Surgery no better than rehabilitation for low back pain

May 22, 2005

Surgery for chronic low back pain is no better than intensive rehabilitation and is unlikely to be a cost-effective use of scarce healthcare resources, show two studies published online by the BMJ today.

These results should help doctors and service providers make decisions about the management of chronic low back pain.

Chronic low back pain, defined as pain lasting for more than 12 months, is common and places a major economic burden on individuals, the healthcare system, and society as a whole. Direct costs were estimated to be around £1.6bn in the United Kingdom in 1998, and the condition is estimated to account for close to 120 million UK work days lost per year.

The trial involved 349 chronic back pain patients from 15 centres across the UK. 176 patients were assigned to spinal fusion surgery and 173 to an intensive programme of rehabilitation, led by physiotherapists, involving daily exercises and cognitive (mental) behavioural therapy.

After two years, 38 patients assigned to rehabilitation had received rehabilitation and surgery, whereas just seven surgery patients received both treatments. There appeared to be a slight advantage to surgical treatment, but the differences were small considering the potential risk and additional cost of surgery.

The authors conclude that there is no clear evidence that spinal fusion surgery is any more beneficial than rehabilitation, and suggest that rehabilitation should be routinely available to chronic low back pain patients.

In the cost analysis, the average total cost per patient was estimated to be £7830 in the surgery group and £4526 in the rehabilitation group, a significant difference of £3304.

The authors conclude that a policy of spinal fusion surgery as first line therapy for chronic low back pain seems not to be a cost effective use of healthcare resources at two year follow-up. However, this could alter if the number of rehabilitation patients subsequently receiving surgery continues to increase in the future.


Related Rehabilitation Articles from Brightsurf:

Simple measurement could transform injury rehabilitation
Researchers from Edith Cowan University in Western Australia have found a simple way to analyse the effectiveness of exercise training that could one day be conducted easily at a local gym or physio.

Vocational rehabilitation helps lift people with disabilities out of poverty
Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits do not always keep individuals with disabilities out of poverty.

Study examines the benefits of virtual stroke rehabilitation programs
While virtual medical and rehabilitation appointments seemed novel when COVID-19 first appeared, they now seem to be part of the new norm and might be paving the way to the future.

How rehabilitation impacts research and care of patients with cerebral palsy
Cerebral palsy (CP) is one of the most common developmental movement disorders in children.

Smartphone accelerometers could help in resistance workouts and rehabilitation protocols
Smartphone accelerometers are effective tools to measure key time-under-tension indicators of muscle training -- and could help in resistance-based workouts and rehabilitation protocols.

Many children in intensive care may not be getting rehabilitation therapy, study shows
Adult patients in hospital intensive care units (ICUs) are often given rehabilitation therapy and urged to keep mobile from an early point in their hospital stays.

Movement study could be significant in helping understand brain rehabilitation
Researchers from the University of Plymouth (UK) and Technical University of Munich (Germany) say their study could be particularly important for those working in rehabilitation and helping people to recover after neurological conditions.

Only 1 in 4 Medicare patients participate in cardiac rehabilitation
Only about 24% of Medicare patients who could receive outpatient cardiac rehabilitation participate in the program.

A conversation could be the answer to successful rehabilitation of prisoners
Researchers have found people on the brink of release from a prison sentence have lost any sense of being connected to the outside world and, as a result, become prejudiced towards wider society.

An artificial skin that can help rehabilitation and enhance virtual reality
EPFL scientists have developed a soft artificial skin that provides haptic feedback and -- thanks to a sophisticated self-sensing mechanism -- has the potential to instantaneously adapt to a wearer's movements.

Read More: Rehabilitation News and Rehabilitation Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to