Boxing Matches Couldn't Be Held If Doctors Refused To Be At The Ringside

June 12, 1998

(Could boxing be banned? A legal and epidemiological perspective)

In an Education and Debate paper in this week's BMJ, Professor Hugh Brayne from the University of Sunderland writes that scientific evidence shows that boxing, both professional and amateur, endangers health.

He notes that no boxing case has ever been heard in the courts and so the legal system has never been asked to consider the scientific evidence against the sport. Even without legislation, says the author, the law could place limitations on the sport. Brayne considers the legal implications of the sport, taking into account intent to cause bodily harm and the issue of consent. He suggests that two possible test cases could be considered in the event of a fight resulting in serious injury or death:- a claim for compensation against the promoter or referee or a criminal prosecution based on the known scientific evidence.

He concludes that since medical cover is a legal requirement at all boxing promotions, the profession should consider whether members should participate, in light of its own ethical standards. If they didn't, boxing would become an impossible activity.

Contact:

Professor Hugh Brayne, Sunderland Business School, University of Sunderland, Sunderland hugh.brayne@sunderland.ac.uk

Carol Brayne, Lecturer, Department of Community Medicine, University of Cambridge, Cambridge
-end-


BMJ

Related Scientific Evidence Articles from Brightsurf:

Who's Tweeting about scientific research? And why?
Although Twitter is best known for its role in political and cultural discourse, it has also become an increasingly vital tool for scientific communication.

Protecting scientific diversity
The COVID-19 pandemic means that scientists face great challenges because they have to reorient, interrupt or even cancel research and teaching.

Scientific evidence found for role of stress in hair whitening
Partnering with scientists at Harvard, a group of Brazilians affiliated with the Center for Research on Inflammatory Diseases (CRID), supported by FAPESP, described the mechanisms that cause hair color loss in extreme situations.

University of Idaho study finds scientific reproducibility does not equate to scientific truth
Reproducible scientific results are not always true and true scientific results are not always reproducible, according to a mathematical model produced by University of Idaho researchers.

A scientific method for perfect fondue
Cheese fondue is an icon of Swiss cuisine and a dinner party staple.

New scientific evidence builds a stronger case for the Endangerment Finding
In the years since the US Environmental Protection Agency's 2009 (EPA) establishment of the 'Endangerment Finding,' a landmark redefinition of harmful greenhouse gasses to pollution, scientific information concerning the impacts and risks of climate change has continued to accumulate.

Breastfeeding in Germany from a scientific viewpoint
Is breastfeeding really better? The intense debate on this question has been going on for decades -- and is often controversial and emotionally discussed.

People trust scientific experts more than the government even when the evidence is outlandish
Members of the public in the UK and US have far greater trust in scientific experts than the government, according to a new study by Queen Mary University of London.

Would you share your scientific results before publication?
Scientists who surveyed more than 7,000 active faculty researchers in the US and abroad report that more than half of them had disclosed their results before publication, largely to receive feedback.

New report examines scientific evidence on safety and quality of abortion care in US
While legal abortions in the US are safe, the likelihood that women will receive the type of abortion services that best meet their needs varies considerably depending on where they live, says a new report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine.

Read More: Scientific Evidence News and Scientific Evidence Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.