Oxford review of economic policy

September 07, 2006

Such approaches, pioneered in the Netherlands and endoresed by the British Better Regulation Task Force (now the Better Regulation Commission), are likely to fail, and may be counterproductive. Indeed, in many areas of the economy, regulation is actually necessary for the competetive markets to function.

Dieter Helm argues that while there are good reasons to believe that regulation will be over-supplied, and that the regulatory system is open to capture by vested interests, there is very little hard empirical evidence to back up these claims.

Rather than focus on such crude red-tape-cutting initiatives, Dieter Helm argues that the priority should be in the design of regulation - when, where, and how to regulate. He argues that market-based instruments, such as environmental taxes and trade permits, are not only usually more efficient in their own right, but they have the very great advantage over traditional command-and-control approaches in that market-based instruments are much more resistant to capture by vested interests. Preventing lobbyists bending regulation to suit vested interests should be a core focus on regulatory reform.

Thus, rather than concentrating on setting out basic principles (the so-called 'five principles of good regulation') - which typically lack solid content - and on processes like Regulatory Impact Assessments, regulatory reform should concentrate on targeting market-based instruments and creating greater independence for regulatory bodies.

Dieter Helm said:

'The British debate about red tape and regulatory reform, has concentrated too much on processes and too little on outcomes, and too much on aggregate targets, and too little on detailed design. Market-based instruments provide a real opportunity to reduce the growth of regulation and squeeze out vested interests and lobby groups.'
-end-
Other articles in the issue include:

Regulation and Productivity Performance: Nicholas Crafts

Regulatory Capture: A Review: Ernesto Dal Bo

Regulation by Prices, Quantities, or Both: A Review of Instrument Choice: Cameron Hepburn

Network Regulation: Simon Cowan Measuring and Managing the Costs of Red Tape: A Review of Recent Policy Developments: Tim Keyworth

Regulatory Policy: OECD Experience and Evidence: Nick Malyshev

* Regulation, edited by Dieter Helm, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Vol. 22, No. 2, Summer 2006.

Further information on this and other issues of the journal is available from Alison Gomm at the Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Park End Central, 40-41 Park End Street, Oxford, OX1 1JD, telephone 0044 1865 792212, fax 0044 1865 251172, email econrev@herald.ox.ac.uk.

In any reference to the journal or an article in it, please mention that the Oxford Review of Economic Policy is published by Oxford University Press.

Oxford University Press

Related Focus Articles from Brightsurf:

To protect nature's benefits, focus on people
New paper calls for the consideration of people's diverse needs in order to develop effective nature-based policies and investments in ecosystems.

How to tune out common odors and focus on important ones
Quantitative biologists at CSHL have figured out how a fly brain learns to ignore overwhelmingly prevalent, mundane odors to focus on more important ones.

Praise, rather than punish, to see up to 30% greater focus in the classroom
To improve behavior in class, teachers should focus on praising children for good behavior, rather than telling them off for being disruptive, according to a new study published in Educational Psychology.

Smart glasses follow our eyes, focus automatically
By using eye-tracking technology to automatically control a pair of autofocus lenses, engineers have created a prototype for 'autofocals' designed to restore proper vision in people who would ordinarily need progressive lenses.

More sleep may help teens with ADHD focus and organize
Teenagers with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) may benefit from more sleep to help them focus, plan and control their emotions.

Money-savers focus attention -- and eyes -- on the prize
Why can some people patiently save for the future, while others opt for fewer dollars now?

Local focus could help tackle global problems
People's love for their local areas could be harnessed to tackle global environmental problems, researchers say.

How the brain enables us to rapidly focus attention
University of Queensland researchers have discovered a key mechanism in the brain that may underlie our ability to rapidly focus attention.

Flying focus: Controlling lasers through time and space
Scientists have produced an extremely bright spot of light that can travel at any speed -- including faster than the speed of light.

Previously grainy wheat genome comes into focus
An international consortium has completed the sequence of wheat's colossal genome.

Read More: Focus News and Focus Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.