Sprawl may threaten wildlife in reserves

July 22, 2002

Rural sprawl may be driving species toward local extinction. New research suggests that ranchettes in the Yellowstone area could degrade the best habitat for birds and so cut their population growth below sustainable levels.

"Our findings suggest that alteration and destruction of the remaining productive habitats outside nature reserves will pose dire threats to many wildlife populations," say Andrew Hansen and Jay Rotella of Montana State University in Bozeman in the August issue of Conservation Biology.

Globally, development is concentrated near biodiversity hotspots. This is partly because private lands are more likely to have productive habitats such as lowlands and coastal and riparian areas, which generally have moderate climates, ample water and fertile soil. In contrast, reserves are more likely to be at higher elevations and have poor soil, which makes them less productive. This disparity means that species in a reserve may depend on the more productive habitat on nearby private lands, making the species vulnerable to development outside the reserve.

Hansen and Rotella studied the effects of land use and habitat type on bird populations in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem (GYE), where rural residential development has increased rapidly. Development has increased more than four times since 1970 in the Montana and Wyoming parts of the GYE. The 3,600-square mile study area ranged from a high-elevation plateau in Yellowstone National Park to privately-owned lowlands. The researchers assessed bird abundance and diversity at 100 sites that represented the study area's range of topography, climate and soils. 135 bird species were found in the study area, and sites estimated to have 60% or more of the maximum bird abundance and diversity were designated "bird hotspots". The researchers also assessed the reproduction and population growth of American robins and yellow warblers at two types of sites: low-elevation cottonwood stands and high-elevation aspen stands.

Hansen and Rotella found that most of the bird hotspots were on or near private lands, which were mostly at low elevations. Only about 7% of the bird hotspots were in reserves, which were mostly at higher elevations. In addition, rural residential development was concentrated near the bird hotspots on private lands. Home densities were nearly 70% higher within about a mile of hotspots than elsewhere on private lands.

The proximity of development to the low-elevation hotspots could mean trouble for the birds. Hansen and Rotella found that robins may depend on the low-elevation hotspots: the results suggest that robin populations are increasing in the cottonwood but not in the aspen sites. The researchers attribute this to the fact that the robin nesting season is two weeks longer in the low-elevation cottonwoods than in the high-elevation aspen, giving females more opportunity to renest.

The researchers also found that yellow warblers may already be threatened by development. The results suggest that even though more females are renesting in the cottonwoods presumably because robins chase these parasites away. Robins also chase potential nest predators.

The birds' dependence on hotspots on private lands and the yellow warbler's vulnerability to development suggest that reserves may not be enough to protect biodiversity. "These trends cast doubt on the viability of current strategies that rely on nature reserves for wildlife conservation and ignore intervening lands. Conservation strategies to protect population source areas outside reserves are likely necessary to reduce rates of future extinction in nature reserves," say Hansen and Rotella. Their work could help managers figure out which lands outside of reserves should be protected.
*Andrew Hansen (406-994-6046, hansen@montana.edu)
[NOTE: he will be unavailable July 25-26 and August 3-9]
*Jay Rotella (406-994-4558, rotella@montana.edu)

http://www.homepage.montana.edu/~hansen/hansen/lab/, the warbler populations are still shrinking there. The researchers attribute this in part to the fact that the cottonwoods are surrounded by rural residential development, and areas with denser development also have more nest predators (such as magpies and crows) and cowbirds, parasites that lay their eggs in other birds' nests. For instance, the researchers found that cowbird parasitism of warbler nests was five times higher in cottonwoods than in aspens (about 44 vs. 9%). Cowbirds did not lay eggs in robin nests,

For PDFs of papers, contact Robin Meadows: robin@nasw.org
[NOTE: I will be on vacation 7/27-31]

To register for media access to our expert directory and back issues of our journal:

For more information about the Society for Conservation Biology:

Society for Conservation Biology

Related Population Growth Articles from Brightsurf:

Violent encounters between gorillas slow population growth rate
A new study by the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund and UC Davis used five decades of data to show how social behavior explains fluctuations in the growth rate of a subpopulation of mountain gorillas.

New insights into colorectal cancer: Growth factor R-spondin suppresses tumor growth
R-spondin, which enhances the growth of healthy cells in the gut, suppresses the growth of intestinal adenoma cells, thus reducing the formation of intestinal tumors.

How birth control, girls' education can slow population growth
Education and family planning have long been tied to lower fertility trends.

The Lancet: World population likely to shrink after mid-century, forecasting major shifts in global population and economic power
World's population likely to shrink after mid-century, forecasting major shifts in global population and economic power - new analysis, published in The Lancet forecasts global, regional, and national populations, mortality, fertility, and migration for 195 countries worldwide.

Planning for a growing elderly population
The fact that people are living longer lives represents one of the crowning achievements of the last century, but also requires careful planning on the part of governments.

How Human Population came from our ability to cooperate
Humans' ability to cooperate during child-bearing years by sharing food, labor, and childcare duties is the story of population growth.

North Carolina coastal flooding is worsening with climate change, population growth
Researchers can confirm what data modeling systems have predicted: Climate change is increasing precipitation events like hurricanes, tropical storms and floods.

Access to contraception not 'silver bullet' to stem population growth in Africa
The population of sub-Saharan Africa is set to double by 2050, yet a new study challenges a common misconception that this is caused solely by inadequate family planning.

Nations with strong women's rights likely to have better population health and faster growth
Nations with strong women's rights are more likely to have better health and faster growth than those who don't promote and protect these values, finds research published in the online journal BMJ Open.

Bacterial population growth rate linked to how individual cells control their size
Physicists from the University of Pennsylvania have developed a model that describes how individual parameters, like the variability in growth and the timing of cell division, can influence population dynamics in bacteria.

Read More: Population Growth News and Population Growth Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.