When cookies catch the cooties

April 30, 2007

DURHAM, N.C. -- Of all the things companies worry about when selling food products, catching "cooties" is probably not high on the list. But new research suggests it should be.

Products such as lard and feminine napkins evoke feelings of disgust that can reduce the appeal of other products they may inadvertently come in contact with in shoppers' grocery carts or on store shelves, according to researchers at Duke University and Arizona State University. The researchers suggest that companies may want to reconsider their packaging and shelf positioning strategies in order to safeguard their brands from offending products.

The researchers say food items sold in clear packaging are especially vulnerable to the effects of "product contagion," the phenomenon by which one product's negative properties can be transferred to another.

The research was conducted by Gavan Fitzsimons, a professor of marketing and psychology at Duke's Fuqua School of Business, and Andrea Morales, an assistant professor of marketing at Arizona State's W.P. Carey School of Business. The findings will appear in the May 2007 Journal of Marketing Research.

Other ordinary products that can evoke feelings of disgust in consumers include trash bags, cat litter, diapers, cigarettes, mayonnaise and shortening. "Because these products are so common, consumers are likely to experience feelings of disgust on routine shopping trips," Fitzsimons said.

Fitzsimons and Morales sought to understand how "disgusting" products can affect consumers' opinions of other products in their grocery carts. They performed a series of experiments in which participants observed food products placed close to or touching a distasteful product.

In all cases, products that touched or rested against disgusting products became less appealing than products that were at least an inch away from the offending products. The effect was also enduring. Participants asked more than an hour after observing the products how much they wanted to try a cookie were less likely to want it if the package of cookies had been in contact with a package of feminine napkins.

The researchers say this behavior is not necessarily irrational, as it likely derives from basic instincts that caution humans against eating foods that have come in contact with insects or other sources of germs.

"Our experiments demonstrated quite clearly that caution about eating contaminated food is simply misapplied to contexts where real contamination is not possible," Morales said.

Fitzsimons and Morales identified product packaging as one factor that can prevent product contagion. Opaque packaging was seen as a sufficient barrier to prevent the spread of unpleasant qualities, while products in transparent packaging remained susceptible to the negative qualities of their neighbors in the shopping cart.

In one experiment, participants viewed packages of rice cakes -- some wrapped in transparent packaging and some in opaque paper carrying a "rice cakes" label --that were touching a container of lard. The rice cakes in the clear packaging were later estimated to have a higher fat content than those in the opaque packaging.

"The product packaging and positioning led the participants to view the rice cakes as taking on fat content from the lard," Morales said.

"Prior marketing research on packaging has held that clear packaging helps sell products because it allows customers to visualize what they are buying," Fitzsimons said. "Based on this research, I would caution marketers that they need to be attuned to not only what is inside their packaging but also to what is around a product that could negatively affect its sales."

Fitzsimons and Morales point to multiple opportunities for products to mingle in grocery carts or on store shelves, where products such as lard and baking goods, diapers and baby food, and mayonnaise and soup are often found together.
-end-


Duke University

Related Marketing Articles from Brightsurf:

How to maximize the potential of marketing agility
Marketing agility is best suited for those marketing decisions where the market response is highly unpredictable, the decision parameters can be broken down into smaller components, and when it is feasible to get quick customer feedback, and when there is less dependence on third parties for executing the marketing activity.

Covert tobacco industry marketing tactics exposed by former employees
Tobacco companies use covert marketing tactics and exploit loopholes in Australian tobacco control laws to promote their products despite current tobacco advertising bans, finds new research from University of Sydney and Cancer Council NSW.

The three strategic priorities of marketing excellence
Investors value marketing excellence more highly than they value strategies based on market orientation and marketing capabilities.

How nonprofits can boost donations using the marketing mix
Nonprofits may better meet their missions by learning to effectively employ the entirety of the marketing mix to attract individuals to available donation opportunities.

Marketing researchers identify the three most powerful drivers of effective crowdfunding
While the concept of crowdfunding is still in its early phases of development, a group of marketing researchers have conducted a study that reveals the most powerful drivers behind effective crowdfunding campaigns.

Alcohol marketing and underage drinking
A new study by a research team including scientists from the Prevention Research Center of the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation provides a systematic review of research that examines relationships between exposure to alcohol marketing and alcohol use behaviors among adolescents and young adults.

Scholars explore role of digital environments in international marketing
Journal of International Marketing launched its 2020 volume with a special issue examining new implications of the digital environment related to the study of international marketing.

Study: Pharmaceutical companies marketing stimulants to physicians
Results of a new study show that a large number of physicians in the US may have received marketing payments from pharmaceutical companies that produce stimulant medications.

Automated text analysis: The next frontier of marketing innovation
The volumes of text data generated in the marketplace can be valuable in generating marketing insights using the newest text analysis methods and technologies.

Global study reveals most popular marketing metrics
Satisfaction is the most popular metric for marketing decisions around the world, according to a new study from the University of Technology Sydney.

Read More: Marketing News and Marketing Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.