Nav: Home

Low lead levels in children negatively affect test scores

October 05, 2016

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] --A decrease in the average level of lead in a preschooler's blood reduces the probability of that child being substantially below proficient in reading by the third grade, a new National Bureau of Economics Research working paper reports. And because poor and minority children are more likely to be exposed to lead, the study suggests that lead poisoning may be one of the causes of continuing gaps in test scores between children from different socioeconomic groups.

"This study underscores the importance of looking at factors outside the educational setting to help explain persistent gaps in test scores," said Anna Aizer, professor of economics at Brown University.

Aizer co-authored the study, "Do Low Levels of Blood Lead Reduce Children's Future Test Scores?" with economist Janet Currie of Princeton University and Brown colleagues Dr. Peter Simon and Dr. Patrick Vivier.

Rhode Island's lead abatement and testing programs

The study looked at eight cohorts of Rhode Island children born between 1997 and 2005, a timeframe whose beginning coincides with two statewide remediation programs. One mandated that landlords in buildings where elevated levels of lead had been found remediate the lead, with the aid of state loans, or face prosecution. The other required all landlords to mitigate lead hazards in the homes they rented regardless of whether an elevated lead level had been reported.

Although lead was outlawed as a paint additive in 1978, much of Rhode Island's housing stock predates that ruling. According to the study, U.S. Census data reveals that 81 percent of the homes in Providence County were built prior to 1978 and 49 percent before World War II.

Minority and low-income children were disproportionately exposed to deteriorating lead-based paint, the authors wrote, because of "residential segregation of the poor, and especially of African Americans, in the four core urban areas of the state located within Providence County."

Rhode Island, the authors note, "had a particularly aggressive program of testing for lead, and 80 percent of all three-year-old children in the state have at least one blood lead level measurement." Most Rhode Island children have repeated tests for lead, according to the authors, so they were able to "match information on preschool blood lead levels from the R.I. Department of Health with the child's test scores from the R.I. Department of Education in order to examine the effects of preschool blood lead levels on third grade test scores."

Measuring lead in blood

Lead, which the authors note has been known to be toxic to the human body since Roman times, affects many of the body's systems, including the renal, endocrine and cardiovascular, "but the nervous system appears to be the most sensitive target," the authors wrote.

Blood lead levels (BLLs) are measured by micrograms of lead per deciliter. "The mean BLL is 3.1, which is well below the Center for Disease Control's threshold for medical intervention of 5 micrograms per deciliter," according to the study.

At the outset of the study, African American children had a mean BLL 5.77, while Hispanic children had a mean BLL of 4.91. By 2005, those concentrations had declined to 2.95 and 2.52 respectively, a decrease of 42 percent.

"This is a very rapid decline, which we attribute in part to the introduction of the lead-safe certificate program," Aizer and her colleagues wrote, noting that the most groups saw a dramatic increase in the percentage of children who lived in a home with a certificate in place at the time of the birth.

"In the 1997 birth cohort only two percent of sample African American children lived in a home that had been certified lead-safe at the time of their birth; by 2005, 12 percent of sample African American children lived in a home that had been certified as lead-safe from the time of their birth," the authors wrote.

Rising test scores in reading

The authors found that by third grade, test scores rose for all children in the study, regardless of demographic group, while the fraction scoring substantially below proficient declined. The greatest gains, the researchers found, were made by the children who were most affected by the certificate program.

The authors found different effects among different economic groups, including that "among children who never participated in the free lunch program, reading test scores rose by 5.9 percent and the percent who were not proficient in reading fell from six to four percent."

On the other hand, among children "who were always eligible for the free lunch program, reading test scores rose by 11.2 percent and the percent who were substantially below proficient in reading fell from 27 to 18 percent, a remarkable improvement."

The authors wrote that they recognized that positive parenting practices or educational policies that targeted poor and minority children could cause gains in reading scores. The researchers also acknowledge that children with higher lead levels "are more likely to come from minority groups, to be poor, to live in single parent homes, and to have less educated mothers. Such a bias would tend to cause researchers to overstate the dangers of lead."

To address these multiple concerns, the authors wrote, "we control for the average reading test scores of all the other students in a child's school and grade. This control captures potential changes in schools (policies, resources, student composition, etc.) that might be relevant to the index child's test scores." The researchers also discounted the additional reduction in blood lead levels in cases where it seemed as though parents were making a special effort to take advantage of the lead certificate program.

The negative effects of even historically low levels of lead

The researchers note that even though blood lead levels are at historically low levels, the negative impact on academic performance is significant.

Aizer, Currie, Simon and Vivier found a one point decline in reading scores for each one unit increase in the mean of a child's blood lead levels, as well as a 3.1 percentage point increase in the probability of being "substantially below proficient" in reading.

According to the study, estimates on blood lead levels' impact on math scores "are imprecisely estimated, though still suggestive of negative effects of lead."

The group's results suggest that Rhode Island's lead-safe certificate program, whose annual cost, they estimate, is about $500,000, caused lead levels to fall faster among disadvantaged children than among other children, and accounted for a third of the gain in reading scores among African American children and a fifth of the gain among Hispanic children over this period.

Brown University

Related Reading Articles:

Socioeconomic background linked to reading improvement
MIT neuroscientists have found that dyslexic children from lower income families responded much better to a summer reading program than children from a higher socioeconomic background.
Reading the genetic code depends on context
University of Utah biologists now suggest that connecting amino acids to make proteins in ribosomes, the cell's protein factories, may in fact be influenced by sets of three triplets -- a 'triplet of triplets' that provide crucial context for the ribosome.
When it comes to reading, kindergarten is the new first grade
A new nationwide study has found that children entering first grade in 2013 had significantly better reading skills than similar students had just 12 years earlier.
Scientists predict reading ability from DNA alone
Researchers from King's College London have used a genetic scoring technique to predict reading performance throughout school years from DNA alone.
Brain activity can be used to predict reading success up to 2 years in advance
By measuring brainwaves, it is possible to predict what a child's reading level will be years in advance, according to research from Binghamton University, State University of New York.
To understand others' minds, 'being' them beats reading them
We tend to believe that people telegraph how they're feeling through facial expressions and body language and we only need to watch them to know what they're experiencing -- but new research shows we'd get a much better idea if we put ourselves in their shoes instead.
New study finds reading can help with chronic pain
A study conducted by researchers from the University of Liverpool, The Reader and the Royal Liverpool University Hospitals Trust, and funded by the British Academy, has found that shared reading (SR) can be a useful therapy for chronic pain sufferers.
'In 50 years, reading will be much easier -- for computers and humans alike'
At a time when even something as fundamental as reading has been co-opted by digital brains, teaching computers to read has become a monumental task.
Aging bonobos in the wild could use reading glasses too
As people age, they often find that it's more difficult to see things up close.
Study finds brain connections key to reading
A new study from MIT reveals that a brain region dedicated to reading has connections necessary for that skill even before children learn to read.

Related Reading Reading:

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Do animals grieve? Do they have language or consciousness? For a long time, scientists resisted the urge to look for human qualities in animals. This hour, TED speakers explore how that is changing. Guests include biological anthropologist Barbara King, dolphin researcher Denise Herzing, primatologist Frans de Waal, and ecologist Carl Safina.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#SB2 2019 Science Birthday Minisode: Mary Golda Ross
Our second annual Science Birthday is here, and this year we celebrate the wonderful Mary Golda Ross, born 9 August 1908. She died in 2008 at age 99, but left a lasting mark on the science of rocketry and space exploration as an early woman in engineering, and one of the first Native Americans in engineering. Join Rachelle and Bethany for this very special birthday minisode celebrating Mary and her achievements. Thanks to our Patreons who make this show possible! Read more about Mary G. Ross: Interview with Mary Ross on Lash Publications International, by Laurel Sheppard Meet Mary Golda...