Marine snail study suggests conservation efforts should move beyond genetic diversity

May 30, 2001

A study of climate-induced evolutionary change in a California intertidal snail suggests that conservation plans for protecting endangered or threatened species should not focus exclusively on genetic diversity. The research is funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF).

In the study, detailed in the June 1 issue of Science, biologists at the University of California, San Diego, and Louisiana State University measured the genetic diversity of populations of Acanthinucella spirata, a common marine gastropod from San Francisco to San Diego. They discovered that the snail's genetic diversity, the most commonly used gauge of a population's health, is highest in the Los Angeles area and lowest in the northern part of its range.

"This novel study provides a new angle to research on genetic/morphologic diversity," says Rich Lane, director of NSF's geology and paleontology program, which funded the research. "It has been thought that morphologic variation is greatest in populations where genetic diversity is highest. While that may be logical, here is a case where it is not true. The bottom line is that greater care and investigation may be needed in choosing locations of biological reserves, and in considering environmental and ecological decisions."

Measurements of genetic diversity now greatly influence decisions on where to locate protected reserves, since the most genetically diverse populations are assumed to be better able to withstand environmental changes. But while the snails around Los Angeles and southward are genetically more diverse than those to the north, the researchers discovered that they are less diverse morphologically. This is due to the presence of a different shell form, or morphology, in some populations in the northern part of the range that is not found in the Los Angeles area or in regions to the south.

"There's a big difference in the morphology-in the shape and size of the shells-between the northern and the southern populations," says Kaustuv Roy, a biologist at UCSD who conducted the study with Michael E. Hellberg, a biologist at LSU, and Deborah P. Balch, a former student at UCSD. "Looking at the coast today, there's a dramatic decline in genetic diversity in this species going from south to north," he adds. "But the northern regions have a greater amount of morphological diversity. So, which do you use to make conservation decisions-genetic diversity or morphological diversity? Here's a case where the two come into conflict."

During many previous ice ages, the cooling of the planet caused localized extinctions of many populations of marine and terrestrial organisms near the northern limits of their ranges. When the earth warmed, some of the southern populations re-colonized the previously occupied northern regions. This is what the scientists believe happened to Acanthinucella spirata, because the snail's genetic diversity is highest around Los Angeles and declines sharply northward. The decline in genetic diversity suggests that the northern part of the range of this marine snail was re-colonized by a small number of individuals from the south, resulting in genetically homogeneous populations to the north.

The researchers obtained their estimates on when this new morphological type arose by calculating the changes over time in a protein they used as a "molecular clock." They also confirmed from their fossil collections that this second distinct morphology was not present along the California coast before this time period.
-end-
Photographs of the two forms of Acanthinucella spirata available at: http://ucsdnews.ucsd.edu/newsrel/science/mcshell.htm
Credit: Kaustuv Roy, UCSD

National Science Foundation

Related Genetic Diversity Articles from Brightsurf:

In the Cerrado, topography explains the genetic diversity of amphibians more than land cover
Study shows that a tree frog endemic to a mountainous region of the Brazilian savanna is unable to disperse and find genetically closer mates when the terrain is rugged, potentially endangering survival of the species

New DNA sequencing technique may help unravel genetic diversity of cancer tumors
Understanding the genetic diversity of individual cells within a cancer tumor and how that might impact the disease progression has remained a challenge, due to the current limitations of genomic sequencing.

Researchers uncover the arks of genetic diversity in terrestrial mammals
Mapping the distribution of life on Earth, from genes to species to ecosystems, is essential in informing conservation policies and protecting biodiversity.

Seahorse and pipefish study by CCNY opens window to marine genetic diversity May 08, 2020
The direction of ocean currents can determine the direction of gene flow in rafting species, but this depends on species traits that allow for rafting propensity.

Study helps arboreta, botanical gardens meet genetic diversity conservation goals
In a groundbreaking study, an international team of 21 scientists evaluated five genera spanning the plant tree of life (Hibiscus, Magnolia, Pseudophoenix, Quercus and Zamia) to understand how much genetic diversity currently exists in collections in botanical gardens and arboreta worldwide.

Study reveals rich genetic diversity of Vietnam
In a new paper, Dang Liu, Mark Stoneking and colleagues have analyzed newly generated genome-wide SNP data for the Kinh and 21 additional ethnic groups in Vietnam, encompassing all five major language families in MSEA, along with previously published data from nearby populations and ancient samples.

Coastal pollution reduces genetic diversity of corals, reef resilience
A new study by researchers at the University of Hawai'i at Mānoa School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology found that human-induced environmental stressors have a large effect on the genetic composition of coral reef populations in Hawai'i.

New world map of fish genetic diversity
An international research team from ETH Zurich and French universities has studied genetic diversity among fish around the world for the first time.

Texas A&M study reveals domestic horse breed has third-lowest genetic diversity
A new study by Dr. Gus Cothran, professor emeritus at the Texas A&M School of Veterinary Medicine & Biomedical Sciences, has found that the Cleveland Bay horse breed has the third-lowest genetic variation level of domestic horses, ranking above only the notoriously inbred Friesian and Clydesdale breeds.

Genetic diversity facilitates cancer therapy
Cancer patients with more different HLA genes respond better to treatment.

Read More: Genetic Diversity News and Genetic Diversity Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.