Kindergarten retention fails to help academic achievement

October 03, 2005

WASHINGTON, October 3, 2005 -- For nearly 100 years, educators have debated the benefits of grade retention versus social promotion. A new examination of research on this perennially-controversial issue indicates that retention does not improve achievement among kindergartners in reading or mathematics, nor does it facilitate instruction by making classrooms more homogeneous academically. The report, based on the dissertation of Guanglei Hong, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto, appears in the fall issue of Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis (EEPA), a peer-reviewed, scholarly journal published by the American Educational Research Association.

The study makes use of data from the U.S. Early Childhood Longitudinal Study Kindergarten cohort (ECLS-K), collected from fall 1998 to spring 2000 and released by the US National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). The research focuses on three questions:

According to researcher Hong, co-authoring with Stephen W. Raudenbush, University of Chicago, results from the study challenge the practice of routinely using kindergarten retention as a solution to the difficulties experienced by young children. Their work shows that:

"In recent years, 'ending social promotion' has become a popular slogan with the movement to set and maintain high standards and educational accountability. In this new climate, many schools have adopted grade retention at most grade levels, even in kindergarten," the authors state. Predictors of retention among kindergarteners include characteristics such as non-Hispanic, male, from a single-parent family with lower socioeconomic status and higher number of siblings, and never having received center-based childcare. In addition, the retainees tended to come from kindergarten classes where teachers spent relatively less time in reading and literacy instruction, covered lower-level content topics, and held different standards based on children's capability. Hong and Raudenbush conclude that "rather than forcing these children to restart from the very beginning, exposing them to meaningful intellectual challenges on a continual basis is perhaps developmentally more appropriate."

Hong and Raudenbush found no evidence that a policy of grade retention in kindergarten improves average achievement in mathematics or reading. Nor did they find evidence that the policy benefits children who are promoted under the policy. The impact of a retention policy is great only for the small percentage of children who are retained, and the evidence suggests that those children learn less than they would have had they instead been promoted.

This research received support through the American Educational Research Association's Grants Program from the National Center for Education Statistics and the Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education; from the National Science Foundation; and from the Spencer Foundation.
The American Educational Research Association (AERA) represents approximately 22,000 scholars who conduct education research and evaluation. The purposes of AERA are to advance knowledge about education, to encourage scholarly inquiry related to education, and to promote the use of research to improve education and serve the public good.

American Educational Research Association
1230 Seventeenth St. NW, Washington DC 20036

American Educational Research Association

Related Mathematics Articles from Brightsurf:

A new method for boosting the learning of mathematics
How can mathematics learning in primary school be facilitated? UNIGE has developed an intervention to promote the learning of math in school.

Could mathematics help to better treat cancer?
Impaired information processing may prevent cells from perceiving their environment correctly; they then start acting in an uncontrolled way and this can lead to the development of cancer.

People can see beauty in complex mathematics, study shows
Ordinary people see beauty in complex mathematical arguments in the same way they can appreciate a beautiful landscape painting or a piano sonata.

Improving geothermal HVAC systems with mathematics
Sustainable heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems, such as those that harness low-enthalpy geothermal energy, are needed to reduce collective energy use and mitigate the continued effects of a warming climate.

How the power of mathematics can help assess lung function
Researchers at the University of Southampton have developed a new computational way of analyzing X-ray images of lungs, which could herald a breakthrough in the diagnosis and assessment of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and other lung diseases.

Mathematics pushes innovation in 4-D printing
New mathematical results will provide a potential breakthrough in the design and the fabrication of the next generation of morphable materials.

More democracy through mathematics
For democratic elections to be fair, voting districts must have similar sizes.

How to color a lizard: From biology to mathematics
Skin color patterns in animals arise from microscopic interactions among colored cells that obey equations discovered by Alan Turing.

US educators awarded for exemplary teaching in mathematics
Janet Heine Barnett, Caren Diefenderfer, and Tevian Dray were named the 2017 Deborah and Franklin Tepper Haimo Award winners by the Mathematical Association of America (MAA) for their teaching effectiveness and influence beyond their institutions.

Authors of year's best books in mathematics honored
Prizes for the year's best books in mathematics were awarded to Ian Stewart and Tim Chartier by the Mathematical Association of America (MAA) on Jan.

Read More: Mathematics News and Mathematics Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to