Stem-cell research: Drawing the line

July 23, 2001

Research with human embryonic stem cells may lead to a revolution in medical science. The pace of research on stem cells, first in mice, now in primates, including human beings, has left little time to consider carefully the ethical issues involved, yet these are some of the most difficult ever raised by medical research. Embryonic stem cells are pluripotent, meaning they are capable of developing into any cell type in the human body. Animal research suggests stem cells may some day provide a way to repair or replace diseased tissues and organs and make it possible to treat people with a wide variety of conditions, such as diabetes, Parkinson's disease, and Alzheimer's disease, for which we currently have no cure. But because harvesting human embryonic stem cells requires the destruction of an embryo, a potential human life, such research also raises troubling ethical issues.

Embryonic stem cells are harvested from three sources: aborted fetuses, so-called cadaveric stem cells; embryos left over from in-vitro fertilisation efforts, so-called discarded embryos; and embryos created in the laboratory solely for the purpose of producing stem cells, so-called research embryos. Opposition to the use of embryonic stem cells from any of these sources comes mainly from those who hold that human life begins at conception and that destroying an embryo at any stage of development is tantamount to infanticide. Advocates of embryonic stem-cell research hold that while embryos certainly deserve respect they are not yet fully human and that the good that may result from medical research studies with their cells justifies their use.

Some stem cells, however, have also been isolated from adult tissues, and opponents of human embryonic stem-cell research argue that research should be limited to such cells. But the general view of scientists working in this area is that adult stem cells, while they may one day prove useful for treatment, are simply not as versatile as their embryonic counterparts, because they are already partly differentiated. In the USA, where there is a bitter fight over federal funding for stem-cell research (see page 217), more than 80 Nobel Laureates signed a letter to President George Bush arguing against regulations that would limit research to those stem cells derived from adult tissues. Indeed, the prospect of restrictions on the use of embryos as a source of stem cells has led to fears of a US brain drain. One leading US stem-cell researcher, Roger Pedersen from the University of California, San Francisco, announced this week that he was moving to the UK-"to get some work done", he was quoted as saying.

In Europe, a report by members of the High Level Expert Group of the European Science Foundation last month arrived at a similar conclusion to their US colleagues, saying that it "is essential to proceed with research on stem cells derived from embryos, fetal tissues and adults, in parallel". And in the UK, the Chief Medical Officer's Expert Group on Therapeutic Cloning in a report published last year also raised concerns about the limitations of stem cells extracted from adult tissues. "It may in the future become possible to reprogramme adult cells to behave like stem cells but at the moment this remains largely hypothetical."

As a review in the current issue of Cell points out, the concept of the stem cell is changing. Stem cells might be better thought of not as fixed cellular entities, but rather in terms of their biological function. Such functions might be induced in different cell types, both embryonic and adult. The focus on function instead of cell type helps take us away from emotive and ultimately irreconcilable debate about the status of the embryo.

Given the potential benefits of human stem-cell research, use of cadaveric cells and embryos surplus to fertility treatments seems justified on pragmatic grounds. For the present, the potential for adult stem cells is at this time too uncertain. However, the creation of embryos solely for the purpose of creating stem cells is more difficult to accept, because, for all practical purposes, they are being treated as a product to be exploited. Although the creation of human embryos for research has been allowed in the UK since 1990, the practice has been tightly regulated. At this time, given the large supply of discarded embryos that is available-more than 100 000 in the USA alone, according to some estimates-the creation of embryos solely for the purpose of producing human stem cells is not only unnecessary but also a step too far.


Related Stem Cells Articles from Brightsurf:

SUTD researchers create heart cells from stem cells using 3D printing
SUTD researchers 3D printed a micro-scaled physical device to demonstrate a new level of control in the directed differentiation of stem cells, enhancing the production of cardiomyocytes.

More selective elimination of leukemia stem cells and blood stem cells
Hematopoietic stem cells from a healthy donor can help patients suffering from acute leukemia.

Computer simulations visualize how DNA is recognized to convert cells into stem cells
Researchers of the Hubrecht Institute (KNAW - The Netherlands) and the Max Planck Institute in Münster (Germany) have revealed how an essential protein helps to activate genomic DNA during the conversion of regular adult human cells into stem cells.

First events in stem cells becoming specialized cells needed for organ development
Cell biologists at the University of Toronto shed light on the very first step stem cells go through to turn into the specialized cells that make up organs.

Surprising research result: All immature cells can develop into stem cells
New sensational study conducted at the University of Copenhagen disproves traditional knowledge of stem cell development.

The development of brain stem cells into new nerve cells and why this can lead to cancer
Stem cells are true Jacks-of-all-trades of our bodies, as they can turn into the many different cell types of all organs.

Healthy blood stem cells have as many DNA mutations as leukemic cells
Researchers from the Princess Máxima Center for Pediatric Oncology have shown that the number of mutations in healthy and leukemic blood stem cells does not differ.

New method grows brain cells from stem cells quickly and efficiently
Researchers at Lund University in Sweden have developed a faster method to generate functional brain cells, called astrocytes, from embryonic stem cells.

NUS researchers confine mature cells to turn them into stem cells
Recent research led by Professor G.V. Shivashankar of the Mechanobiology Institute at the National University of Singapore and the FIRC Institute of Molecular Oncology in Italy, has revealed that mature cells can be reprogrammed into re-deployable stem cells without direct genetic modification -- by confining them to a defined geometric space for an extended period of time.

Researchers develop a new method for turning skin cells into pluripotent stem cells
Researchers at the University of Helsinki, Finland, and Karolinska Institutet, Sweden, have for the first time succeeded in converting human skin cells into pluripotent stem cells by activating the cell's own genes.

Read More: Stem Cells News and Stem Cells Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to