripe Projector captures spectroscopic and 3D imaging data for applications like machine vision, crop monitoring, self-driving cars and corrosion detection.

Climate change could increase rice yields
Research reveals how rice ratooning practices can help Japanese farmers increase rice yields.

Breeding new rice varieties will help farmers in Asia
New research shows enormous potential for developing improved short-duration rice varieties.

High-protein rice brings value, nutrition
A new advanced line of rice, with higher yield, is ready for final field testing prior to release.

Rice plants engineered to be better at photosynthesis make more rice
A new bioengineering approach for boosting photosynthesis in rice plants could increase grain yield by up to 27 percent, according to a study publishing January 10, 2019 in the journal Molecular Plant.

Can rice filter water from ag fields?
While it's an important part of our diets, new research shows that rice plants can be used in a different way, too: to clean runoff from farms before it gets into rivers, lakes, and streams.

Rice plants evolve to adapt to flooding
Although water is essential for plant growth, excessive amounts can waterlog and kill a plant.

Read More: Rice News and Rice Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.