'Accelerated approval' drugs: How well are they studied?

August 15, 2017

When an investigational prescription drug shows promise for treating a serious illness or filling an unmet medical need, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has special programs available to expedite its clinical testing and approval. One is the "Accelerated Approval" pathway, in which the FDA will accept weaker-than-usual evidence of the drug's efficacy from its pre-clinical trials. In exchange, the FDA requires that the manufacturer conduct post-approval confirmatory studies.

To understand how this pathway is implemented, in a recent study published in JAMA, researchers at Brigham and Women's Hospital and the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) examined the pre-approval and post-approval clinical trials of drugs granted FDA Accelerated Approval between 2009 and 2013. During that time, the FDA granted 22 drugs Accelerated Approval and ordered 38 post-approval studies to confirm the safety and efficacy of these drugs. Three years after the last drug's approval, the researchers found that only half of those post-approval studies had been completed. They also found that the characteristics of those completed studies did not differ much from the pre-approval studies. The researchers found that the proportion of randomized or blinded trials didn't differ and that many of the confirmatory trials still relied on surrogate measures of effect--that is, blood tests or radiological studies that may not correlate with real clinical endpoints.

"One might expect Accelerated Approval confirmatory trials to be much more rigorous than the pre-approval trials," said Aaron S. Kesselheim, MD, JD, MPH, of the BWH Division of Pharmacoepidemiology and Pharmacoeconomics and senior author of the study. "But we found that there were few differences in these key design features of the trials conducted before or after approval." In 17 out of the 18 completed studies, surrogate measures were still the primary endpoints of the studies.

"It is important to use clinical endpoints in testing investigational drugs whenever possible because there are numerous cases of drugs approved on the basis of a surrogate measure that turn out to later not effect actual clinical outcomes--or even make them worse," said Kesselheim.

To address these issues and improve the quality of Accelerated Approval confirmatory studies, Kesselheim suggests that the FDA clearly describe the limitations in the pre-approval data that will need to be addressed in post-approval studies and that they work with manufacturers to ensure that post-approval studies are conducted using design features that will be optimally useful for confirming the efficacy of the drug.
Funding for this work was supported by the Higher Education Funding Council of England and the Laura and John Arnold Foundation.

Paper cited: Naci H et al. "Characteristics of Pre-Approval and Post-Approval Studies for Drugs Granted Accelerated Approval by the US Food and Drug Administration" JAMA DOI: 10.1001/jama.2017.9415

Brigham and Women's Hospital

Related Clinical Trials Articles from Brightsurf:

Nearly 1 in 5 cancer patients less likely to enroll in clinical trials during pandemic
A significant portion of cancer patients may be less likely to enroll in a clinical trial due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

COVID-19 clinical trials lack diversity
Despite disproportionately higher rates of COVID-19 infection, hospitalization and death among people of color, minority groups are significantly underrepresented in COVID-19 clinical trials.

Why we should trust registered clinical trials
In a time when we have to rely on clinical trials for COVID-19 drugs and vaccines, a new study brings good news about the credibility of registered clinical trials.

Inclusion of children in clinical trials of treatments for COVID-19
This Viewpoint discusses the exclusion of children from coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) clinical trials and why that could harm treatment options for children.

Review evaluates how AI could boost the success of clinical trials
In a review publishing July 17, 2019 in the journal Trends in Pharmacological Sciences, researchers examined how artificial intelligence (AI) could affect drug development in the coming decade.

Kidney patients are neglected in clinical trials
The exclusion of patients with kidney diseases from clinical trials remains an unsolved problem that hinders optimal care of these patients.

Clinical trials beginning for possible preeclampsia treatment
For over 20 years, a team of researchers at Lund University has worked on developing a drug against preeclampsia -- a serious disorder which annually affects around 9 million pregnant women worldwide and is one of the main causes of death in both mothers and unborn babies.

Underenrollment in clinical trials: Patients not the problem
The authors of the study published this month in the Journal of Clinical Oncology investigated why many cancer clinical trials fail to enroll enough patients.

When designing clinical trials for huntington's disease, first ask the experts
Progress in understanding the genetic mutation responsible for Huntington's disease (HD) and at least some molecular underpinnings of the disease has resulted in a new era of clinical testing of potential treatments.

New ALS therapy in clinical trials
New research led by Washington University School of Medicine in St.

Read More: Clinical Trials News and Clinical Trials Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.