System takes from poor schools and gives to the rich, study shows

May 27, 2003

School districts transfer millions of dollars each year from schools in poor neighborhoods to those with wealthier students and higher-paid teachers, a new study shows.

The study documents the effects of a system used by nearly all of America's urban school districts, which allocate money to schools as if all teachers made the same salary even though better-paid teachers cluster in affluent neighborhoods.

The result: one Baltimore County school with low teacher salaries, for example, received $500,000 less than reported in the district's own budget documents.

"Do we really want to keep systematically funneling resources away from poor and low-performing schools?" asked study co-author Paul Hill, director of the University of Washington's Center on Reinventing Public Education.

Hill and fellow UW researcher Marguerite Roza examined the effects in four major school districts - Baltimore City, Baltimore County, Cincinnati and Seattle - of the salary-averaging system that makes it appear as though teachers in low-income schools cost as much as the senior teachers in high-income schools.

In each district, researchers found, salary averaging works against efforts to invest more money in poor schools.

By switching to a system that accounts for actual pay, districts could let poorer schools recoup the lost dollars for smaller classes or better technology, researchers said.

Union rules and longstanding practice often permit experienced teachers to choose their schools, and they often choose schools that enroll students from more privileged backgrounds. But in allocating staff costs, districts' budgets show all teachers earning the district-wide average.

In reality, Roza and Hill found that the average teacher in Baltimore's high-poverty schools pulls in nearly $2,000 less than the district average - and $4,000 less than those at the wealthiest schools. Poor schools receive no extra resources to compensate for their lower-cost teachers, and budget documents hide the salary differences.

"Those lost dollars really add up, to the tune of $637 per pupil in one Seattle school," Roza said. "District budget documents should reflect how much money the district is really spending on each school."

The study, funded through the Atlantic Philanthropies and the Annie E. Casey Foundation, is being posted online this week and will be part of a book to be published by the Brookings Institution next year. The research suggests the pattern plagues most urban districts.

In Seattle, teachers in the city's wealthier Northeast zone earned average salaries above $41,000, which those in the less-affluent Southeast averaged $37,670.

Hill and Roza recommended not only using real salaries in budgeting, but adding financial incentives to lure better teachers to struggling schools.
-end-
For more information, contact Hill at 206-685-2214 or bicycle@u.washington.edu, or Roza at 206-612-0810 or MargRoza@aol.com. The Center on Reinventing Public Education, at the Daniel J. Evans School of Public Affairs, University of Washington, studies major issues in education reform and governance. The center can be reached at 206-685-2214. The study - including charts and graphs - is available online at www.crpe.org/workingpapers/pdf/Roza-Hill.pdf

University of Washington

Related Teachers Articles from Brightsurf:

AI teachers must be effective and communicate well to be accepted, new study finds
The increase in online education has allowed a new type of teacher to emerge -- an artificial one.

Future teachers more likely to view black children as angry, even when they are not
A new study of prospective teachers finds that they are more likely to interpret the facial expressions of Black boys and girls as being angry, even when the children are not angry.

Prospective teachers misperceive Black children as angry
Prospective teachers appear more likely to misperceive Black children as angry than white children, which may undermine the education of Black youth, according to new research published by the American Psychological Association.

Children who have difficult relationships with their moms are clingy towards teachers
Children who experience 'dependent' or clingy relationships with their preschool teachers tend to also have difficulties in their relationships with their mothers finds researchers at the NYU Steinhardt School of Culture, Education, and Human Development.

Research finds teachers just as likely to have racial bias as non-teachers
Research released today challenges the notion that teachers might be uniquely equipped to instill positive racial attitudes in children or bring about racial justice, without additional support or training from schools.

Young teachers happier but say hard work is unrewarded
Newly qualified teachers report higher levels of wellbeing and life satisfaction compared to other graduates, but are more likely to say hard work in Britain is unrewarded, according to UCL research.

Robots can learn how to support teachers in class sessions
New research conducted at the University of Plymouth shows that a robot can be programmed to progressively learn autonomous behaviour from human demonstrations and guidance.

Preschool teachers ask children too many simple questions
When preschool teachers read books in their classrooms, the questions they ask play a key role in how much children learn, research has shown.

Teachers predict pupil success just as well as exam scores
New research from King's College London finds that teacher assessments are equally as reliable as standardised exams at predicting educational success.

Teachers and Trump
Teachers felt immense pressure from school leaders and families to respond in a certain way -- or not at all -- in their classrooms following the 2016 presidential election, according to new research from Michigan State University.

Read More: Teachers News and Teachers Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.