Nav: Home

Who owns the dead?

September 08, 2016

After the September 11th terrorist attacks, New York City's chief medical examiner guaranteed that he and his staff would spare no expense in trying to identify every victim and human body part larger than a thumbnail and return them to their families.

Fifteen years later, only 1,640 of the 2,753 victims killed in Manhattan have been identified.

In the new book, "Who Owns the Dead? The Science and Politics of Death at Ground Zero," Carnegie Mellon's Jay D. Aronson details the cultural and political reasons behind why the promise was made--a combination of the need to recover remains, pay tribute to the 9/11 victims and redevelop the World Trade Center site--and why living up to the task has been so challenging.

"My main goal in writing the book was to help Americans understand the challenges of recovering from mass atrocity or disaster in a way that goes beyond simply cleaning up and rebuilding, which is what most work focuses on in this context," said Aronson, associate professor of science, technology and society in the Dietrich College's Department of History and director of the Center for Human Rights Science.

Aronson initially intended to examine the ethical and political implications of Staten Island's Fresh Kills landfill, where materials from the World Trade Center site were sorted, and the disagreements between families and officials over storing remains in the Memorial Museum Complex. But he realized that the massive and ongoing 9/11 recovery effort--the most costly forensic investigation in U.S. history--is a highly significant event in American history that can also offer insights into other mass casualty incidents around the world.

"As a society, we tend to be simultaneously fascinated and repulsed by death, and I wanted to take a clear-headed look at how we dealt with the massive problem of human remains in the aftermath of the World Trade Center attacks," Aronson said. "I also wanted to explain what sometimes seemed like irrational and emotionally-driven behavior of some families to human remains issues in a way that was both empathetic and demonstrated the reasons why they responded the way they did."

Though science and technology have driven recovery and identification since the attacks, politics, culture, personal perception and emotion are central to understanding those processes, as well as how the victims are memorialized.

Historian Thomas Lacquer wrote that, "Aronson explores our commitment as a species to care for our dead through a beautifully written, intellectually serious and deeply researched account... At the heart of his story are the dead of a sacralized space and their remains?fragmentary, many unidentified, so little in and of themselves?that collectively and name by name come to represent the contested meanings of an epochal event in modern history."

Science Magazine featured a review of the book in its Sept. 2 issue and highlighted how Aronson is among the first to analyze the conflicts and controversies that erupted as New York City and the nation sought to recover from the attacks and reconstruct the World Trade Center site.

"It is extremely challenging to write a text and show no favoritism, but Aronson succeeds incredibly well, encouraging readers to come to their own conclusions," Sue Black wrote. "He masterfully chronicles the bitter debate between those who 'gave' their lives and those who 'lost' their lives, those who lived in Manhattan and those who died in Manhattan, those who lost family members and those who wished to rebuild a city."

"Who Owns the Dead?" was published by Harvard University Press.

Carnegie Mellon University

Related Human Remains Articles:

The fossilization process of the dinosaur remains
A piece of work conducted between the UPV/EHU-University of the Basque Country and the University of Zaragoza has conducted an in-depth analysis of the dinosaur fossils at La Cantalera-1, one of the Iberian sites belonging to the Lower Cretaceous with the largest number of vertebrates.
Thanks to pig remains, scientists uncover extensive human mobility to sites near Stonehenge
A mutli-isotope analysis of pigs remains found around henge complexes near Stonehenge has revealed the large extent and scale of movements of human communities in Britain during the Late Neolithic.
Searching for human remains: Study suggests methodology to improve results
In an effort to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of law enforcement searches for human remains in the wild, searchers should cover the same area twice from two different angles and work no more than 1 to 2 meters apart while exploring the area
First evidence of gigantic remains from star explosions
Astrophysicists have found the first ever evidence of gigantic remains being formed from repeated explosions on the surface of a dead star in the Andromeda Galaxy, 2.5 million light years from Earth.
Remains of Anglo-Saxon cemetery discovered
Archaeologists from the University of Sheffield have uncovered a previously unknown Anglo-Saxon cemetery.
Siberian paleontologists discovered the oldest macro-skeleton remains
The oldest skeleton remains known to fossil chronicle of the Earth belonged to the microorganisms that lived 700-650 million years ago.
Stillbirth reduction strategy remains unproven, study finds
A care package aimed at reducing the risk of babies being stillborn may offer marginal benefit, research led by the University of Edinburgh suggests.
CT technique expands possibilities of imaging ancient remains
Researchers in Sweden using computed tomography (CT) have successfully imaged the soft tissue of an ancient Egyptian mummy's hand down to a microscopic level, according to a new study.
DNA analysis of 6,500-year-old human remains in Israel points to origin of ancient culture
An international team of researchers from Tel Aviv University, the Israel Antiquities Authority and Harvard University has discovered that waves of migration from Anatolia and the Zagros mountains to the Levant helped develop the Chalcolithic culture that existed in Israel's Upper Galilee region some 6,500 years ago.
Hector weakens but remains Category 4 Hurricane
Hurricane Hector has weakened slightly but still remains a robust Category Four storm at present.
More Human Remains News and Human Remains Current Events

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Rethinking Anger
Anger is universal and complex: it can be quiet, festering, justified, vengeful, and destructive. This hour, TED speakers explore the many sides of anger, why we need it, and who's allowed to feel it. Guests include psychologists Ryan Martin and Russell Kolts, writer Soraya Chemaly, former talk radio host Lisa Fritsch, and business professor Dan Moshavi.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#538 Nobels and Astrophysics
This week we start with this year's physics Nobel Prize awarded to Jim Peebles, Michel Mayor, and Didier Queloz and finish with a discussion of the Nobel Prizes as a way to award and highlight important science. Are they still relevant? When science breakthroughs are built on the backs of hundreds -- and sometimes thousands -- of people's hard work, how do you pick just three to highlight? Join host Rachelle Saunders and astrophysicist, author, and science communicator Ethan Siegel for their chat about astrophysics and Nobel Prizes.