Nav: Home

Who owns the dead?

September 08, 2016

After the September 11th terrorist attacks, New York City's chief medical examiner guaranteed that he and his staff would spare no expense in trying to identify every victim and human body part larger than a thumbnail and return them to their families.

Fifteen years later, only 1,640 of the 2,753 victims killed in Manhattan have been identified.

In the new book, "Who Owns the Dead? The Science and Politics of Death at Ground Zero," Carnegie Mellon's Jay D. Aronson details the cultural and political reasons behind why the promise was made--a combination of the need to recover remains, pay tribute to the 9/11 victims and redevelop the World Trade Center site--and why living up to the task has been so challenging.

"My main goal in writing the book was to help Americans understand the challenges of recovering from mass atrocity or disaster in a way that goes beyond simply cleaning up and rebuilding, which is what most work focuses on in this context," said Aronson, associate professor of science, technology and society in the Dietrich College's Department of History and director of the Center for Human Rights Science.

Aronson initially intended to examine the ethical and political implications of Staten Island's Fresh Kills landfill, where materials from the World Trade Center site were sorted, and the disagreements between families and officials over storing remains in the Memorial Museum Complex. But he realized that the massive and ongoing 9/11 recovery effort--the most costly forensic investigation in U.S. history--is a highly significant event in American history that can also offer insights into other mass casualty incidents around the world.

"As a society, we tend to be simultaneously fascinated and repulsed by death, and I wanted to take a clear-headed look at how we dealt with the massive problem of human remains in the aftermath of the World Trade Center attacks," Aronson said. "I also wanted to explain what sometimes seemed like irrational and emotionally-driven behavior of some families to human remains issues in a way that was both empathetic and demonstrated the reasons why they responded the way they did."

Though science and technology have driven recovery and identification since the attacks, politics, culture, personal perception and emotion are central to understanding those processes, as well as how the victims are memorialized.

Historian Thomas Lacquer wrote that, "Aronson explores our commitment as a species to care for our dead through a beautifully written, intellectually serious and deeply researched account... At the heart of his story are the dead of a sacralized space and their remains?fragmentary, many unidentified, so little in and of themselves?that collectively and name by name come to represent the contested meanings of an epochal event in modern history."

Science Magazine featured a review of the book in its Sept. 2 issue and highlighted how Aronson is among the first to analyze the conflicts and controversies that erupted as New York City and the nation sought to recover from the attacks and reconstruct the World Trade Center site.

"It is extremely challenging to write a text and show no favoritism, but Aronson succeeds incredibly well, encouraging readers to come to their own conclusions," Sue Black wrote. "He masterfully chronicles the bitter debate between those who 'gave' their lives and those who 'lost' their lives, those who lived in Manhattan and those who died in Manhattan, those who lost family members and those who wished to rebuild a city."

"Who Owns the Dead?" was published by Harvard University Press.

Carnegie Mellon University

Related Human Remains Articles:

Forensic technique uses forehead X-rays to assess age of juvenile remains
Forensic anthropology researchers have developed a technique that can provide an approximate age for juveniles and young people based on an X-ray of the frontal sinus region of the skull.
Scientists find 7.2-million-year-old pre-human remains in the Balkans
Scientists analyzing 7.2 million-year-old fossils uncovered in modern-day Greece and Bulgaria suggest a new hypothesis about the origins of humankind, placing it in the Eastern Mediterranean and not -- as customarily assumed -- in Africa, and earlier than currently accepted.
Russian scientists have found the remains of an unknown animal
During an expedition to the Krasnoyarsk Territory, scientists from Tomsk State University and St.
Flawed forensic science may be hampering identification of human remains
Research from The Australian National University (ANU) has cast doubt on a method used in forensic science to determine whether skeletal remains are of a person who has given birth.
Oldest remains of insects from bed bug genus found in Oregon
A cave in Oregon that is the site of some the oldest preserved evidence of human activity in North America was also once home to not-too-distant cousins of the common bed bug.
Wispy remains of supernova explosion hide possible 'survivor'
This image, taken with NASA's Hubble Space Telescope, shows the supernova remnant SNR 0509-68.7, also known as N103B.
Testing for hepatitis C virus remains low among baby boomers
A new Brief Report appearing in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine looks at vaccination rates for Hepatitis C virus two years after the United States Preventive Services Task Force recommended it for all baby boomers, and finds rates are still very low.
Mummified remains identified as Egyptian Queen Nefertari
A team of international archaeologists believe a pair of mummified legs on display in an Italian museum may belong to Egyptian Queen Nefertari -- the favorite wife of the pharaoh Ramses II.
1815 UK geologic map remains the benchmark
Although most people do not regularly appreciate it, geologic maps have been and remain a critical foundation of industrial society.
Remains of rice and mung beans help solve a Madagascan mystery
Researchers have helped discover why the inhabitants of Madagascar speak Malagasy, a language otherwise unique to Southeast Asia and the Pacific -- a region located at least 6,000 km away.

Related Human Remains Reading:

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Digital Manipulation
Technology has reshaped our lives in amazing ways. But at what cost? This hour, TED speakers reveal how what we see, read, believe — even how we vote — can be manipulated by the technology we use. Guests include journalist Carole Cadwalladr, consumer advocate Finn Myrstad, writer and marketing professor Scott Galloway, behavioral designer Nir Eyal, and computer graphics researcher Doug Roble.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#529 Do You Really Want to Find Out Who's Your Daddy?
At least some of you by now have probably spit into a tube and mailed it off to find out who your closest relatives are, where you might be from, and what terrible diseases might await you. But what exactly did you find out? And what did you give away? In this live panel at Awesome Con we bring in science writer Tina Saey to talk about all her DNA testing, and bioethicist Debra Mathews, to determine whether Tina should have done it at all. Related links: What FamilyTreeDNA sharing genetic data with police means for you Crime solvers embraced...