Do campaign finance reforms truly help make elections more competitive?

July 15, 2020

Proponents of campaign finance reform claim that putting limits on how much money can be raised and spent to support a political candidate leads to more competitive elections by helping level the political playing field between incumbents -- the people holding the political office -- and challengers. However, a new study by two social scientists at the University of Missouri finds state campaign finance reforms actually have no beneficial effect on the competitiveness of state legislative elections. Instead, some reforms, such as limits on corporate political spending and public financing of elections, advantage incumbents.

Jeff Milyo, a professor and chair of the Department of Economics in the MU College of Arts and Science, said the study improves on previous studies conducted prior to the ruling in the U.S. Supreme Court case, "Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission." The ruling struck down state laws prohibiting corporations from using their money for political advertising as a violation of the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of speech.

In the study, researchers examined the competitiveness of state legislative elections before and after various changes in state laws, such as this ruling, Milyo said.

"Our analysis of nearly 66,000 state contests over 30 years -- from 1986 to 2018 -- reveals that most campaign finance reforms have little impact on state legislative elections," Milyo said. "But if anything, the much-maligned Citizens United decision has led to an increase in electoral competitiveness. That decision, which struck down regulations in a number of states, provides a kind of natural experiment to examine the relationship between corporate political spending and the incumbency advantage in state legislative elections."

Milyo said the study also demonstrates that full public financing of legislative elections, or "clean money" reforms that provide a set amount of financing to candidates, may also favor the reelection of an incumbent state legislator. He said it can be difficult for challengers to be successful in winning an election over a longtime state legislator.

"Challengers need to be able to raise and spend money to overcome the many advantages that incumbent legislators enjoy in elections," Milyo said. "That's why campaign finance reforms that limit political spending do not increase competitiveness in elections and sometimes have the opposite effect as might have been intended."
The study, "Do campaign finance reforms insulate incumbents from competition? New evidence from state legislative elections," was published in PS: Political Science and Politics, a quarterly journal of the American Political Science Association. Jordan Butcher, an assistant professor of political science at Arkansas State University, is a co-author on the study. Butcher graduated this year from MU with a doctorate in political science.

University of Missouri-Columbia

Related Competitiveness Articles from Brightsurf:

Siberian scientists identified the most promising Russian forest products
A team of scientists from Siberian Federal University evaluated the competitiveness of Russian forest industry products by analyzing international trade data from different regions of the country and comparing it to the data from other markets.

Do campaign finance reforms truly help make elections more competitive?
A new study by two social scientists at the University of Missouri finds state campaign finance reforms actually have no beneficial effect on the competitiveness of state legislative elections.

Laws help reduce pollution and do not affect competitiveness, study finds
Researchers from the University of Granada, in collaboration with the universities of Berkeley and Minnesota, have conducted a review of the most important international scholarship on environmental regulation and firms The researchers propose that international initiatives, such as the World Climate Summit in Madrid, should provide the basis for more effective future regulations Their findings have been published in the research journal with the greatest worldwide impact in the fields of business and business management

Closing the gender gap in competitiveness with a psychological trick
The degree of willingness among men and women to assert themselves in competition can be balanced out.

Impact of weather and well-timed cultural management techniques on organic weed control
Weed management can be a tough challenge in organic cropping systems since growers don't have herbicides in their weed control arsenal.

Foreign investments crucial for positive return on exports
Experts at Higher School of Economics have shown that the availability of direct foreign investment is an important and necessary condition for positive return on exports for companies operating in foreign markets.

What mitigates the consequences of recession for companies?
Experts of the Higher School of Economics (HSE) demonstrated that companies with foreign ownership have an easier time overcoming the consequences of economic recessions.

Researchers find optimal rules for seedings in knock-out tournaments
Researchers from the Higher School of Economics and the Stanford Graduate School of Business have conducted a study on tournaments using the playoff system, which is one of the most popular forms of sporting competitions.

Low-dose diazepam can increase social competitiveness
EPFL scientists have discovered how low-dose anxiolytics increase the social competitiveness of high-anxious individuals by boosting the energy output of mitochondria in an area of the mammalian brain that controls motivation and reward.

What do your co-workers really think of you?
Everyday in the workplace, colleagues actively compete for a limited amount of perks, including raises, promotions, bonuses and recognition.

Read More: Competitiveness News and Competitiveness Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to