Nav: Home

Working or protesting

May 16, 2018

The higher the unemployment rates in Western European countries, the more likely it is that socio-political destabilization will occur. At the same time, the highest levels of unemployment in Eastern European countries are accompanied by anti-government protests of very low intensity. This is just one of the conclusions made by HSE experts in their paper 'Unemployment as a predictor of socio-political destabilization in Western and Eastern European countries'.

The scholars analyzed the World Bank's data on unemployment and on socio-political destabilization from the Cross National Time Series (CNTS) database, 1991-2014. Linear correlation was used to compare these data. Scholars from various countries have studied the correlation between unemployment and socio-political destabilization before, but this has led to contradicting conclusions. HSE experts were the first to analyze these factors dividing the countries based on the presence or lack of communist past.

The project examined data from 24 non-post-Communist (Western) European countries, and 21 post-Communist (Eastern) European countries: Western Europe: Andorra, Austria, Belgium, Great Britain, Denmark, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Iceland, Spain, Italy, Cyprus, Lichtenstein, Luxembourg, Malta, Monaco, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, San Marino, Finland, France, Sweden, and Switzerland. Eastern Europe: Albania, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Hungary, Kosovo, Latvia, Lithuania, Macedonia, Moldova, Montenegro, Poland, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Ukraine, Croatia, Czech Republic, and Estonia.

The analysis used indicators such as socio-political destabilization as political assassinations, political strikes, big terrorist attacks and (or) 'guerilla actions', government crises, purges, riots, coups d'etats and coup attempts, anti-government demonstrations, and an aggregated index of socio-political destabilization. The calculations for Western European countries showed a positive correlation with all these indicators except for purges. This means that the higher the unemployment rate, the higher the rate of socio-political destabilization.

The scholars carried out decile analysis. They divided all the countries studied into 10 equal groups according to unemployment level, and then calculated the mean value for all destabilization indicators in each of the groups. This approach uses not specific countries, but groups of countries as a unit for comparison. The scientists detected that in 10% of countries with maximum levels of unemployment (over 12.1%) approximately four anti-government demonstrations happen annually.

The situation in Eastern European (post-Communist) countries is markedly different. The researchers did not identify a positive statistically significant correlation with any of the nine indicators of socio-political destabilization, which means the higher the unemployment, the less often the people protest.

The decile analysis demonstrated that more than one large-scale anti-government demonstration occurs every five years in Eastern European countries with minimal levels of unemployment. Comparatively, they found that less than one demonstration occurs every five years in countries with maximum unemployment rates (over 23.8%).

Reasons for Protests

The experts looked into the motivations for participating or not participating in protests, based on a preliminary study by Sergey Tsirel, one of the co-authors. They concluded that the unemployed have the following reasons for not participating in protest actions:
  • Feeling like a small neglected person who is afraid to speak up against power and society;

  • The need to spend time looking for a job, making money and supporting the family (spouse, children, parents etc);

  • The fear of being blacklisted by the police and especially employers as a rebel and a undesirable candidate for a job;

  • The fear of losing favour among supporters (including family, clan and community leaders) who provide money, loans, and part-time jobs.
However, the unemployed have the following reasons for participating in protests:
    Anger toward their former employers who fired them, as well as potential employers who denied them a job or offered a job and a salary which did not meet their qualifications and ambitions;

    Anger toward the government which implemented an economic policy that led to their unemployment;

    Anger toward the government which established unemployment benefits that are insufficient, regulations around receiving benefits that are too strict, and periods of payment that are too short;

    Free time allowing them to participate in politics and protests.
There are many reasons and circumstances that may direct an unemployed person or potentially unemployed person to participate or not participate in a protest. However, if the situation in a particular country is far from being revolutionary and the regime is far from collapsing, the key factor was found to be the presence or lack of the source of subsistence. According to researchers, the main reason for such contrasting reactions to growing unemployment among Western and Eastern Europeans is the difference in unemployment benefit rates. In the countries where unemployment benefits and the period of their payment are large (Western Europe), growing unemployment is accompanied by growing support for protests and participation in anti-government demonstrations. In countries with low benefits and short periods of payments (Eastern Europe), the people who lose their jobs mostly care about their personal problems and are less inclined to participate in protests if they have lost their job or are at a high risk of losing it.

An additional factor that results in differences in reactions demonstrated by Western and Eastern Europeans to losing a job is labour migration from Eastern to Western Europe. It 'dilutes' the 'fuel' for protests in the East and meanwhile contributes to protests among the Western European unemployed who support anti-immigrant laws.

'Migration waves after 2014, of course, influenced the protests, causing specific anti-immigrant protests. According to preliminary data, this may increase with growing unemployment in Western Europe', added Andrey Korotaev, one of the study authors and Head of the HSE Laboratory for Monitoring the Risks of Socio-Political Destabilization.

The danger of growing unemployment in developed economies is currently rather high. It may be caused by relocating product manufacturing to poorer countries with smaller salaries and social benefits, as well as by growing automation and robotization not only in production, but also in the service sector. At the same time, some of the Western countries are planning to introduce a 'basic income' for its citizens that doesn't depend on their employment. HSE experts conclude in their study that paradoxically, a very probable result of such policies, despite a certain decrease in income inequality, may be growing protest activities. And conversely, if there is no considerable growth of salaries and social benefits in Eastern European countries, the growing unemployment is not expected to impact protest activity, despite a certain increase in inequality.

National Research University Higher School of Economics

Related Unemployment Articles:

Unemployment associated with 50 percent higher risk of death in heart failure patients
Unemployment is associated with a 50 percent higher risk of death in patients with heart failure, according to research presented today at Heart Failure 2017 and the 4th World Congress on Acute Heart Failure.1 The observational study in more than 20,000 heart failure patients found that not being employed was linked with a greater likelihood of death than history of diabetes or stroke.
Can unemployment increase stroke risk?
In middle-age Japanese men and women, losing their job increased their risk of having a stroke and dying of stroke; while a new job increased stroke risk even more, especially in men.
Research finds link between unemployed women trading sex for security and high HIV rates
Dr. Kelly Austin finds that unemployment among young women significantly impacts the proportion of female HIV cases among those aged 15-24 in developing -- especially Sub-Saharan African countries.
Shootings in US schools are linked to increased unemployment
A Northwestern University study has found that economic insecurity is related to the rate of gun violence at K-12 and postsecondary schools in the United States.
Survey on Americans' priorities finds health care, unemployment, immigration, education top list
Health care, unemployment, immigration, and education top a lengthy and varied list of the American public's policy priorities for 2017, according to a new national survey conducted by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research.
Study examines work status, productivity after bariatric surgery
In a study appearing in the Oct. 18 issue of JAMA, David R.
Penn study links recession recovery, increase in commercial truck fatalities
New findings by grad student Monica He of the University of Pennsylvania reveal unexpected health consequences of economic recovery on fatalities involving large, commercial vehicles.
How the Great Recession weighed on children
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health researchers have found that increases in unemployment in California during the Great Recession were associated with an increased risk for weight gain among the state's 1.7 million public school students, suggesting that economic troubles could have long-term health consequences for children.
Why everyone wants to help the sick -- but not the unemployed
New research from Aarhus BSS at Aarhus University explains why health-care costs are running out of control, while costs to unemployment protection are kept in line.
Survey finds that social security and unemployment are Americans' primary economic concerns
A new national poll conducted by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research provides a detailed look at the economic issues Americans identify as most important.

Related Unemployment Reading:

Generation Jobless?: Turning the youth unemployment crisis into opportunity
by Peter Vogel (Author)

Generation Jobless? uniquely explores the characteristics of both today's and tomorrow's youth and the causes of the youth unemployment crisis. The book takes a global, multi-stakeholder perspective to showcase proven solutions to tackle the crisis. Featuring interviews and input from business leaders, policy makers, educators, entrepreneurs and the Next Generation itself, it offers a positive and constructive look at change by directing each group to become part of the solution and in particular youth to take on responsibility for themselves and their peers by turning into job... View Details

Fighting FIRED With Fire: A Guide to Coping with Job Loss, Rising from the Ashes and Igniting a Career You Love
by Megan M Wagner (Author)

Nearly 50,000 people lose their jobs EVERY DAY. Are you one of them? Have you recently lost your job? Are you worried about what’s going to happen with your career next? Are you battling emotional issues such as self-doubt and anxiety? Before you burn down the building, read this first. Fighting FIRED With Fire offers guiding solutions to help cope with job loss, relatable stories from others who have experienced unemployment, and invaluable tips on how to start rebuilding a career that you love. If you’ve recently experienced unexpected unemployment, you may not know where to turn for... View Details

The Unemployment Survival Guide
by Jim Stringham (Author), David R Workman (Author)

Unemployment is unquestionably one of life's most stressful and difficult experiences, and it happens to virtually everyone at least once during the course of their working lives. It is a time of uncertainty and transition-but it can also be a time to learn, grow, and seriously examine the direction of one's life. Break Time: Nourishing Yourself Through Unemployment provides practical solutions for the roller coaster of experiences that people have from the day a job is lost to the day a promising new one is found. Authors Jim Stringham and David R. Workman show you how to take advantage of... View Details

A World of Three Zeros: The New Economics of Zero Poverty, Zero Unemployment, and Zero Net Carbon Emissions
by Muhammad Yunus (Author)

A winner of the Nobel Peace Prize and bestselling author of Banker to the Poor offers his vision of an emerging new economic system that can save humankind and the planet
Muhammad Yunus, who created microcredit, invented social business, and earned a Nobel Peace Prize for his work in alleviating poverty, is one of today's most trenchant social critics. Now he declares it's time to admit that the capitalist engine is broken--that in its current form it inevitably leads to rampant inequality, massive unemployment, and environmental destruction. We need a new economic system... View Details

by A C. 1877-1959 Pigou (Author)

This work has been selected by scholars as being culturally important, and is part of the knowledge base of civilization as we know it. This work was reproduced from the original artifact, and remains as true to the original work as possible. Therefore, you will see the original copyright references, library stamps (as most of these works have been housed in our most important libraries around the world), and other notations in the work.

This work is in the public domain in the United States of America, and possibly other nations. Within the United States, you may freely copy and... View Details

Equilibrium Unemployment Theory (MIT Press)
by Christopher A. Pissarides (Author)

This book focuses on the modeling of the transitions in and out of unemployment, given the stochastic processes that break up jobs and lead to the formation of new jobs, and on the implications of this approach for macroeconomic equilibrium and for the efficiency of the labor market.

An equilibrium theory of unemployment assumes that firms and workers maximize their payoffs under rational expectations and that wages are determined to exploit the private gains from trade. This book focuses on the modeling of the transitions in and out of unemployment, given the stochastic... View Details

You are Fired, Laid Off, Now What? How to Survive, Thrive and Win the Unemployment Benefits You Deserve

The Statistics Are Truly Eye Opening: According to 2014 statistics, an average of 54,736 people are laid off or fired each day in the United States. We’ve all been there and whether we like it or not, we will cross these challenging abyss and situation sooner or later.

You Are Fired, Laid-off, Now What? How to Survive, Thrive, and Win the Unemployment Benefits You Deserve a practical, resource filled and extremely useful guide to help you achieve two main goals:

Goal #1: Be able to get the most benefits and money through the... View Details

Unemployment: Macroeconomic Performance and the Labour Market
by Richard Layard (Author), Stephen Nickell (Author), Richard Jackman (Author)

This broad survey of unemployment is a benchmark summary of the authors position which became hugely influential. This second edition brings the analysis up to date by relating it to recent empirical developments. This book is a major source of reference for both scholars and students.
View Details

Keeping Your Head After Losing Your Job: How to Survive Unemployment
by Robert L. Leahy (Author)

"A practical guide to picking yourself up, restoring your health and well-being, and getting the motivation and confidence to move forward with your life.—Susan Nolen-Hoeksema, PhD, author of the best-selling Women Who Think Too Much

Losing your job may be the most difficult thing you'll experience. Your mental health and physical well-being can suffer, leaving you feeling anxious, helpless, and alone. Dr. Robert L. Leahy has worked with many unemployed people over the years, and his successful techniques draw upon Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), as well as practices,... View Details

Unemployment (Global Viewpoints)
by Noel Merino (Author)

This series provides readers with the information they need to think critically about the worldwide implications of global issues; each volume focuses on a controversial topic of worldwide importance and offers a panoramic view of opinions.; This title examines the topic around the issues of the global problem of unemployment, the victims of unemployment, the causes of unemployment, and the solutions to unemployment.; By illuminating the complexities and interrelations of the global community, this excellent resource helps students and other researchers enhance their global awareness. Each... View Details

Best Science Podcasts 2018

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2018. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Attention Please
In an age of constant information and infinite distractions, how can we pay more attention to our ... attention? This hour, TED speakers explore the battle for our awareness during the digital age. Guests include sociologist Zeynep Tufekci, podcast host Manoush Zomorodi, neuroscientist Amishi Jha, designer Tristan Harris, and computer scientist Jaron Lanier.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#475 Mother Nature is Trying to Kill You (Rebroadcast)
This week, we're learning how deadly and delightful our planet and its ecosystem can be. We're joined by biologist Dan Riskin, co-host of Discovery Canada's Daily Planet, to talk about his book "Mother Nature Is Trying to Kill You: a Lively Tour Through the Dark Side of the Natural World." And we'll talk to astronomer and author Phil Plait about Science Getaways, his company that offers educational vacation experiences for science lovers.