Ear thermometry not reliable for precise measurement of infants' body temperature

August 22, 2002

This release has been modified since its original posting.

Authors of a systematic review in this week's issue of THE LANCET suggest that measuring infants' body temperature in the ear is not a reliable means of assessing precise body temperature.

Infrared ear thermometry is frequently used in children--this is a quick method of taking temperature, and the ear is easily accessible. Rosalind Smyth and colleagues from the University of Liverpool, UK, evaluated the agreement between temperature measured at the rectum and ear in children.

31 comparisons (which included data for just under 4500 children) were assessed. Although the pooled mean temperature difference (rectal minus ear) was small (0.29ºC), there were some wide individual differences, suggesting that the use of ear thermometry could either overestimate or underestimate body temperature, with implications for clinical management.

Rosalind Smyth comments: "Our systematic review has shown that in children, the agreement of infrared ear thermometry with rectal temperature measurements is low, and that differences were in either direction. We used rectal temperature for the reference measure because it has shown good agreement with core body temperature and because it is an established method of measuring temperature in children. The low level of agreement between the two methods might be attributable to inaccuracies in measurement at either site. Heterogeneity between studies made comparisons difficult and could be attributable to inconsistencies in ear modes between different manufacturers. However, the implications of our findings are that measurements taken with infrared ear thermometry cannot be used as an approximation of rectal temperature, even when the device is used in rectal mode. This finding means that the presence of fever might not be detected, and accurate temperature might not be obtained in situations in which body temperature needs to be measured with precision."

In an accompanying Commentary (p 584), Segun Akinyinka from University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria, concludes: "Although tympanic thermometry is acceptable to patients, parents, and healthcare practitioners, it is not yet clear that tympanic thermometry is sufficiently accurate to measure core temperature."
-end-
Contact: Suzanne Hughes, Communications Manager, The Royal Liverpool Children's NHS Trust - Alder Hey, Eaton Road, Liverpool L12 2AP, UK; T) +44 (0)151 252 5693; F) +44 (0) 151 252 5456; E) suzanne.hughes@rlch-tr.nwest.nhs.uk

Dr Segun Akinyinka, Department of Paediatrics, College of Medicine, University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria; T) +234 2 241 3503 x2420/2751; F) +234 2 241 0588; E) asegun@hotmail.com

Lancet

Related Body Temperature Articles from Brightsurf:

History of temperature changes in the Universe revealed
How hot is the Universe today? How hot was it before?

A drop in temperature
In the nearly two centuries since German physician Carl Wunderlich established 98.6°F as the standard ''normal'' body temperature, it has been used by parents and doctors alike as the measure by which fevers -- and often the severity of illness -- have been assessed.

Get diamonds, take temperature
Measuring the temperature of objects at a nanometer-scale has been a long challenge, especially in living biological samples, because of the lack of precise and reliable nanothermometers.

Linking calorie restriction, body temperature and healthspan
Cutting calories significantly may not be an easy task for most, but it's tied to a host of health benefits ranging from longer lifespan to a much lower chance of developing cancer, heart disease, diabetes and neurodegenerative conditions such as Alzheimer's.

New method measures temperature within 3D objects
University of Wisconsin-Madison engineers have made it possible to remotely determine the temperature beneath the surface of certain materials using a new technique they call depth thermography.

Who takes the temperature in our cells?
The conditions in the environment are subject to large fluctuations.

Whole body ownership is not just the sum of each part of the body
Differences between whole body and body part ownership were clarified using scrambled body stimulation in a virtual environment, wherein the observer's hands and feet were presented in randomized spatial arrangements.

How diarrhea pathogens switch into attack mode at body temperature
Many bacterial pathogens excrete toxins as soon as they have entered the host in order to suppress its immune response.

Human body temperature has decreased in the United States, Stanford study finds
Since the early 19th century, the average human body temperature in the United States has dropped, according to a study by researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine.

T-shirt generates electricity from temperature difference between body and surroundings
Researchers of the Faculty of Science of the University of Malaga (UMA) have designed a low-cost T-shirt that generates electricity from the temperature difference between the human body and the surroundings.

Read More: Body Temperature News and Body Temperature Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.