Greater financial integration generally not associated with better healthcare quality

August 03, 2020

The COVID-19 pandemic has led to severe financial stress for both hospitals and physician practices, raising serious concerns that many may either close or be purchased by larger organizations. Such consolidation is well-recognized to lead to higher prices. Whether it will lead to better quality of care is less clear.

A new study published in the August Issue of Health Affairs, based on the first comprehensive national survey of physician practices, hospitals and health systems, found that larger, more integrated systems do not generally deliver better quality. "We looked at a broad range of quality measures and compared independent hospitals and practices with those owned by different kinds of health systems," said Elliott Fisher, MD, MPH, lead author and professor of medicine and health policy at Dartmouth. "In no case was ownership by larger, more complex health systems associated with better quality."

Another key finding from the study was the remarkable degree of variation in quality scores across hospitals and physician practices, regardless of whether they were independent or owned by larger systems. "This degree of variation points to tremendous opportunities to improve the quality of care in both hospitals and practices," said Stephen Shortell, PhD, Professor of the Graduate School, University of California, Berkeley. "We must continue to put in place the incentives and programs needed to drive improvement."

The research team assessed the degree to which hospitals and physician practices under several different ownership structures--including financial independence and financial integration with larger health systems--adopted care delivery and payment reforms intended to improve quality. They analyzed data from the National Survey of Healthcare Organizations and Systems, which included responses from 2,190 physician practices and 739 hospitals that were collected between June 2017 and August 2018. The surveys included questions about care for complex, high-need patients; participation in quality-focused payment programs; screening for clinical conditions and social needs; and use of registries and evidence-based guidelines.

"The policy implications of this research are clear," said Carrie Colla, PhD, professor of health policy and clinical practice at Dartmouth, who worked as a policy advisor in Congress during a recent sabbatical. "With Covid-19 wreaking financial havoc on smaller healthcare organizations, policy makers--both at the federal and state levels--should ensure that purchases of practices and hospitals adhere to current antitrust law. They should also consider financial support for those most threatened by the pandemic."
This research is part of Dartmouth's broader efforts as one of three national Centers of Excellence on Health System Performance to understand how health systems' use of evidence-based innovations affects healthcare quality, delivery, and costs. Dartmouth receives funding for this work from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and collaborates with researchers at the University of California, Berkeley; the University of California, San Francisco; the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill; Harvard University; and the Mayo Clinic.

The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice is a world leader in studying and advancing models for disruptive change in healthcare delivery. The work of Dartmouth Institute faculty and researchers includes developing the concept of shared decision-making between patients and healthcare professionals, creating the model for Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs), and introducing the game-changing concept that more healthcare is not necessarily better care.

The Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth

Related Health Policy Articles from Brightsurf:

Investment, health policy changes are key for new Alzheimer's treatments
Two new USC reports describe a challenging obstacle course for patients to access Alzheimer's disease treatments once they become available.

Growing volume of gun policy research creates basis for policy decisions
While research about many gun policies still lags, a surging number of studies now provides the evidence needed to make sound decisions on policies designed to reduce homicides and injuries while protecting individuals' rights.

ACP calls for comprehensive reform of US health in a series of policy papers
The American College of Physicians issued a bold call to action challenging the US to implement systematic reform of the healthcare system, and released an ambitious new vision for a better health care system for all and expansive policy recommendations for how to achieve it.

Oral health effects of tobacco products: Science and regulatory policy proceedings
AADR held the 'Oral Health Effects of Tobacco Products: Science and Regulatory Policy' meeting.

Is US immigration policy environment associated with mental health outcomes for US-born teens of of immigrant parents
The current immigration policy environment in America appears to be associated with reported adverse mental health outcomes among US-born children of Latinx immigrants.

Silver loading and switching: Unintended consequences of pulling health policy levers
A move by the White House in 2017 -- decried by many health policy analysts as an attempt to undercut the Affordable Care Act (ACA) -- had unanticipated consequences that improved the affordability of health insurance for Marketplace enrollees.

African-American men's health disparities: Research, practice, and policy implications
The burden of risk factors for chronic disease is substantially higher in black men compared with their white counterparts, including a higher prevalence of obesity and hypertension.

Tragic death of baby highlights need for vitamin D public health policy change
UK vitamin D supplementation policy needs to change to protect the health and lives of babies, pregnant women and dark skinned individuals, say University of Birmingham researchers.

Study: Health benefits will offset cost of China's climate policy
China's climate policy should pay for itself: A new MIT study finds that a four percent reduction per year in carbon emissions should net the country $339 billion in health savings.

Diagnosing the impacts of health policy
KAUST shows a new statistical technique offers a better way to gauge the effectiveness of complex healthcare interventions.

Read More: Health Policy News and Health Policy Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to