Nav: Home

Clinton's contrasting memoir writing styles linked to public perception problems

October 04, 2016

Many consider the political memoir genre to be obsolete since they rarely reveal anything new or noteworthy.

However, Carnegie Mellon University's David Kaufer and the University of Maryland's Shawn J. Parry-Giles analysis of Hillary Clinton's two political memoirs, "Living History" and "Hard Choices," has discovered links to the U.S democratic presidential candidate's public perception problems. Published in the National Communication Association's Quarterly Journal of Speech, the new study identifies two contrasting writing styles with one underlying theme: Clinton's guardedness.

Kaufer and Parry-Giles uncovered that both memoirs were written with a future presidential run in mind. They also found that the writing styles reveal specific challenges for female political candidates.

For their analysis, Kaufer and Parry Giles, professor and chair of the University of Maryland's Department of Communication, used DocuScope, a CMU-developed digital humanities tool to statistically tag, examine and visualize text for rhetorical patterns.

They found that "Living History," which spans Clinton's childhood through her years as first lady, was written in the Boswellian approach, meaning it delved into her most intimate thoughts. "Hard Choices," written to recount her tenure as secretary of state, used the Plutarchian style of focusing on the leader's public service performance.

"But that is only the beginning of the story," said Kaufer, the Paul Mellon Distinguished Professor of English in CMU's Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences. "Our important finding was the interleaving of the styles across both memoirs and Clinton's choice to employ an institutional style when a disclosive personal style was not only expected but hyped by her publishers.

"For example, 'Living History's' chapter on the Lewinsky scandal reveals a litigator style pressing the case against Kenneth Starr more than the personal style of a betrayed spouse," he added. "And her chapters on a future vision for America in 'Hard Choices' emphasize more the continuation of the visions of the two presidents she served than a vision of her own."

Kaufer and Giles see gender as playing a role in these style options and decisions.

"Clinton has been attacked for being too much of a 'policy wonk' and not revealing enough about her personal life in her memoirs," Giles said. "But this is really a by-product of the 'double bind' women face in politics. Women in politics, like Clinton, often find they can't be too intellectual or too emotional -- or too serious or too jovial."

The authors propose that, "because of the binds they face, it is easy for women candidates to be pushed back into pragmatism to remain 'appropriate.'"
Read the full study.

Carnegie Mellon University

Related Women Articles:

Career military women who served in Vietnam: Happier and in better health than all women
A study of American women deployed to Vietnam for military or civilian service shows that 48 percent of career military women were very happy compared to 38 percent of women in the general population, and of better than average physical and mental health.
Women treated for precursor of breast cancer can expect to live as long as other women
Women over 50 who have been treated for ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), a precursor of breast cancer, are more likely to be alive ten years later than women in the general population, according to new research presented at the European Cancer Congress 2017.
Black women more likely to be diagnosed with late stage breast cancer than white women
Black African women are nearly twice as likely to be diagnosed with late stage breast cancer as white women in England according to new analysis.
Pregnancy increases stroke risk in young women, but not in older women
Pregnancy was not found to raise the risk of stroke in older women, but the risk was significantly higher in young women, according to a study from Columbia University Medical Center and NewYork-Presbyterian.
Soluble corn fiber can help young women build bone, and older women preserve bone
Supplementing with soluble corn fiber at two critical times in a woman's life -- adolescence and post-menopause -- can help build and retain calcium in bone, according to new research from Purdue University.
Women with epilepsy just as likely to get pregnant as healthy women of childbearing age
In a prospective study, women with epilepsy had a comparable likelihood of achieving pregnancy, time taken to get pregnant, and pregnancy outcomes such as miscarriage, compared to a group of healthy peers.
Reduced anxiety and depression for women participating in women-only cardiac rehab programs
Cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of death for women globally.
Black women in Canada have substantially higher risk of preterm birth than white women
A study comparing rates of preterm birth among non-Hispanic black and non-Hispanic white women in Canada found that the rates were substantially higher among black women than white women, mirroring the disparity in the United States.
Breast cancer becoming as common among African-American women as among white women
Breast Cancer Statistics, 2015 finds rates among African-American women in the United States have continued to increase, converging with rates among white women and closing a gap that had existed for decades.
Unmarried women: Politically cohesive, more concerned about women's status
Why do unmarried women tend to be more liberal and Democratic than their married counterparts?

Related Women Reading:

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Digital Manipulation
Technology has reshaped our lives in amazing ways. But at what cost? This hour, TED speakers reveal how what we see, read, believe — even how we vote — can be manipulated by the technology we use. Guests include journalist Carole Cadwalladr, consumer advocate Finn Myrstad, writer and marketing professor Scott Galloway, behavioral designer Nir Eyal, and computer graphics researcher Doug Roble.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#530 Why Aren't We Dead Yet?
We only notice our immune systems when they aren't working properly, or when they're under attack. How does our immune system understand what bits of us are us, and what bits are invading germs and viruses? How different are human immune systems from the immune systems of other creatures? And is the immune system so often the target of sketchy medical advice? Those questions and more, this week in our conversation with author Idan Ben-Barak about his book "Why Aren't We Dead Yet?: The Survivor’s Guide to the Immune System".