Universal screening for intimate partner violence may provide only modest benefits

August 04, 2009

New research suggests that universal intimate partner violence (IPV) screening in health care settings does not result in significant changes in subsequent reports of IPV or quality of life, according to a study in the August 5 issue of JAMA, a theme issue on violence and human rights.

There is a lack of consensus on the issue of screening women for IPV in health care settings. Proponents support screening because of the high prevalence of IPV and associated impairment and the availability of feasible screening techniques. But organizations such as the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and the Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care have concluded that insufficient evidence exists to recommend for or against universal screening - mainly due to lack of interventions that have been proven effective for women exposed to violence and referred from health care settings. "Nevertheless, clinicians and health care organizations are being encouraged to implement IPV screening. Numerous professional societies recommend routine IPV evaluation, assessment, and/or screening as a part of standard patient care, and the standards of the Joint Commission require that hospitals have objective criteria for identifying and assessing possible victims of abuse and neglect," the authors write.

Harriet L. MacMillan, M.D., M.Sc., F.R.C.P.C., of McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, and colleagues examined the effectiveness of IPV screening and communication of a positive screening result to clinicians in health care settings, compared with no screening, in reducing subsequent violence and improving quality of life. The randomized controlled trial was conducted in 11 emergency departments, 12 family practices, and 3 obstetrics/gynecology clinics in Ontario, Canada, among 6,743 female patients, age 18 to 64 years.

Women in the screened group (n = 3,271; 347 positive for abuse) self-completed the Woman Abuse Screening Tool (WAST); if a woman screened positive, this information was given to her clinician before the health care visit. Subsequent discussions and/or referrals were at the discretion of the treating clinician. The nonscreened group (n = 3,472; 360 positive for abuse) self-completed the WAST and other measures after their visit. Women who disclosed past-year IPV were interviewed at the start of the study and every 6 months until 18 months regarding subsequent incidents of IPV and quality of life, as well as several health outcomes and potential harms of screening. The number of women who did not complete the study was high: 43 percent of screened women, and 41 percent of nonscreened women, and data analysis accounted for these losses.

The study found that:
  • The authors suggest that one possible explanation for the lack of effectiveness of screening was "If it is true that study participation conferred benefits, the fact that both groups were interviewed using the same methods at the same intervals would have reduced the likelihood of detecting differences between groups. Screening itself--asking about IPV exposure--may have offered little benefit."

    They add that even though screening may provide some small benefits on some outcomes, "It is critical to balance the number and magnitude of potential benefits of universal screening with the human, opportunity, and resource costs required." In this trial, trained research assistants conducted the screening in each health care setting and clinicians were only notified when a screen was positive. All sites consented to participate, and training regarding IPV was provided to them.

    "We conclude, although sample attrition urges cautious interpretation, that these results do not provide sufficient evidence to support universal IPV screening in health care settings in the absence of an effective intervention to prevent or reduce IPV, especially in the context of the resources required to conduct screening and to deal with the number of women identified by the screening tool," the authors write. "Further research is essential to determine whether these findings are replicated in other settings and samples." They add that evidence regarding effective interventions to assist women who disclose abuse in health care settings is urgently required.

    (JAMA. 2009;302[5]:493-501. Available pre-embargo to the media at www.jamamedia.org)

    Editor's Note: Please see the article for additional information, including other authors, author contributions and affiliations, financial disclosures, funding and support, etc.

    Editorial: Preventing Intimate Partner Violence - Screening Is Not Enough

    In an accompanying editorial, Kathryn E. Moracco, Ph.D., M.P.H., and Thomas B. Cole, M.D., M.P.H., of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, (Dr. Cole is also a Contributing Editor, JAMA), comment on the findings of the study by MacMillan and colleagues.

    "... there continues to be a lack of evidence that universal screening alone improves health outcomes for IPV survivors. It is certainly understandable that clinicians and health care facilities have implemented universal screening programs, given the prevalence and potential severity of IPV. However, the results of the study by MacMillan et al should dispel any illusions that universal screening with passive referrals to community services is an adequate response to violence in intimate relationships. Specific interventions to prevent the recurrence of abuse for women at risk of violence should be implemented and rigorously tested, preferably in randomized trials, without further delay."

    (JAMA. 2009;302[5]:568-570. Available pre-embargo to the media at www.jamamedia.org)

    Editor's Note: Please see the article for additional information, including financial disclosures, funding and support, etc.

    The JAMA Network Journals

    Related Violence Articles from Brightsurf:

    Combined intimate partner violence that includes sexual violence is common & more damaging
    Women who experience sexual violence combined with other forms of intimate partner violence suffer greater damage to their health and are much more likely to attempt suicide, according to a study led by researchers at the University of Bristol's Centre for Academic Primary Care published in the International Journal of Epidemiology today [12 November 2020].

    As farming developed, so did cooperation -- and violence
    The growth of agriculture led to unprecedented cooperation in human societies, a team of researchers, has found, but it also led to a spike in violence, an insight that offers lessons for the present.

    The front line of environmental violence
    Environmental defenders on the front line of natural resource conflict are being killed at an alarming rate, according to a University of Queensland study.

    What can trigger violence in postcolonial Africa?
    Why do civil wars and coups d'├ętat occur more frequently in some sub-Saharan African countries than others.

    Another victim of violence: Trust in those who mean no harm
    Exposure to violence does not change the ability to learn who is likely to do harm, but it does damage the ability to place trust in 'good people,' psychologists at Yale and University of Oxford report April 26 in the journal Nature Communications

    Victims of gun violence tell their stories: Everyday violence, 'feelings of hopelessness'
    Invited to share their personal stories, victims of urban gun violence describe living with violence as a 'common everyday experience' and feeling abandoned by police and other societal institutions, reports a study in the November/December Journal of Trauma Nursing, official publication of the Society of Trauma Nurses.

    Does more education stem political violence?
    In a study released online today in Review of Educational Research, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Educational Research Association, three Norwegian researchers attempt to bring clarity to this question by undertaking the first systematic examination of quantitative research on this topic.

    Teen dating violence is down, but boys still report more violence than girls
    When it comes to teen dating violence, boys are more likely to report being the victim of violence -- being hit, slapped, or pushed--than girls.

    Preventing murder by addressing domestic violence
    Victims of domestic violence are at a high risk to be murdered -- or a victim of attempted murder -- according to a Cuyahoga County task force of criminal-justice professionals, victim advocates and researchers working to prevent domestic violence and homicides.

    'Love displaces violence'
    Art historian Eva-Bettina Krems on persistent motifs of peace in art from antiquity to the present day -- dove, rainbow or victory of love: artists draw on recurring motifs.

    Read More: Violence News and Violence Current Events
  • Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.