Uninsured patients receive unpredictable, rationed access to health care

August 26, 2008

A case study of three health care institutions -- public, for-profit and not-for-profit -- within one metropolitan area found that self-pay patients must navigate a system that provides no guarantees medical centers will follow their own policies for providing uncompensated care.

The study is published in the August issue of the journal Medical Care.

"We know from previous research that the uninsured have poor outcomes on a number of measures and they are less likely to seek care when they need it," said Dr. Saul Weiner, University of Illinois at Chicago associate professor of pediatrics and internal medicine, and lead author of the study. "But we know less about what actually happens when the uninsured try to obtain health care in various settings, and more specifically, how institutions deal with these patients."

There are about 47 million Americans who do not have any health insurance and must pay for care out-of-pocket, according to Weiner.

The study analyzed how three medical centers with different ownership models rationed uncompensated care to patients without insurance. Data were obtained from hospital financial reports, a survey of 292 self-pay patients, and from the self-pay policies and practices of front-line staff.

The researchers found that all three institutions had policies for accepting self-pay patients, but that many times their practices did not match the policies. Prepayment was often left to the discretion of front line staff, who also determined whether a patient might be turned away from care.

The researchers found the differences among the three institutions were significant. The institutions and the city in which they are located were not identified.

"We found that the public institution was the most open to seeing patients in a variety of settings. By contrast, the for-profit institution would really only see patients in the emergency department," said Weiner.

Federal regulations mandate emergency care in order for a hospital to obtain Medicare and Medicaid funding.

Nearly 13 percent of patients were uninsured at the public hospital, compared to four percent and six percent at the not-for-profit and for-profit the researchers reported.

Although the public institution saw patients in a variety of diverse settings -- such as specialty clinics and surgery -- it worked really hard to obtain some payment from these patients and actually was much more successful at collecting a percentage of charges than was the for-profit, said Weiner.

The public hospital collected 67 percent of charges to self-pay patients, whereas the private hospital collected only 13 percent.

However, the public hospital actually had greater net losses in caring for the uninsured than the for-profit or the not-for-profit.

"The for-profit basically took its losses and seemed to say, 'We'll just see these folks in the emergency department, we won't work too hard to get money from them, and so be it,'" said Weiner. "And, not surprisingly, the not-for-profit fell in between."

Self-pay patients accounted for only 20 percent of bad debt at the for-profit hospital, compared with 52 percent and 76 percent of bad debt at the not-for-profit and public hospitals.

"For the uninsured, it's a pretty capricious system," said Weiner.

"As we move forward in the political process we have to recognize that this is essentially an unmanaged group -- a group of people who don't know what they're going to get. They are getting care from a set of institutions that are uncomfortable and unsure about what it is they want to provide."
-end-
The study was funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the Veterans Administration.

Extended interview as MP3 audio file available

Transcript of podcast available by clicking here

UIC ranks among the nation's top 50 universities in federal research funding and is Chicago's largest university with 25,000 students, 12,000 faculty and staff, 15 colleges and the state's major public medical center. A hallmark of the campus is the Great Cities Commitment, through which UIC faculty, students and staff engage with community, corporate, foundation and government partners in hundreds of programs to improve the quality of life in metropolitan areas around the world.

For more information about UIC, visit www.uic.edu

University of Illinois at Chicago

Related Emergency Department Articles from Brightsurf:

Deep learning in the emergency department
Harnessing the power of deep learning leads to better predictions of patient admissions and flow in emergency departments

Checklist for emergency department team's COVID-19 surge
After reviewing the literature on COVID-19 scientific publications the authors developed a checklist to guide emergency departments.

Why is appendicitis not always diagnosed in the emergency department?
A new study examines the factors associated with a potentially missed diagnosis of appendicitis in children and adults in the emergency department.

Providing contraceptive care in the pediatric emergency department
A new study found that two-thirds of female adolescents ages 16-21 seen in a pediatric Emergency Department (ED) were interested in discussing contraception, despite having a high rate of recent visits to a primary care provider.

Low back pain accounts for a third of new emergency department imaging in the US
The use of imaging for the initial evaluation of patients with low back pain in the emergency department (ED) continues to occur at a high rate -- one in three new emergency visits for low back pain in the United States -- according to the American Journal of Roentgenology (AJR).

Emergency department admissions of children for sexual abuse
This study analyzed emergency department admissions of children for sexual abuse between 2010 and 2016 using a nationwide database of emergency visits and US Census Bureau data.

30-day death rates after emergency department visits
Researchers used Medicare data from 2009 to 2016 to see how 30-day death rates associated with emergency department visits have changed.

Preventing smoking -- evidence from urban emergency department patients
A new study from the Prevention Research Center of the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation offers a more in-depth understanding of smoking among patients in an urban emergency department.

When a freestanding emergency department comes to town, costs go up
Rather than functioning as substitutes for hospital-based emergency departments, freestanding emergency departments have increased local market spending on emergency care in three of four states' markets where they have entered, according to a new paper by experts at Rice University.

Emoji buttons gauge emergency department sentiments in real time
Simple button terminals stationed around emergency departments featuring 'emoji' reflecting a range of emotions are effective in monitoring doctor and patient sentiments in real time.

Read More: Emergency Department News and Emergency Department Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.