Better Right-Turn Warnings Needed On Tractor-Trailer Trucks

May 01, 1996

[Excerpts from "Pardon My Right Turn" by David N. Aurelio & Todd M. Newman, in ERGONOMICS IN DESIGN, Volume 5, Number 2, April 1997. Copyright 1997 by Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, P.O. Box 1369, Santa Monica, CA 90406-1369 USA; 310/394-1811, fax 310/394-2410, http://hfes.org. To obtain a copy of the entire article, which includes full references and illustrations, contact Lois Smith at hfes@compuserve.com or at the address above.]

Tractor-trailer trucks and automobiles have different sizes, weights and acceleration capabilities and sometimes form a hazardous combination on the nation's roads. But driving behind tractor-trailer trucks does have its advantages. It gives one the opportunity to read such captivating trailer tailgate messages as "How's My Driving?" and "Please Drive Safely." All kidding aside, driving behind and to the right of a tractor-trailer truck can be dangerous. When it makes a right-hand turn, it can hit and damage a car that is too close.

In this article, we are concerned with the design of truck warning signs that alert car drivers of trucks' wide right turns. These signs usually say "Caution - Wide Turns" or some variant. We are also concerned with the differences between the signs when there are no legal regulations governing their design. Over the past year or two, we have become aware of signs on the back of tractor-trailers alerting drivers to wide rights turns and have become intrigued with how many different signs there are and their merits. We therefore decided to study the signs to determine which we prefer from a human factors perspective.

Collecting Examples of Warning Signs

We evaluated the signs by taking pictures of them, ordering them according to various criteria, drawing conclusions about their effectiveness, and asking human factors researchers to evaluate them. While traveling to and from work over a two-week period, we photographed warning signs on the back of trucks parked at a truck stop on Interstate Route 95 near Boston. (Taking photos while driving behind trucks on highways or waiting for them at busy street intersections were not safe or time-efficient methods.)

Requirements for Signs

As part of our research, we spoke with various national trucking associations and federal agencies about these right-turn signs. We learned that the signs are voluntary and not regulated. A member of the staff of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration said that the agency considers for regulation signs that are reflective, self-illuminated, or concerning hazardous cargo. Personnel at the American Trucking Association and National Transportation Safety Board provided similar comments.

Although it was apparent that the developers of the 25 signs we photographed used considerable conscientious effort, each of the signs only partially follows general human factors guidelines for warnings. According to one guideline, "at a minimum, a warning should contain the following fundamental elements: signal word, hazard, consequences, instructions" (Sanders & McCormick, 1993, p. 683). ANSI standard Z535.2 states that a warning sign should contain a signal word, a text message, and a pictorial (American National Standards Institute, 1991). Although some of the signs included a signal word, none of them described in text the possible consequences of ignoring the warning (i.e., a collision). However, many of the signs did depict a collision in their sketches.

Creating an Improved Sign

After viewing our 25 pictures, the five human factors researchers stated that none represented the best possible warning sign. Instead, they pointed out sign elements that they believed would best communicate the collision hazard. Combining their most frequent responses, we created a list of elements of an improved warning sign. The researchers reviewed the list and concurred that it was reasonable.
-end-


Human Factors and Ergonomics Society

Related Driving Articles from Brightsurf:

Driving behavior less 'robotic' thanks to new Delft model
Researchers from TU Delft have now developed a new model that describes driving behaviour on the basis of one underlying 'human' principle: managing the risk below a threshold level.

Warming temperatures are driving arctic greening
As Arctic summers warm, Earth's northern landscapes are changing. Using satellite images to track global tundra ecosystems over decades, a new study found the region has become greener, as warmer air and soil temperatures lead to increased plant growth.

Software of autonomous driving systems
Researchers at TU Graz and AVL focus on software systems of autonomous driving systems.

Driving immunometabolism to control lung infection
When drugs to kill microbes are ineffective, host-directed therapy uses the body's own immune system to deal with the infection.

Representation of driving behavior as a statistical model
A joint research team from Toyohashi University of Technology has established a method to represent driving behaviors and their changes that differ among drivers in a single statistical model, taking into account the effect of various external factors such as road structure.

Improving the vision of self-driving vehicles
There may be a better way for autonomous vehicles to learn how to drive themselves: by watching humans.

Impaired driving -- even once the high wears off
McLean researchers have discovered that recreational marijuana use affects driving ability even when users are not intoxicated.

Self-driving microrobots
Most synthetic materials, including those in battery electrodes, polymer membranes, and catalysts, degrade over time because they don't have internal repair mechanisms.

AI to determine when to intervene with your driving
Can your AI agent judge when to talk to you while you are driving?

Cooperating may result in better self-driving experience
To better understand and predict the outcomes of the steering wheel control dilemma, contrary to many previous studies, in a paper published in IEEE/CAA Journal of Automatica Sinica, Dr.

Read More: Driving News and Driving Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.