Nav: Home

Vanished classmates: The effects of immigration enforcement on school enrollment

July 02, 2019

Main Findings:

  • Partnerships between Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and local police departments designed to enforce immigration laws reduced the number of Hispanic students in U.S. public schools in adopting counties by 10 percent after two years.

  • Partnerships enacted during 2000 to 2011 displaced about 320,000 Hispanic students, with the impact concentrated among elementary school students, most of whom were likely born in the United States.

  • This evidence is based on data from a period when federal support for ICE partnerships with local police was more limited than in recent years. The increased number of new ICE partnerships with local police under the Trump administration suggests that their current educational, economic, and social costs may be even more severe.


  • Using data acquired from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security through Freedom of Information Act requests, researchers Thomas Dee and Mark Murphy, both of Stanford University, identified 55 counties in the United States where ICE partnerships with local law-enforcement agencies designed to identify, arrest, and remove undocumented residents were put into place between 2000 and 2011.

  • These partnerships led to a 10 percent reduction in Hispanic student enrollment following two years of implementation. The reduction appeared to be concentrated among the youngest students. The authors note that most of the impacted students with an undocumented parent are themselves U.S. citizens.

  • The authors estimate that during the period studied, ICE partnerships displaced approximately 320,000 Hispanic students, by encouraging families to leave and discouraging other families from coming in. In contrast, ICE partnerships did not affect non-Hispanic enrollment.

  • "Our results underscore the dramatic and presumably unintended consequences of ICE partnerships for students and schools," said Thomas Dee, the Barnett Family Professor at Stanford University. "Prior research clearly suggests that causing families to move under duress or dropping out of school harms students, while inhibiting family moves that would enhance economic opportunity can also be detrimental."

  • The authors note that students may have been further harmed academically to the extent that ICE partnerships decreased parental involvement with their schools.

  • The authors found that at the same time that ICE partnerships reduced the Hispanic presence in public schools they did not lower student-teacher ratios or the share of remaining public school students who were disadvantaged (as measured by their eligibility for the National School Lunch Program).

  • "Our finding on student-teacher ratios suggests that schools hired fewer teachers as a result of the enrollment declines," said Dee. "Our finding on the share of disadvantaged students enrolled suggests either that the affected Hispanic students were not concentrated among low-income families, or that the displaced Hispanic students were more disadvantaged but the ICE partnerships also harmed local economic activity, lowering the family incomes of remaining students."

  • "It's important to note that our findings are based on data from 2000 to 2011 when these ICE partnerships received measured support from the Bush and Obama administrations," said Mark Murphy, a PhD candidate at Stanford University. "Given the recent support for the rapid expansion of such partnerships under the Trump administration, these results have contemporary policy relevance."

  • The authors note that according to Executive Order 13767, issued by President Donald Trump on January 25, 2017, the adoption of new ICE partnerships were to be enacted with immediacy and, according to Trump, "to the maximum extent permitted by law."

  • "The number of ICE partnerships has increased dramatically during the Trump administration," said Murphy. "ICE currently has 90 active agreements with local law-enforcement agencies. The increased scale of these 'reverse sanctuary' policies suggests that their educational, economic, and social costs may be even more severe. We hope to extend our research to study the impact of the most recent ICE partnerships as well."
Periodically, AERA will issue a brief overview, or snapshot, of a recent study that has been published in one of its peer-reviewed journals. AERA "Study Snapshots" provide a high-level glimpse into new education research.

Study: "Vanished Classmates: The Effects of Local Immigration Enforcement on School Enrollment"

Authors: Thomas Dee (Stanford University), Mark Murphy (Stanford University)

Published online July 2, 2019, in the American Educational Research Journal, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Educational Research Association.

To talk to the study authors, please contact AERA Communications: Tony Pals, Director of Communications,, (202) 238-3235, (202) 288-9333 (cell); Collin Boylin, Communications Associate,, (202) 238-3233, (860) 490-8326 (cell).

To browse more recent AERA-published research, click here.

About AERA

The American Educational Research Association (AERA) is the largest national interdisciplinary research association devoted to the scientific study of education and learning. Founded in 1916, AERA advances knowledge about education, encourages scholarly inquiry related to education, and promotes the use of research to improve education and serve the public good. Find AERA on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.


Tony Pals,
(202) 238-3235, (202) 288-9333 (cell)

Collin Boylin,
(202) 238-3233, (860) 490-8326 (cell)

American Educational Research Association

Related Immigration Articles:

Arrival of refugees in Eastern German communities has no effect on voting behavior, attitudes on immigration
The arrival of refugees in eastern German communities has had no effect on local residents' voting behavior or on their attitudes toward immigration, finds a new study of citizens in more than 200 regional municipalities.
Attitudes toward race, immigration underscored vote switching in 2016 election
It's estimated that around 9% of voters who supported Barack Obama in 2012 crossed party lines to endorse Donald Trump in 2016 -- but why?
Vanished classmates: The effects of immigration enforcement on school enrollment
Partnerships between Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and local police departments designed to enforce immigration laws reduced the number of Hispanic students in US public schools in adopting counties by 10 percent after two years.
Is US immigration policy environment associated with mental health outcomes for US-born teens of of immigrant parents
The current immigration policy environment in America appears to be associated with reported adverse mental health outcomes among US-born children of Latinx immigrants.
Courts' sentencing of Hispanic defendants differs by destination, citizenship, year
A new study examined whether federal courts in areas where Hispanics have historically immigrated handed out sentences differently than federal courts in areas that are new destinations for Hispanic immigration, and how those sentences differed by citizenship.
Immigration is beneficial to economies, even after 100 years
A new paper published in the Review of Economic Studies finds that US counties with more historical immigration have higher incomes, less poverty, and lower unemployment today.
Brexit as much due to resistance to supranationalism as immigration
The UK referendum vote to leave the European Union (EU) may have had as much to do with people's distrust of international organisations as it did fear of immigration.
Immigration to the United States changes a person's microbiome
Researchers at the University of Minnesota and the Somali, Latino, and Hmong Partnership for Health and Wellness have new evidence that the gut microbiota of immigrants and refugees rapidly Westernize after a person's arrival in the United States.
Immigration restrictions for EU citizens could damage UK research and healthcare
An analysis of senior European scientists and doctors working in the UK underlines the high risk of considerable damage to the UK's science output and international research reputation caused by any post-Brexit immigration restrictions, as well as an associated reduction in healthcare quality.
The road to November: New poll monitors public attitudes on race, immigration leading up to midterms
A new study developed by Cornell University researchers will use three waves of surveys to show how voters' views on issues that include race, immigration and gender will influence the 2018 midterm elections in November and whether those attitudes shift leading up to the elections.
More Immigration News and Immigration Current Events

Top Science Podcasts

We have hand picked the top science podcasts of 2019.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Accessing Better Health
Essential health care is a right, not a privilege ... or is it? This hour, TED speakers explore how we can give everyone access to a healthier way of life, despite who you are or where you live. Guests include physician Raj Panjabi, former NYC health commissioner Mary Bassett, researcher Michael Hendryx, and neuroscientist Rachel Wurzman.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#543 Give a Nerd a Gift
Yup, you guessed it... it's Science for the People's annual holiday episode that helps you figure out what sciency books and gifts to get that special nerd on your list. Or maybe you're looking to build up your reading list for the holiday break and a geeky Christmas sweater to wear to an upcoming party. Returning are pop-science power-readers John Dupuis and Joanne Manaster to dish on the best science books they read this past year. And Rachelle Saunders and Bethany Brookshire squee in delight over some truly delightful science-themed non-book objects for those whose bookshelves are already full. Since...
Now Playing: Radiolab

An Announcement from Radiolab