Food for thought: Ketogenic diets reduce athletes' anaerobic performanceMay 01, 2018
ST. LOUIS -- Athletes who turn to ketogenic diets to help their performance in high-intensity, short duration sports may want to think again, according to new research from Saint Louis University.
In a small study, Edward Weiss, Ph.D., associate professor of nutrition and dietetics at Saint Louis University, together with SLU graduate students Kym Wroble, R.D. and Morgan Trott, R.D., examined the exercise performance of 16 men and women after following either a low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet or a high-carbohydrate diet for four days. His team then tested the anaerobic exercise performance of the participants.
The research team found that after following the ketogenic diet, the participants did not perform as well at the exercise tasks.
"In popular discussions, the term 'ketogenic diet' often is used as a broader term for low carb diets, including Atkins," Weiss said. "However, the language is often confused. People often think low carb and high protein. This is related, but different, as protein can only be at normal levels for a true ketogenic diet.
"The objective of a ketogenic diet is to starve the body of carbohydrate. If there is too much protein in the diet, the body will use the protein to make carbohydrates, which defeats the purpose. When the body is sufficiently deprived of carbohydrate, it manufactures ketone bodies as an alternate fuel. It's an emergency backup system that allows us to survive when we are at risk of starvation. But, it has side effects.
"Right now in the general public, it's touted for weight loss. Some studies have shown that it is effective for weight loss. I worry, though, that this may be a lot of smoke and mirrors. A typical diet is 60 percent carbohydrate. So, if you limit carbs, you might find yourself just not eating that much. If you eliminate most food options, you may just be losing weight because you are cutting calories."
The study has implications both for those who turn to ketogenic diets for weight loss and for athletes who aim to improve their performance.
"The energy metabolism system that's affected is anaerobic. Watching the summer Olympics, the 100 meter sprint and the triple jump depend on this system. You might say that this doesn't relate to me. But for someone with low fitness, they use this same metabolism to get up the stairs. Everyday people use this kind of metabolism without realizing it. This study shows that this energy system is compromised by this type of diet."
Weiss has one caveat.
"There are populations that a ketogenic diet may benefit," Weiss said. "For example, patients who have epilepsy benefit from this diet. For those with abnormal cell metabolism that causes seizures, causing cells to feed on ketones instead can be helpful."
The bottom line?
"Short-term low carbohydrate, ketogenic diets reduce exercise performance in activities that are heavily dependent on anaerobic energy systems," Weiss reports. "These findings have clear performance implications for athletes, especially for high-intensity, short duration activities and sports.
"This diet is especially hot among people who are trying to optimize their health. What this study tells me is that unless there are compelling reasons for following a low-carb diet, athletes should be advised to avoid these diets."
Saint Louis University
Related Weight Loss Articles:
A new study, published in the journal Social Science and Medicine, has shown that selling rewards programmes to participants entering a weight loss programme is a low cost strategy to increase both the magnitude and duration of weight loss.
Alternate day fasting regimens have increased in popularity because some patients find it difficult to adhere to a conventional weight-loss diet.
School bullies and their victims are more obsessed with weight-loss than anyone else, according to new research by the University of Warwick.
Talk to a woman in menopause and you're likely to hear complaints about hot flashes and an inability to lose weight, especially belly fat.
Weight loss has a significant and prolonged positive impact on psoriasis symptoms and quality of life.
Carrying extra weight increases a person's risk that a benign blood disorder will develop into multiple myeloma, a blood cancer.
Gastric bypass surgery is more effective for weight loss and long-term weight maintenance than are other surgical procedures and non-surgical treatment, according to a study led by researchers at Duke Health and the Durham VA Medical Center.
Severely obese patients undergoing weight loss surgery are more likely to have increased fracture risks both before and after the surgical procedure compared to obese and non-obese people people who don't need surgery, finds a large study published by The BMJ this week.
New research, led by the University of Southampton, has found that an online behavioural counselling tool is effective at helping people lose weight.
In an analysis that included nearly 30,000 overweight or obese adults, compared with placebo, orlistat, lorcaserin, naltrexone-bupropion, phentermine-topiramate, and liraglutide were each associated with achieving at least 5 percent weight loss at 52 weeks, and phentermine-topiramate and liraglutide were associated with the highest odds of achieving at least 5 percent weight loss, according to a study appearing in the June 14 issue of JAMA.
Related Weight Loss Reading:
Meal Prep Your Way to Weight Loss: 28 Days to a Fitter, Healthier You
by Nikki Sharp (Author)
A 28-day program for eating clean, featuring more than 100 healthy recipes with time-saving advance-prep methods, from the author of The 5-Day Real Food Detox
“An effective guide to help you achieve a healthier life and stop dieting once and for all.”—Mark Hyman, M.D., #1 New York Times bestselling author of Food: What the Heck Should I Eat?
LOSE WEIGHT IN JUST FOUR WEEKS
Any successful goal starts with a plan. And diet and fitness guru Nikki Sharp knows all about planning. The former model, Instagram star, and... View Details
The Secrets to Ultimate Weight Loss: A revolutionary approach to conquer cravings, overcome food addiction, and lose weight without going hungry
by Chef AJ (Author), Glen Merzer (Author)
Chef AJ’s larger than life personality will smooth the path to the diet you must follow to enjoy the health and happiness you deserve. Her personal and professional experiences have earned her the right to be considered the world expert on “Making the Change.”—John McDougall, MD, cofounder of the McDougall Program
In her new book, plant-based diet expert Chef AJ provides you with not only tips and techniques to begin your weight-loss journey but also the secrets to tasty homemade dishes that will fill you up without adding on the pounds.
Chef AJ is here to... View Details
90 DAYS Exercise & Diet Journal: Daily Food and Weight Loss Diary
by Get Fit Notebooks (Author)
Do you want convenience and speedy results? 90 DAYS Excercise & Diet Journal is your companion during your 90 day diet. It's your motivating planner for a successful change in diet and a daily companion on the journey to more health!
For daily filling out and documentation of nutrition and exercise. "How I feel" can also be crossed off on all daily pages for additional motivation. Perfect for planning and preparing your own weekly plans and recording desired progress.
Measure Your Body
One major benefit of this diet journal are the divider pages for recording the... View Details
The Dash Diet Weight Loss Solution: 2 Weeks to Drop Pounds, Boost Metabolism, and Get Healthy
by Marla Heller (Author)
THE NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER--BASED ON THE DIET RANKED "#1 BEST DIET OVERALL" BY US NEWS & WORLD REPORT--FOR 8 YEARS IN A ROW!The DASH diet isn't just for healthy living anymore--now it's for healthy weight loss, too. Using the newest DASH diet research, bestselling author, foremost DASH dietitian and leading nutrition expert Marla Heller hascreated the most effective diet for quick-and lasting-weight loss. This is the only book to bring you the latest updates for the DASH diet, integrated with the latest weight loss research, which work synergistically to maximize results.... View Details
21-Day Weight Loss Kickstart: Boost Metabolism, Lower Cholesterol, and Dramatically Improve Your Health
by Neal D Barnard (Author)
For years, Dr. Neal D. Barnard has been at the forefront of cutting-edge research on what it really takes to lose weight and restore the body to optimal health. Now, with his proven, successful program, in just three short weeks you'll get fast results-drop pounds, lower cholesterol and blood pressure, improve blood sugar, and more. With Dr. Barnard's advice on how to easily start a plant-based diet, you'll learn the secrets to reprogramming your body quickly:
· Appetite reduction: Strategically choose the right foods to naturally and easily tame your... View Details
Lose Weight by Eating: Detox Week: Twice the Weight Loss in Half the Time with 130 Recipes for a Crave-Worthy Cleanse
by Audrey Johns (Author)
Lose 10 pounds in 7 days—the author of the popular book and blog Lose Weight by Eating offers multiple plan options and 130 delicious, real-food recipes in this illustrated guide to help you get healthy, eat better, and reach (and maintain) your ideal weight.
Dietary detoxes shouldn’t leave you hungry, deprived, and desperate to binge on the foods you’ve been trying to avoid. Instead, Audrey Johns has designed a practical, proven detox plan that encourages you to eat for your cravings. She took naughty recipes and made them over so nice that they’re actually... View Details
100 MORE Days of Weight Loss Day-by-Day Journal: For Recording Lesson Assignments and Insights
by Linda Spangle (Author)
Award winning author of Life is Hard, Food is Easy This journal is the perfect guide to use with Linda Spangle's daily motivator book, 100 MORE Days of Weight Loss. With easy fill-in-the-blank pages, you can track your progress as well as record your ideas and insights. Each journal page provides space for completing the assignments at the end of a daily lesson, reinforcing the powerful learning and understanding that takes place with this book. This journal used along with the book 100 MORE Days of Weight Loss... View Details
The Tapping Solution for Weight Loss & Body Confidence: A Woman's Guide to Stressing Less, Weighing Less, and Loving More
by Jessica Ortner (Author), Christiane Northrup M.D. (Foreword)
Many women live their lives believing that they can’t ask for what they want until they change something they’re unhappy with. No promotion until they get new skills. No relationship until they establish their career. No fulfillment until they find love. One of the most common conditions women place on themselves is weight loss—no love until they lose weight, no sex until they lose weight, no happiness until they lose weight. But Jessica Ortner, co-producer of the highly successful documentary on meridian tapping, The Tapping Solution, offers women a better choice. Why not lose the... View Details
A Course in Weight Loss: 21 Spiritual Lessons for Surrendering Your Weight Forever
by Marianne Williamson (Author)
"If your 'weighty thinking' does not change, then even if you lose weight you'll retain an overwhelming subconscious urge to gain it back. It's less important how quickly you lose weight, and more important how holistically you lose weight; you want your mind, your emotions, and your body to all 'lose weight.' Weight that disappears from your body but not from your soul is simply recycling outward for a while
but is almost certain to return. It's self-defeating, therefore, to struggle to drop excess weight unless