Nav: Home

Study adds to evidence that racial and economic factors affect surgical pain management

September 14, 2017

A "look back" analysis of more than 600 major colorectal surgeries using a "checklist" tool has added further evidence that racial and socioeconomic disparities may occur during many specific stages of surgical care, particularly in pain management.

A report of the study's findings by researchers at Johns Hopkins Medicine, published Sept. 11 in Diseases of the Colon & Rectum, documents the specific ways in which historically disadvantaged populations receive less optimal pain management and are placed on "enhanced recovery" protocols later than their wealthier and white counterparts.

"This study demonstrates that process measures, which guide and document each step of care, may be critical factors in preventing differences in care, particularly those due to race and socioeconomic status" says Ira Leeds, M.D., research fellow at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and the paper's co-first author. "We can't fix what we don't measure," he adds.

Enhanced recovery after surgery (ERAS) protocols are predefined pathways designed to standardize some aspects of surgical care in order to reduce complications, decrease lengths of stay and improve overall patient satisfaction.

To determine whether ERAS had an impact, or revealed any racial and socioeconomic disparities after surgery, Leeds and colleagues performed a retrospective analysis of information gathered before and after the implementation of a colorectal ERAS pathway at The Johns Hopkins Hospital.

A total of 639 patient experiences (199 pre-ERAS implementation and 440 post-implementation) were used in the analysis, all surgeries performed between Jan. 1, 2013 and June 30, 2016. The research team collected socioeconomic information, medical diagnoses in addition to colorectal disease, and surgical outcomes information housed in Johns Hopkins' National Surgical Quality Improvement Program's internal database.

Data about participation in ERAS and adherence to process measures were obtained from the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine's Department of Surgery quality improvement database.

Patients were categorized as either white or nonwhite patients, and low socioeconomic status or high socioeconomic status was determined by zip code. Some 75.2 percent of all patients were white and 91.7 percent were categorized as having a high socioeconomic status.

The researchers found that white patients were more likely to have transverse abdominis plane (TAP) blocks or epidurals initiated and maintained than nonwhite patients (57.1 versus 44.1 percent for initiation; 47.3 versus 34.3 percent for maintenance).

A similar trend for initiation of pain management was seen for high socioeconomic status patients (55.4 versus 41.5 percent). Leeds says this suggests that either nonwhite patients declined epidural blocks for pain management at higher rates due to inadequate counseling on the benefits, or that doctors carried implicit biases that led them to offer such pain management options less often to minorities and the poor.

Patients with a high socioeconomic status were placed on an ERAS pathway during scheduling more often than low socioeconomic status patients (69.7 versus 58.5 percent).

Prior to ERAS implementation, median lengths of stay, complication rates and total number of complications were not statistically different between white and nonwhite patients. Following ERAS implementation, median lengths of stay improved in both whites (a decrease of 1.5 days) and nonwhites (-1 days) and in patients with high socioeconomic status (-1 days) and low socioeconomic status (-2.0 days).

Following pathway implementation, the median lengths of stay improved in all subgroups with an overall decrease of 1 day, with no statistical difference by race or socioeconomic status. There were no significant differences in complication rates between racial (26.4 versus 28.8 percent) and socioeconomic groups (27.3 versus 25.0 percent) before ERAS implementation, and this was unchanged after ERAS implementation.

Leeds says the study results do not prove implicit racial or other bias as the cause of the differences in care, but they should, he says, heighten concern about the existence of such disparities and renew attention toward identifying and addressing bias.

While Leeds acknowledges the study's limitations of only including one institution and drawing from two datasets not designed to be merged for analysis, he notes that the findings add evidence regarding the efficacy of ERAS pathways in identifying disparities and highlight how short-term disparities can be mitigated by quality monitoring.
-end-
Two of the co-authors on this paper, Elizabeth Wick, M.D., and Deborah Hobson from Johns Hopkins, are currently leading efforts to enable more than 750 hospitals across the U.S. to implement ERAS. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality-funded project, Improving Surgical Care and Recovery, is a collaboration between the Johns Hopkins Armstrong Institute for Patient Safety and Quality and the American College of Surgeons.

Other authors on this paper include Yewande Alimi, Jonathan E. Efron, Elliott R. Haut and Fabian Johnston from the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine.

Cancer Institute T32 training grant 5T32CA126607. Leeds received additional support for research expenses from the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons Research Foundation General Surgery Resident Research Initiation Grant GSSRIG-031. Haut was supported as the primary investigator of an Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality grant (1R01HS024547-01) and a Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute contract (CE-12-11-4489). Johnston was supported as the primary investigator of an Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality grant (1K08HS024736-01) from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.

Johns Hopkins Medicine

Related Socioeconomic Status Articles:

Socioeconomic status in childhood linked with cardiac structure and function in adulthood
The multicenter trial coordinated by the Research Centre of Applied and Preventive Cardiovascular Medicine at the University of Turku, Finland, shows that low socioeconomic status in childhood increases the risk of higher left ventricular mass and poorer diastolic function in adulthood.
Is there an association between socioeconomic status in childhood and the heart?
Socioeconomic inequalities are a public health challenge in cardiovascular disease and a new study published by JAMA Pediatrics examined the association of childhood family socioeconomic status in youth on measures of left ventricular mass and diastolic function 31 years later in adulthood.
Does access to quality playgrounds vary with a child's socioeconomic status & obesity risk?
A study of all 3rd-5th grade youth in one US county examined differences in access to playgrounds and associations between youth weight and playground accessibility and quality.
Socioeconomic background linked to reading improvement
MIT neuroscientists have found that dyslexic children from lower income families responded much better to a summer reading program than children from a higher socioeconomic background.
Improvements in control of cardiovascular risk factors not seen at all socioeconomic levels in US
Between 1999 to 2014, there was a decline in average systolic blood pressure, smoking, and predicted cardiovascular risk of 20 percent or greater among high-income US adults, but these levels remained unchanged in adults with incomes at or below the federal poverty level, according to a study published by JAMA Cardiology.
Lower socioeconomic status is linked to obesity through distress and emotional eating
New research presented at this year's European Congress on Obesity in Porto, Portugal, shows that lower socioeconomic status is associated with higher body-mass index (BMI) through its effects on distress and subsequent emotional eating.
Race, gender and socioeconomic factors impact PCI outcomes
Results from 'Interaction Effects of Race/Ethnicity and Sex on Outcomes after PCI: A Subanalysis of the PLATINUM Diversity study' were presented today as a late-breaking clinical trial at the Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions (SCAI) 2017 Scientific Sessions in New Orleans.
Studies reveal socioeconomic and racial disparities in lupus
Two new studies have uncovered socioeconomic disparities related to the health of patients with lupus.
Childhood lead exposure associated with lower IQ, socioeconomic status nearly 3 decades later
Children who had higher blood lead levels at age 11 were more likely to have lower cognitive function, IQ and socioeconomic status when they were adults at age 38, according to a study published by JAMA.
Most remaining smokers in US have low socioeconomic status
After decades of declining US smoking rates overall, most remaining smokers have low income, no college education, no health insurance or a disability.

Related Socioeconomic Status Reading:

Cutting Class: Socioeconomic Status and Education (Culture and Education Series)
by Joe L. Kincheloe (Editor), Shirley R. Steinberg (Editor)

In these vivid, thought-provoking essays, leading scholars draw from their own life experiences to explore the ways in which socio-economic class has shaped their lives and educational practices. Some experienced the sting of poverty as students, while others tell stories of a privileged upbringing and moments of epiphany when they recognized the far-reaching effects of class privilege. Many in this volume tell stories of their successful (and not-so-successful) teaching experiences with students from various social classes, providing valuable insights for teachers and other education... View Details


Socioeconomic Status, Parenting, and Child Development (Monographs in Parenting Series)
by Marc H. Bornstein (Editor), Robert H. Bradley (Editor)

Socioeconomic Status, Parenting, and Child Development presents cutting-edge thinking and research on linkages among socioeconomic status, parenting, and child development. The contributors represent an array of different disciplines, and approach the issues from a variety of perspectives. Accordingly, their "take" on how SES matters in the lives of children varies.

This volume is divided into two parts. Part I concerns the constructs and measurement of SES and Part II discusses the functions and effects of SES. Each part presents four substantive chapters on the topic... View Details


Women's Socioeconomic Status and Religious Leadership in Asia Minor: In the First Two Centuries C.E. (Emerging Scholars)
by Katherine Bain (Author)

Moving beyond discussions of patriarchy and prescribed "women's roles" in the Roman world—discussions that have relied too much on elite literary sources, in her view—Katherine Bain explores what inscriptional data from Asia Minor can tell us about the actual socioeconomic status of women in the first and second centuries C.E. Her findings suggest that outside of the prescriptive lenses of the upper classes, women were described, in honorary and funerary inscriptions, in terms that mirrored the socioeconomic status of men, suggesting that women's leadership in social associations—and by... View Details


Accounting for Social Risk Factors in Medicare Payment
by Engineering, and Medicine National Academies of Sciences (Author), Health and Medicine Division (Author), Board on Health Care Services (Author), Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice (Author), Committee on Accounting for Socioeconomic Status in Medicare Payment Programs (Author), Donald M. Steinwachs (Editor), Kathleen Stratton (Editor), Leslie Y. Kwan (Editor)

Recent health care payment reforms aim to improve the alignment of Medicare payment strategies with goals to improve the quality of care provided, patient experiences with health care, and health outcomes, while also controlling costs. These efforts move Medicare away from the volume-based payment of traditional fee-for-service models and toward value-based purchasing, in which cost control is an explicit goal in addition to clinical and quality goals. Specific payment strategies include pay-for-performance and other quality incentive programs that tie financial rewards and sanctions to... View Details


Popular: Finding Happiness and Success in a World That Cares Too Much About the Wrong Kinds of Relationships
by Mitch Prinstein (Author)

A leading psychologist examines how our popularity affects our success, our relationships, and our happiness—and why we don’t always want to be the most popular.
 
Popular examines why popularity plays such a key role in our development and, ultimately, how it still influences our happiness and success today. In many ways—some even beyond our conscious awareness—those old dynamics of our youth continue to play out in every business meeting, every social gathering, in our personal relationships, and even how we raise our children. Our popularity even affects our... View Details


Race, Ethnicity, and Socioeconomic Status: A Theoretical Analysis of Their Interrelationship
by Charles Vert Willie (Author)

Providing an adequate conceptual apparatus for the explanation and interpretation of behavior associated with race, ethinicity, and socioeconomic status is the goal of this book. Empirical research findings and their theoretical analysis are linked.
E. Franklin Frazier, recognized minorities as mirrors of their society. He hypothesized that study of their adaptations would provide a clearer understanding of the relation of human motivation to culture. Race, Ethnicity, and Socioeconomic Status confirms the Frazier hypothesis and extracts from studies of blacks and other racial and... View Details


Socioeconomic Status: Influences, Disparities and Current Issues (Social Issues, Justice and Status)
by Geoffrey Perkins (Editor)

View Details


Socioeconomic Status and Health in Industrial Nations: Social, Psychological, and Biological Pathways (Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences)
by Nancy E. Adler (Editor), Michael Marmot (Editor), Bruce S. McEwen (Editor), Judith Stewart (Editor)

View Details


Accounting for Social Risk Factors in Medicare Payment: Criteria, Factors, and Methods
by Engineering, and Medicine National Academies of Sciences (Author), Health and Medicine Division (Author), Board on Health Care Services (Author), Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice (Author), Committee on Accounting for Socioeconomic Status in Medicare Payment Programs (Author)

Recent health care payment reforms aim to improve the alignment of Medicare payment strategies with goals to improve the quality of care provided, patient experiences with health care, and health outcomes, while also controlling costs. These efforts move Medicare away from the volume-based payment of traditional fee-for-service models and toward value-based purchasing, in which cost control is an explicit goal in addition to clinical and quality goals. Specific payment strategies include pay-for-performance and other quality incentive programs that tie financial rewards and sanctions to... View Details


Environmental and Socioeconomic Status of the Hampshire Energy Project
by United States General Accounting Office (GAO) (Author)

Environmental and Socioeconomic Status of the Hampshire Energy Project View Details

Best Science Podcasts 2018

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2018. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

The Person You Become
Over the course of our lives, we shed parts of our old selves, embrace new ones, and redefine who we are. This hour, TED speakers explore ideas about the experiences that shape the person we become. Guests include aerobatics pilot and public speaker Janine Shepherd, writers Roxane Gay and Taiye Selasi, activist Jackson Bird, and fashion executive Kaustav Dey.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#478 She Has Her Mother's Laugh
What does heredity really mean? Carl Zimmer would argue it's more than your genes along. In "She Has Her Mother’s Laugh: The Power, Perversions, and Potential of Heredity", Zimmer covers the history of genetics and what kinship and heredity really mean when we're discovering how to alter our own DNA, and, potentially, the DNA of our children.