Nav: Home

How migrants' traditional cuisines cost them calories

May 04, 2016

When migrants move, they often try to keep eating their native cuisine. But a new study from an MIT professor reveals an economic tension underneath this practice: Migrants who hang on to their old cuisines often pay more to eat, because they tend to move to places where their familiar foods are more expensive. In turn, poor migrants on tight budgets must reduce the amount of calories they can consume.

More specifically, the study finds that in India, the most adversely affected migrants face a "caloric tax" of 7.2 percent -- the quantity by which purchasing higher-priced ingredients lowers the intake of calories. And even in impoverished households, which appear more willing to adapt their diets out of necessity, there is still a 5.3 percent reduction in calories.

"Migrants continue to consume the foods that were popular in their origin states, after they moved," says David Atkin, an assistant professor in MIT's Department of Economics, who performed the research. "That's not surprising. What's surprising in the context of India is that they [migrants] are often on the edge of malnutrition and continuing to consume these foods even in circumstances where these foods are relatively expensive."

A paper detailing the study, "The Caloric Costs of Culture: Evidence from Indian Migrants," appears in the American Economic Review. Atkin is the sole author.

The North-South divide

To conduct the research, Atkin drew upon the 1983 and 1987-88 Indian National Sample Surveys (NSS), which recorded purchases of 169 food groups from 125,000 households, along with other data including migration information. About 6 percent of the households consisted of migrants who had moved from another part of India.

Among other things, Atkin's research revealed a distinct geographic pattern for India as a whole. Diet adaptation issues seem to pertain more strongly to people who have moved from the country's north to the south, and vice versa, rather than along an east-west axis.

"If you go north to south [in India] then you're moving from primarily wheat-consuming areas to rice-consuming areas, and the relative prices of those two mean these people can be quite adversely affected," Atkin explains. "Meanwhile, you could imagine moving east to west and not crossing similar barriers where the prices are relatively different."

The study also showed a gender effect at work. Households are less likely to adapt their cuisines to local preferences when the husband, rather than the wife, is a migrant.

"It seems to be driven by simple preferences," Atkin says. "The husband is demanding rice even though he's moved to an area of the country which typically consumes wheat, for example."

India defines an undernourished household as one consuming fewer than 2,400 calories per person per day in rural India and 2,100 calories per person per day in urban settings. (Rural residents in this calculation require more calories to offset their daily activities.) About 66 percent of rural households and 60 percent of urban households in the NSS count as undernourished.

Policy: Designing better food programs

To be sure, as Atkin notes about the study, the fact that the findings are drawn from 1980s data means circumstances could have changed since then. But as he writes in the paper, "There are several reasons to think the findings are still relevant." Among them: India's Famine Inquiry Commission of 1945, which examined the Bengal famine of 1943, found an aligned pattern, in that people with preferences for rice-centered cuisines were less willing to consume wheat, even at moments of significant need.

On the policy front, Atkin believes his research pertains to three types of programs: food aid, lowering tariffs to encourage imports, and new food-growing policies. In all cases, he thinks, policymakers should be cognizant of local cuisine preferences, to make sure that food being offered matches local tastes.

Among other examples, he notes, programs exporting yellow maize to Africa have not worked as well as expected, since the local dietary preference in many places is white maize.

"We need to take into account people's preferences when designing nutritional programs, hunger alleviation programs," says Atkin. "It's important for those programs to be sensitive to what people like to eat."
Additional background

ARCHIVE: A "graduation" from poverty

ARCHIVE: Passage from India

ARCHIVE: At MIT, food for thought

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Related Calories Articles:

Fitness trackers accurately measure heart rate but not calories burned, study finds
An evaluation of seven devices in a diverse group of 60 volunteers showed that six of the devices measured heart rate with an error rate of less than 5 percent.
How many calories in that tweet?
A team of scientists have invented an instrument for measuring calories in social media.
Study tallies extra calories Americans consume in their coffee, tea
More than 160 million people in the US drink coffee or tea on a regular basis, and many of them use sugar, cream, flavored syrups or other calorie-laden additives in their drinks of choice.
Children's menus still laden with fat, sodium, and calories despite industry pledges
Despite a 2011 pledge among United States chain restaurants to improve the nutritional value of children's menu options, a new study finds no significant improvements have been made to cut calories, saturated fat, or sodium.
Kids' restaurant menu items often include excess calories
Children eat much of their food away from home, with one of three children and 41 percent of teenagers eating at fast-food outlets on any given day.
Study in rats finds low blood alcohol levels have no effect on total calories consumed
Laboratory rats will drink alcohol if it's available, and may even get a little tipsy, researchers report in a new study.
Sleep deprivation may cause people to eat more calories
Sleep deprivation may result in people consuming more calories during the following day, according to a systematic review and meta-analysis led by researchers at King's College London.
Teenage weight gain down to dramatic drop in calories they burn
An acceleration in obesity among young teenagers could be explained by a 12-year-long study which found that the number of calories they burn while at rest drops suddenly in puberty.
Want to cut calories? New studies suggest placing orders before it's time to eat
Want to cut calories and make healthier meal choices? Try avoiding unhealthy impulse purchases by ordering meals at least an hour before eating.
Moderately reducing calories in non-obese people reduces inflammation
Eating less may help us lead longer, healthier lives, according to new results from a large, multicenter study led by Tufts researchers.

Related Calories Reading:

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Failure can feel lonely and final. But can we learn from failure, even reframe it, to feel more like a temporary setback? This hour, TED speakers on changing a crushing defeat into a stepping stone. Guests include entrepreneur Leticia Gasca, psychology professor Alison Ledgerwood, astronomer Phil Plait, former professional athlete Charly Haversat, and UPS training manager Jon Bowers.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#524 The Human Network
What does a network of humans look like and how does it work? How does information spread? How do decisions and opinions spread? What gets distorted as it moves through the network and why? This week we dig into the ins and outs of human networks with Matthew Jackson, Professor of Economics at Stanford University and author of the book "The Human Network: How Your Social Position Determines Your Power, Beliefs, and Behaviours".