Regardless Of Race Or Gender, People Think Alike About Work, Study Shows

August 04, 1998

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. -- Every year, millions of Americans take vocational tests, almost all of them based on the Holland theory of personality types and vocational interests.

But what if the Holland-based map to the world of work was causing some people to get lost? What if certain groups of people just thought about the world of work in a different way? Other tests, after all, such as college-entrance and IQ exams, have come under fire as biased toward some groups.

No need to worry, says University of Illinois researcher Susan X Day, the author of a recent paper on the topic. When it comes to how Americans perceive different job-related activities and how they relate to one another, people apparently think remarkably alike, Day said. Race, ethnicity and gender don't appear to play a role.

Day, a doctoral student in the department of educational psychology, draws her conclusions from an analysis of the answers provided by 49,450 college-bound persons who took the ACT Interest Inventory in October 1989. Her sample, supplied on her request by ACT Inc., consisted of one-twelfth of the Caucasians and all of the African-Americans, Asian-Americans, Mexican-Americans and Native Americans who took the test at that time. For her analysis, Day also divided each of those groups by gender, to create a total of 10 groups.

Her paper on the topic, co-written by James Rounds, a U. of I. professor of educational psychology, was published in the July issue of the journal American Psychologist.

In presenting her findings at the National Career Development Association conference in July, Day noted "nobody was surprised, but everybody was very relieved it's been a concern, of course, for anyone who counsels people about careers, and it's been a concern for the people who develop and sell the tests."

Although most of those in the field of vocational testing had had confidence in the use of Holland-based tests across U.S. ethnic and racial groups, "our study is probably the first big empirical justification for thinking that," Day said.

Day said she was surprised by the "very remarkable" degree to which the 10 different groups matched up. The Holland theory lays out six occupational types in a circular order, and each type is represented in the ACT Interest Inventory by 15 related work activities, for a total of 90 items. Day used a statistical method called multidimensional scaling to plot on a graph the relationships among the 90 activities, derived from the 10 groups' responses. Not only did the activities array themselves in the expected Holland order, but all 10 groups' responses fit the same pattern with outstanding similarity.

Looking at the results, Day said: "It was just 'Eureka!' when I got the first printout. It was one of those really exciting research experiences."

[Editor's note: Ms. Day's middle initial is X, without a following period.]
-end-


University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Related Race Articles from Brightsurf:

Why do so many parents avoid talking about race?
BU social psychologists share ways adults can overcome their own assumptions and discomfort to talk honestly about race with children.

New Texas poll: Trump up in close race
President Donald Trump has an apparent lead over former Vice President Joe Biden in a close contest for Texas' 38 electoral votes according to a new poll of likely voters in the state released today.

Children notice race several years before adults want to talk about it
Adults in the United States believe children should be almost 5 years old before talking with them about race, even though some infants are aware of race and preschoolers may have already developed racist beliefs, according to new research published by the American Psychological Association.

Having a doctor who shares the same race may ease patient's angst
When doctors are the same race as their patients, it can sometimes forge a sense of comfort that helps to reduce anxiety and pain, particularly for Black patients, new research from the University of Miami suggests.

How can you sleep during a solo sailing race?
Weeks of sailing on a 6 meters boat, nothing but the ocean for four thousand miles.

How race affects listening during political conversations
A new study offers a rare look at how black and white people listen to each other during political discussions, including those that touch on controversial issues about race.

Race-specific lupus nephritis biomarkers
A University of Houston biomedical researcher has discovered a difference in urinary biomarker proteins of lupus nephritis in patients according to race.

How race is associated with differences among patients with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Researchers in this observational study looked at how race was associated with difference in symptoms, access to care, genetic testing and clinical outcomes among 2,467 patients (8.3% black and 91.7% white) with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, a condition where the heart muscle becomes abnormally thick, which can make it harder to pump blood.

Breastfeeding disparities among us children by race/ethnicity
Overall rates of breastfeeding increased from 2009 to 2015 but they varied by race/ethnicity in this observational study that used national survey data for nearly 168,000 infants in the United States.

Is giant cell arteritis associated with race?
Giant cell arteritis is an inflammation of the blood vessels that typically occurs in adults over 50 and, if left untreated, can result in irreversible vision loss and death.

Read More: Race News and Race Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.