Public has a stake in what religious schools teach, professor says

June 05, 2006

Whether it's prayer in schools, alternatives to evolution, or courses on the Bible, the debate continues on the role of religion in public schools. But does the public have an interest in what's taught in religious schools?

The answer is yes, says Walter Feinberg, the Charles Dunn Hardie Professor of Philosophy of Education at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and the author of a new book, "For Goodness Sake: Religious Schools and Education for Democratic Citizenry" (published by Routledge).

The public has an interest because "the education of children in a democratic society is everybody's business," Feinberg wrote in the introduction to his book. The public needs to know that religious schools are instilling the attitudes, skills and beliefs that are essential to democracy, and which cannot be assumed to "grow themselves."

"There is no doubt that religion has left us with a wealth of moral understanding that helps to make human beings human," Feinberg wrote. It's one reason some religious groups advocate for religion to play a central role in the moral education of children in public schools, he said.

"Nevertheless, modern, liberal democracies have their own sets of requirements, from the need for autonomy and critical reflection ... to the requirement for tolerance, mutual recognition, and respect for differences," Feinberg wrote. Some aspects of some religions can be in tension with those requirements.

And unlike public schools, "these schools are not answerable to a public formed through a democratic process," Feinberg wrote. Their curriculum "is largely veiled from public scrutiny and shielded from public debate."

In his research for the book, supported by a grant from the Spencer Foundation, Feinberg practiced a kind of philosophy in the field, or "philosophical ethnography." Over a three-year period, he spent time in Catholic, Jewish, Protestant and Islamic schools. He observed classrooms and interviewed teachers, administrators and former students, probing their assumptions and values as part of the process.

Feinberg's concern centers on potential tensions within the twin platforms of democracy: liberalism, the political philosophy that emphasizes the individual's right to choose how to live his or her own life, and pluralism, the view that society must embrace many different types of beliefs and communities, even some that are not committed to the autonomy that liberalism prizes.

Feinberg doesn't believe that democracy is hostile to religion or to religious education. To the contrary, he believes that every religion has a "right of chauvinism," but that that right must be understood as universal. In other words, he said, "I have a right to believe my religion is the best religion in the world, but I also believe that you have the right to believe that your religion is the best religion in the world."

But in the intersection between religion and democratic ideals, tensions can arise, for instance, when a religion claims absolute truth, emphasizes exclusivity, or feels the need to control inquiry.

Feinberg explores the way a Jewish day school shapes a commitment to Israel, the way Catholic schools deal with church doctrine about sex and sexual identity in the presence of students who are sexually active and gay, and how students in a conservative Christian school are inoculated against inconvenient scientific ideas such as evolution.

Among the religious teachers Feinberg observed and interviewed, he found that most were flexible and non-dogmatic, and demonstrated a practical wisdom in balancing religious doctrine with the cultural climate and a concern for their students. How they did that is a large part of the story he tells in the book.

The best teachers "had creative ways of interrogating, without confronting, religious doctrine," he said. "It's not just a program to them, it's a way of framing a life, and they communicate that to these students, and I think it's very powerful when it's done well," he said.

In addressing the concerns Feinberg cites in his book, he argues against excessive state intervention into the classroom or curriculum. Instead, he suggests addressing the public interest through the training of religious teachers.

Ironically, rather than lessons on the foundations of democracy, Feinberg suggests that one of the most beneficial subjects in training religious teachers would be more about the history of the faith and religious teaching. "They need to know that it is possible for religious doctrine to change over time," he said.

In the interest of pluralism, the state also might take a role in suggesting or offering alternative experiences that increase students' contact with those of other faiths or backgrounds, Feinberg said.

For the same reason, public schools, with their diversity across religious and cultural lines, need to remain strong and viable, Feinberg wrote. "Public schools, when working as they should, can provide the trust and understanding that can allow single-tradition religious schools to flourish at the educational margins."
-end-


University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Related Education Articles from Brightsurf:

Applying artificial intelligence to science education
A new review published in the Journal of Research in Science Teaching highlights the potential of machine learning--a subset of artificial intelligence--in science education.

Dementia education
School-based dementia education could deliver much needed empathy and understanding for older generations as new research from the University of South Australia shows it can significantly improve dementia knowledge and awareness among younger generations.

How can education researchers support education and public health and institutions during COVID-19?
As education researchers' ongoing work is interrupted by school closures, what can they do to support education and public health institutions dealing with the Covid-19 pandemic?

Online education platforms could scale high-quality STEM education for universities
Online and blended (online and in-person) STEM instruction can produce the same learning outcomes for students as traditional, in-person classes at a fraction of the cost, finds research published today in Science Advances.

Technology in higher education: learning with it instead of from it
Technology has shifted the way that professors teach students in higher education.

The new racial disparity in special education
Racial disparity in special education is growing, and it's more complex than previously thought.

Education may be key to a healthier, wealthier US
A first-of-its-kind study estimate the economic value of education for better health and longevity.

How education may stave off cognitive decline
Prefrontal brain regions linked to higher educational attainment are characterized by increased expression of genes involved in neurotransmission and immunity, finds a study of healthy older adults published in JNeurosci.

Does more education stem political violence?
In a study released online today in Review of Educational Research, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Educational Research Association, three Norwegian researchers attempt to bring clarity to this question by undertaking the first systematic examination of quantitative research on this topic.

Individual education programs not being used as intended in special education
Gone are the days when students with disabilities were placed in a separate classroom, or even in a completely different part of the school.

Read More: Education News and Education Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.