Electrocardiogram shows value in college athletes' screens

May 04, 2020

Over the past 30 years, colleges and universities have increasingly screened athletes for health conditions that may pose undue risk to sports participation. Sudden cardiac death is the leading cause of death among college athletes, so a primary function of these screenings is to reveal unknown heart conditions.

The National Collegiate Athletic Association requires a baseline pre-participation physical exam and patient history; some schools also administer an electrocardiogram (ECG), which measures the electrical output of a person's heartbeat. Disagreement exists, however, about ECGs' value. While experts generally agree that an ECG can flag cardiac issues of concern, detractors say they result in too many false-positive findings, leading to unnecessary additional tests and costs.

The journal Heart Rhythm published the multi-institutional research. It was led by Dr.

Harmon and colleagues found that, across 8,602 records of Pacific-12 Conference athletes, cardiovascular screenings with an ECG in addition to a patient history and physical exam were six times more likely to detect a risky heart condition than screenings that involved only a patient history and physical. In parallel, ECG use improved the cost efficiency per diagnosis by five-fold.

"This is a real-world assessment of the discoveries resulting from different screening strategies, and how much they cost," Harmon said. "This study shows that screening with ECG is not only significantly more effective, it is only incrementally more expensive overall and costs much less per diagnosis. It can be implemented for much less than the cost of a pair of athletic shoes."

The researchers sought to compare positive findings, disease prevalence, and the costs of two screening strategies. They collected nine years of athletes' de-identified data from Pac-12 Conference institutions, which employ varied strategies for pre-participation physical screenings. Also analyzed were secondary tests, cardiac diagnoses, return-to-play outcomes, and complications from testing.

From 8,602 screenings, 11 athletes were identified with cardiovascular conditions:
  • History and physical exam: Two athletes (of 4,955) were identified as at risk, equating with a prevalence of 0.05% (1 in 2,454). Per-athlete screening cost averaged $130; cost per diagnosis was $312,407.
  • History, physical and ECG: nine athletes (of 3,647) were identified as at risk, equating with a prevalence of 0.024% (1 in 410). Per-athlete screening test cost was $152; cost per diagnosis was $61,712.

The costs of screenings and secondary testing were based on the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Physician Fee Schedule.

"This is the first study to compare screenings by using real-life outcomes rather than theoretical models and variable assumptions," said Harmon, a UW professor of family medicine and of orthopedics and sports medicine.

Not every school can incorporate ECG tests into athlete screenings, Harmon said. It's less a question about covering a $22 test cost and more about whether physicians are readily available to interpret the ECGs.

The study included screenings of athletes across all varsity sports, though men's basketball and football account for more than 50% of sudden cardiac deaths among college athletes, she said. Several Pac-12 schools have prioritized those sports for screening.
The research was supported with a grant from the

" Pac-12 Conference's Student-Athlete Health and Well-Being Initiative.

University of Washington Health Sciences/UW Medicine

Related Sudden Cardiac Death Articles from Brightsurf:

Sudden cardiac death often a woman's first sign of heart disease
New research from the Center for Cardiac Arrest Prevention at the Smidt Heart Institute at Cedars-Sinai shows that rates of sudden cardiac arrest are rising following decades of a downward trend.

New research could reduce the risk of sudden cardiac death
New research has shown that by changing the time course of voltage change early in action potential it is possible to both withhold a potentially lethal electrical disturbance and improve the strength of cardiac contraction in heart failure at the same time.

Rare genetic variants predispose to sudden cardiac death
By identifying rare DNA variants that substantially increase risk of sudden cardiac death, researchers have laid the foundation for efforts to identify individuals who could benefit from prevention strategies prior to experiencing symptoms.

Racial disparities in sudden cardiac death rates cannot be explained by known risk factors
A Penn Medicine study, published online today in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, showed that even after controlling for risk factors like income, education, smoking, exercise, and bad cholesterol, among others, black patients remained at significantly higher risk for sudden cardiac death than white patients.

Preventing sudden cardiac death with genome editing
Gene editing successfully prevented sudden cardiac death in a mouse model of inherited cardiac arrhythmia disorder.

Wearable defibrillator lowers sudden cardiac death, but only when you wear it
An international clinical trial that studied wearable cardioverter defibrillators (WCDs) found that the devices did not significantly reduce sudden cardiac death -- the primary goal of the device -- among patients assigned to the device in the first 90 days after a heart attack, but did lower mortality among those who wore it as prescribed, according to a study led by researchers at UC San Francisco.

New model estimates odds of events that trigger sudden cardiac death
A new computational model of heart tissue allows researchers to estimate the probability of rare heartbeat irregularities that can cause sudden cardiac death.

Mitochondrial DNA could predict risk for sudden cardiac death, heart disease
Johns Hopkins researchers report that the level, or 'copy number,' of mitochondrial DNA -- genetic information stored not in a cell's nucleus but in the body's energy-creating mitochondria -- is a novel and distinct biomarker that is able to predict the risk of heart attacks and sudden cardiac deaths a decade or more before they happen.

New report outlines 10 measures for the prevention of sudden cardiac death
A new report presents 10 quality and performance measures that are intended to help stakeholders--including health systems, legislative bodies, and nongovernmental organizations, as well as healthcare practitioners, patients, families and communities -- in the effort to prevent sudden cardiac death.

Sudden cardiac death of teen reminds physicians of precision medicine
The sudden death of a 13-year-old boy resulted in more than 20 relatives to be incorrectly diagnosed as having a potentially lethal heart rhythm condition.

Read More: Sudden Cardiac Death News and Sudden Cardiac Death Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.