New Book Reveals Scientific Controversy Surrounding Turin Shroud

June 09, 1997

Harry Gove, a physicist who took his quest to determine the age of the famed Turin Shroud all the way to the pope, has published a book recounting the remarkable clash between science and religion that he witnessed in the decade-long struggle to subject Jesus' purported burial cloth to the rigors of modern carbon dating. The book offers readers the first behind-the- scenes peek into the very public wrangling over the shroud.

Gove, now a professor emeritus of physics at the University of Rochester, was one of three researchers who in 1977 developed accelerator mass spectrometry for carbon dating, a technology that definitively disproved the authenticity of the Turin Shroud 11 years later. Gove's book, Relic, Icon or Hoax? Carbon Dating the Turin Shroud, tells how he was soon swept into the all-encompassing debate over the shroud -- a relic that has mystified Christians ever since its first recorded appearance in 1353.

The 14-foot by 3-foot strip of linen bears a faint but haunting likeness of a naked man who shows all the marks of crucifixion described in the Bible, including strategically placed blood-like stains. It is now stored by the Roman Catholic Church in the cathedral at Turin, Italy.

"I wasn't even aware of the Turin Shroud until my interest was sparked by a letter I received in 1977 from an Anglican priest who had seen an article in Time magazine about our work with accelerator mass spectrometry," Gove says. "He wanted to know if this technology -- which accurately determines the age of artifacts by measuring carbon isotopes in samples of only fractions of a milligram -- might be used on the shroud."

Over the next decade, Gove and a handful of other would-be shroud analysts successfully took on reluctant church officials, culminating in a dramatic 1986 meeting with Pope John Paul II followed by a workshop on procedures for dating the shroud. Gove and company also overcame the interference of a group of rival scientists who were certain of the shroud's authenticity. Finally the church relented, but it allowed tiny fragments of the shroud to be tested at only three institutions; much to Gove's chagrin, Rochester was not among them.

"I was most disappointed (a monumental understatement)," he writes. "I wanted the job to be done right. Using only three labs was not the right way to do it."

After years of intrigue and delays, the first scientific analysis of the Turin Shroud on May 6, 1988 revealed it to be other than Jesus' burial shroud: The flax from which it was made was harvested within three decades of the year 1325.

The lull in the Turin Shroud debate prompted by this finding has recently given way to new speculation. Some scientists, who continue to insist on the shroud's authenticity, have suggested that the carbon dating was skewed by contaminants on the shroud.

Gove questions these claims. "The shroud would have to be 70 percent contaminants for the dating to be so far off," he says.

Scientists and shroud enthusiasts alike have received the book favorably. "This book ... is written by a top scientist in the style of the best investigative journalism," writes Colin Humphreys, a materials science professor at Cambridge. "The story is absolutely fascinating, with a constant interplay of science and religion, and a surprising amount of intrigue and suspense."

Relic, Icon or Hoax? Carbon Dating the Turin Shroud, published in October 1996 by the Institute of Physics Publishing in Philadelphia, sells for $35.

University of Rochester

Related Religion Articles from Brightsurf:

How religion can hamper economic progress
Study from Bocconi University on impact of antiscientific curricula of Catholic schools on accumulation of human capital in France during the 2nd Industrial Revolution could hold lessons on impact of religion on technological progress today.

CU Denver study looks into the connection between religion and equal pay
Traci Sitzmann, an Associate Professor at the University of Colorado Denver Business School, and Elizabeth Campbell, an Assistant Professor at the University of Minnesota, provide empirical evidence and an explanation into why religion perpetuates the gender wage gap.

How religion can heighten or help with financial stress
Researchers found that some people experience financial stress due, in part, to their religion's demands on their time and money.

Religion associated with HPV vaccination rate for college women
A survey of female college students finds 25% had not been vaccinated for HPV and religion may be a contributing factor.

Rise of religion pre-dates Incas at Lake Titicaca
An ancient group of people made ritual offerings to supernatural deities near the Island of the Sun in Lake Titicaca, Bolivia, about 500 years earlier than the Incas, according to an international team of researchers.

Sociologists study the impact religion has on child development
Do children raised by religious parents have better social and psychological development than those raised in non-religious homes?

Research: Religion affects consumer choices on specialty foods
People with strong religious beliefs are more likely to buy fat-free, sugar-free or gluten-free foods than natural or organic foods, according to new research that could influence the marketing of those specialty food products.

Drug use, religion explain 'reverse gender gap' on marijuana
Women tend to be more conservative than men on political questions related to marijuana.

UTSA researcher studies the impact religion has on sleep quality
Christopher Ellison, in The University of Texas at San Antonio (UTSA) Department of Sociology, Terrence D.

Some black and Latino Christians rely on religion for healing
Christians who are comparatively well-represented in the medical field, like Korean-Americans, understand the relationship between faith and health differently than those who are not, like African-Americans and Latinos.

Read More: Religion News and Religion Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to