'Institution shocks' spotlight effects of changing economic institutions

May 01, 2018

In recent years economists have joined historians and others in thinking that institutions, like governments, markets, and firms, are the key to understanding how economies work. From a research standpoint, the challenge is how to study what happens when institutions change.

"When it comes to studying how a change in economic institutions will affect the workings of the economy, history has refused to perform the right experiments," says economist Samuel Bowles of the Santa Fe Institute, articulating the centuries-old research challenge.

There are a limited number of game-changing events, like the Bolshevik Revolution replacing capitalism by centralized economic planning, or the emancipation of U.S. slaves. And as these examples suggest, when economic institutions do change, it is usually because much else has changed too, making it difficult to isolate the real causal effects of the institutional changes per se.

With Daniele Girardi of the University of Massachusetts, Bowles hit upon what is as close to a natural experiment on society-wide institutional changes as could be imagined. Collecting new data, the researchers studied how the electoral victory of socialist Salvador Allende in Chile on September 4, 1970, affected the value of firms on the Santiago Stock Market. The outcome was almost entirely unanticipated -- especially by the wealthy.

The morning after the election, Chilean businesses woke up to an entirely new economic environment, with across-the-board nationalizations of firms promised by the new government. The value of shares fell by half.

U.S. National Security Adviser Henry Kissinger phoned President Richard Nixon on September 12, 1970.

"The big problem today is Chile," said Kissinger.

Nixon responded: "Their stock market went to hell."

A second "institution shock" occurred three years later, when the Chilean armed forces overthrew the constitutional government, replacing Allende with business-friendly, autocratic rule under Augusto Pinochet. The stock market skyrocketed, increasing in value over 80 percent in a single trading day.

"These effects are gigantic compared to existing studies, that have looked at surprise electoral victories of Democrats or Republicans in the U.S. and Labor vs Conservatives in the UK," Girardi explains. "The difference is that in Chile the capitalist economic system itself was on the table."

In another newly released paper, Girardi found that across hundreds of close elections in which party economic platform differences were much less than in the Chilean case, a left of center victory decreases stock market values by 5 to 10 percent.

Simon DeDeo (Carnegie Mellon University), who uses computational linguistic methods to study institutional change in the past, remarks: "People rarely tell us what they really think. What's amazing here is how much a few pages of old stock market listings can reveal: the fears of the bourgeois elite, and their taste for dictatorship." DeDeo was not involved in the current study.

Bowles says the takeaway message is that we "cannot understand the economy through a lens that is limited to economics; we need to bring in law, politics, history, and the other disciplines."

Santa Fe Institute

Related Stock Market Articles from Brightsurf:

AI stock trading experiment beats market in simulation
Researchers in Italy have melded the emerging science of convolutional neural networks with deep learning -- a discipline within artificial intelligence -- to achieve a system of market forecasting with the potential for greater gains and fewer losses than previous attempts to use AI methods to manage stock portfolios.

New criteria for bank loans and stock exchange listings could protect ocean resources
Review of publicly available information from 2008-2017 found no bank loan to seafood companies that included sustainability criteria.

Spread-changing orders and deletions affect stock prices
In a new study published in EPJ B, Stephan Grimm and Thomas Guhr from Duisburg-Essen University in Germany compare the influences that three price-changing events have on these spread changes.

Taking stock of Indonesia's reef fishes
A research team estimated the natural stock of reef fishes from three regencies in the lesser Sunda-Banda Seascape in Indonesia to fill gaps in knowledge of species composition and biodiversity.

Understanding stock market returns: Which models fits best?
A comparison of two models for stock market prediction shows clear differences in their accuracy, depending on the length of the forecasting period.

Stock market shows greater reaction to forecasts by analysts with favorable surnames
Financial analysts whose surnames are perceived as favorable elicit stronger market reactions to their earnings forecasts, new research from Cass Business School has found.

Stock options worth more for women, senior managers, study finds
A novel new way of determining the value of employee stock options has yielded some surprising insights: Options granted to woman and senior managers are worth more because they hold them longer.

It's time for a hyper-crash, say multifractal analyses of the main stock market index
The near future of the global economy looks extremely bleak.

Carbon emissions will start to dictate stock prices
Companies that fail to curb their carbon output may eventually face the consequences of asset devaluation and stock price depreciation, according to a new study out of the University of Waterloo.

Innovation and speculation drive stock market bubble activity, according to new study
A group of data scientists conducted an in-depth analysis of major innovations and stock market bubbles from 1825 through 2000 and came away with novel takeaways of their own as they found some very distinctive patterns in the occurrence of bubbles over 175 years.

Read More: Stock Market News and Stock Market Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.