Nav: Home

'No evidence' grammar schools can promote social mobility, study suggests

July 12, 2018

Expanding the number of grammar schools is unlikely to promote social mobility by providing more opportunities for disadvantaged pupils, a new study published in Educational Review finds.

Study author Binwei Lu, of Durham University, used England's National Pupil Database to show how a child's chances of going to grammar school varied depending on the Local Authority (LA) in which they lived, their social and ethnic background, and their attainment level at primary school. The database included more than 600,000 pupils, of which around 186,000 were in the 36 LAs with grammar schools.

In those LAs, the proportion of pupils attending such schools varied widely: from 1.4 to 37.4 per cent. Selection criteria also varied, with pupils in certain LAs needing to achieve more than twice the Key Stage 2 marks of those in other LAs to have any chance of being admitted.

As a result, applying in a different LA - an option more readily available to more affluent families - could increase a child's chances.

"While it is often mentioned that coaching gives more affluent pupils an unfair advantage in grammar school selection, our study suggests that a simpler, but effective action for the rich would be to let their children sit the 11+ in other Local Authorities with more grammar school opportunities," Miss Lu noted.

The study also found that pupils eligible for free school meals, pupils with special educational needs, native English speakers, and white pupils were less likely to go to grammar schools, while those from more affluent areas and from minority ethnic groups were more likely to attend.

Despite these differences, the research showed that, during the selection process, attainment was more important than personal background, indicating no bias towards certain groups of pupils in the selection process itself. Rather, the inequality of opportunity to go to grammar school for pupils from different backgrounds was probably the result of diverging attainment among these different groups at the end of primary education.

"While this outcome demonstrates the relatively equitable process of grammar school enrolment based on selection criteria, there is also no evidence that grammar schools can help the poor, as their likelihood of attending such schools is limited," Miss Lu said.

"If secondary schools are allowed to select based on attainment, they are thus selecting pupils from more advantaged backgrounds. The assumption that grammar schools promote social mobility is therefore unsound.

"On the contrary, if grammar schools do perform better than other state schools, they will widen the gap between children from high and low socioeconomic groups by offering higher Key Stage 4 results for their pupils. In the meantime, pupils without sufficient family support, who thus perform worse than they would have otherwise at the age of 11, will lag further behind as they will be enrolled in less effective secondary schools."
-end-


Taylor & Francis Group

Related Pupils Articles:

Is it okay for children to count on their fingers?
Is it OK for children to count on their fingers?
No evidence that enrichment activities encourage pupils to study STEM A-levels
There is no evidence to suggest enrichment activities run to interest pupils in science, technology, engineering and maths results in significantly higher numbers of teenagers studying these subjects at A-level.
Teenagers can become disruptive if teachers use psychological pressure
The study, which was led by Stephen Earl from the University's School of Sport and Exercise Sciences, discovered that psychological pressure from teachers can contribute to disengagement amongst teenage pupils under 14.
Are you listening? Your pupils indicate if you are
A new Dartmouth study finds that listeners are most likely to tune in when a speaker delivers the most emotional peaks of his/her narrative, as revealed by synchronous pupil dilation patterns of speakers and listeners due to shared attention.
Measurements by school pupils paved way for key research findings
With their measurements and samples, nearly 3,500 schoolchildren have assisted a research study on lakes and global warming, now published in the journal Scientific Reports.
Cyberbullying rarely occurs in isolation, research finds
Cyberbullying is mostly an extension of playground bullying -- and doesn't create large numbers of new victims -- according to research from the University of Warwick.
Brainy teens may be less likely to smoke, but more likely to drink and use cannabis
Brainy teens may be less likely to smoke, but more likely to drink alcohol and use cannabis, than their less academically gifted peers, suggests research published in the online journal BMJ Open.
STEM enrichment activities have no impact on results
Enrichment activities to encourage pupils to study science and technology subjects have made no difference to their performance in mathematics exams, new research shows.
Creative mathematical tasks contribute to deeper learning in mathematics
Working with creative mathematical tasks is important for pupils both to reflect on mathematics as well as for their subsequent test results.
Weird pupils let octopuses see their colorful gardens
A UC Berkeley student and his Harvard astrophysicist father propose a way that cephalopods -- octopus, squid and cuttlefish -- can detect color despite being technically colorblind.

Related Pupils Reading:

The Pupil
by Dawn Goodwin (Author)

Minimus Pupil's Book: Starting out in Latin
by Barbara Bell (Author), Helen Forte (Illustrator)

The Pupil: Poems
by W. S. Merwin (Author)

Chopin: Pianist and Teacher: As Seen by his Pupils
by Jean-Jacques Eigeldinger (Editor), Naomi Shohet (Editor), Krysia Osostowicz (Editor), Dr Roy Howat (Editor)

Power Up Level 1 Pupil's Book
by Caroline Nixon (Author), Michael Tomlinson (Author)

Minimus Secundus Pupil's Book: Moving on in Latin
by Barbara Bell (Author), Helen Forte (Illustrator)

The Pupil (Caper Court)
by Caro Fraser (Author)

The Little Eye Book: A Pupil's Guide to Understanding Ophthalmology
by Janice K. Ledford COMT (Author)

100 Ideas for Supporting Pupils with Dyspraxia and DCD
by Amanda Kirby (Author), Lynne Peters (Author)

Pupil Book 4 (Collins Primary Literacy) (Bk. 4)
by Ann Webley (Author)

Best Science Podcasts 2018

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2018. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Dying Well
Is there a way to talk about death candidly, without fear ... and even with humor? How can we best prepare for it with those we love? This hour, TED speakers explore the beauty of life ... and death. Guests include lawyer Jason Rosenthal, humorist Emily Levine, banker and travel blogger Michelle Knox, mortician Caitlin Doughty, and entrepreneur Lux Narayan.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#491 Frankenstein LIVES
Two hundred years ago, Mary Shelley gave us a legendary monster, shaping science fiction for good. Thanks to her, the name of Frankenstein is now famous world-wide. But who was the real monster here? The creation? Or the scientist that put him together? Tune in to a live show from Dragon Con 2018 in Atlanta, as we breakdown the science of Frankenstein, complete with grave robbing and rivers of maggots. Featuring Tina Saey, Lucas Hernandez, Travor Valle, and Nancy Miorelli. Moderated by our own Bethany Brookshire. Related links: Scientists successfully transplant lab-grown lungs into pigs, by Maria Temming on Science...