Kidney transplant, the cost of accounting for patients' preferences

July 17, 2020

VENICE - From the moment a kidney becomes available, there are just 24 hours to identify the recipient and carry out the transplant. Waiting lists are extremely long, available organs are few and not all of them are 'ideal'. Furthermore, a recipient has the ability to 'refuse' a kidney, for instance by continuing with the dialysis treatment while waiting for a better moment, thus complicating the race against time to carry out the transplant.

This issue involving the scarcity of resources and an array of delicate choices, could be resolved in a more efficient manner if the allocation system accounted for the patients' preferences, alongside parameters of compatibility, age and waiting time.

These are the results of a study recently published in the Journal of Health Economics by Giacomo Pasini, professor of Economics at Ca' Foscari University of Venice, co-authored by Mesfin G. Genie - who received its PhD in Economics at Ca' Foscari and is now working at the University of Aberdeen - and Antonio Nicolò of the University of Padua. The field work was made possible thanks to a strategic project fund granted by the University of Padua.

The economists interviewed 248 patients on the waiting list for a kidney transplant at the Kidney and Pancreas Transplantation Unit of the University of Padua's School of Medicine, one of the key centres in Italy, with over 2000 operations completed.

The experiment allowed the researchers to analyze the patients' preferences regarding different variables such as waiting time, post-graft life expectancy, infection risk and the neoplastic risk.

Patients who are not willing to take any risks, for example, might want to wait longer to get the 'perfect' kidney. Conversely, patients who find the dialysis treatment particularly unbearable, such as parents of young children whose life quality is seriously hindered by the number of hours they need to spend in the hospital, could be willing to accept an augmented risk kidney, just so they can get the transplant as soon as possible.

"We found a significant heterogeneity in the preferences of patients who are waiting for a transplant - explains Giacomo Pasini - Furthermore, we have proved how including patients' preferences in the kidney allocation algorithm would considerably improve both the patients' satisfaction and the expected graft survival"

The study has also tackled the internationally relevant topic of the so-called "marginal" kidney - that is to say potentially suitable kidneys, but inferior to standard criteria.

Examples are: kidneys from deceased older donors or those of a young person who died in a car crash, as a residual infection risk cannot be excluded.

"Marginal kidneys are currently offered only to those patients who have been on the waiting list for a long time - stated Professor Pasini - our article suggests there might be more patients who are willing to accept a marginal kidney right away. Broadly speaking, we are putting forward a way to improve the kidney allocation system that could improve both the efficiency of the procedure (an increase in the number of transplants completed) and the life quality of the patients".

Università Ca' Foscari Venezia

Related Kidney Transplant Articles from Brightsurf:

The effects of social determinants of health on kidney transplant candidates
Social determinants of health are associated with patient-reported outcomes in adults who are eligible to undergo kidney transplantation evaluations.

Tailored education system to benefit kidney transplant patients
Researchers find their computer-tailored education system, 'Your Path to Transplant' increases knowledge and readiness to pursue kidney transplant.

Kidney transplant, the cost of accounting for patients' preferences
Taking into account patients' preferences can help speed up the organ allocation process and improve the life quality of the recipients, as shown by a joint study conducted by Ca' Foscari University and the University of Padua

New hope for kidney revival for transplant
Cell therapy delivered directly to the kidney can revive a 'marginal' organ, improving function and could offer new hope for providing more kidneys for transplant.

Are kidney transplant patients at higher risk? The European experience
The risk of death is relatively high in kidney transplant patients admitted to hospital with COVID-19.

The economic burden of kidney transplant failure in the United States
A recent analysis published in the American Journal of Transplantation estimates that for the average US patient who has undergone kidney transplantation, failure of the transplanted organ (graft failure) will impose additional medical costs of $78,079 and a loss of 1.66 quality-adjusted life years.

Mixed chimerism improves long-term kidney transplant outlook
Mixed chimerism - the continued mixing of donor and recipient blood cells following a transplant of blood progenitor cells - could improve outcomes for kidney transplant recipients, according to a new clinical study in about 50 patients.

Kidney paired donation is an excellent option for transplant candidates
An analysis compared transplant recipients who received kidneys through national kidney paired donation and those who received kidneys from other living donors (such as relatives, friends or other paired exchange mechanisms).

Mediterranean diet may help preserve the kidney health of transplant recipients
In a study of kidney transplant recipients, those with higher adherence to the Mediterranean diet were less likely to experience kidney function loss.

New blood test can detect rejection by antibodies after kidney transplant
A group of European scientists led by KU Leuven has found a biomarker that can identify patients with symptoms of kidney rejection symptoms after a transplant as a result of antibodies.

Read More: Kidney Transplant News and Kidney Transplant Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to