Diagnosing Depression In Primary Care

October 06, 1998

ANN ARBOR---Researchers in the University of Michigan Health System say a new study illustrates the need for fresh approaches to defining and diagnosing depression by primary care doctors. The study "False Positives, False Negatives and the Validity of the Diagnosis of Major Depression in Primary Care" is published in the current edition of the Archives of Family Medicine.

The research team, led by Michael Klinkman, M.D., associate professor of family medicine, studied several hundred patients in southeast Michigan who were making visits to their family doctor. What emerged from the many findings is the idea that depression is a fluid disease that needs to be tracked over time to correctly diagnose and treat it in the primary care setting.

"We have not yet found the proper way to classify depressive disorders in primary care," says Klinkman. "The boundaries between major depression and minor depression that have been so clearly defined in the psychiatric setting become blurred in primary care patients where symptoms change over time in response to many influences. Distress and depression might easily be detected during one office visit and totally hidden during another."

Klinkman says the study had three major findings:

--Three different groups of patients emerged in primary care practices:

1. A group that was clearly not depressed.

2. A group that was clearly depressed and impaired.

3. An "in-between" group. Some of these patients met screening criteria for depression and others did not---but all looked indistinguishable in their clinical characteristics. These were distressed patients with a prior history of mental health problems.

--Physicians detected depression in the "in-between" group based on their knowledge of the patient's prior mental health history.

--Primary care doctors detected depression in their patients more frequently when they knew them well.

Researchers used a two-stage sampling strategy to select patients. In stage one, 1,928 adult patients were given standard diagnostic tests for major depressive disorder (MDD) while they were waiting for a scheduled visit with their family doctor. Completed questionnaires were received from 1,580 of these patients.

Immediately after the office visit, physicians completed a rating form that measured perception of patient depression, general health and stress as well as other measures of the physician's treatment history with the patient.

For the second stage, a weighted subsample of the 1,580 patients was selected to undergo further testing by a trained social worker or master's level clinical psychologist. From this subsample, a group of 372 patients was used in the study.

Previous research at the U-M found that family physicians successfully diagnosed most severely depressed patients, but often missed those with more minimal impairment. Klinkman and his team closely examined those patients who were "missed"---the false-positives (patients identified by their physician as depressed who did not meet diagnostic criteria for major depression) and false-negatives (patients who met criteria for major depression who were not identified by their physician). They found that the two groups were indistinguishable in their clinical characteristics. The study showed the main indicator for how a physician diagnosed and treated depression in these patients was prior knowledge of clinical history.

In comparison to the standard structured clinical interview, family doctors using the aforementioned clinical history cues misdiagnosed the majority of depressed patients---over-diagnosing (false-positives) and under-diagnosing (false-negatives) at equal rates. Klinkman says this is because of rigid diagnostic criteria that define major depression as a symptom count during a two-week period.

"One thing that seems clear from our study results," Klinkman says, "is that depression in primary care is more accurately defined by symptoms and impairment over time. A patient currently being treated for depression would not be diagnosed as a 'case' using standard criteria. This makes little sense."

Klinkman and his investigators propose a new conceptual model of diagnosing and treating depression in the primary care setting---one that views major depressive disorder as a chronic condition that ebbs and flows over time.

By looking at the disease over a longer period of time, the true positives would still be identified, while many false-positives in this study would be more accurately seen as patients with MDD undergoing successful treatment. Klinkman says the remainder of the false-positive and false-negatives should be diagnosed as a distressed group who were possibly depressed, but had minimal impairment and warranted further evaluation to more accurately diagnose.
The U-M research team consisted of Klinkman, James Coyne, Ph.D., Susan Gallo, Ph.D., and Thomas Schwenk, M.D. The study was funded by a grant from the National Institute of Mental Health.

University of Michigan Medical Center
Department of Public Relations
October 6, 1998 (4)
Contact: David Wilkins
1500 E. Medical Center Dr. Ann Arbor, MI 48109
Phone: 734-764-2220
E-mail: wilkins@umich.edu

University of Michigan Medical Center
Department of Public Relations
October 6, 1998 (4)
Contact: Pete Barkey
1500 E. Medical Center Dr. Ann Arbor, MI 48109
Phone: 734-764-2220
E-mail: pbarkey@umich.edu

University of Michigan

Related Depression Articles from Brightsurf:

Children with social anxiety, maternal history of depression more likely to develop depression
Although researchers have known for decades that depression runs in families, new research from Binghamton University, State University of New York, suggests that children suffering from social anxiety may be at particular risk for depression in the future.

Depression and use of marijuana among US adults
This study examined the association of depression with cannabis use among US adults and the trends for this association from 2005 to 2016.

Maternal depression increases odds of depression in offspring, study shows
Depression in mothers during and after pregnancy increased the odds of depression in offspring during adolescence and adulthood by 70%.

Targeting depression: Researchers ID symptom-specific targets for treatment of depression
For the first time, physician-scientists at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center have identified two clusters of depressive symptoms that responded to two distinct neuroanatomical treatment targets in patients who underwent transcranial magnetic brain stimulation (TMS) for treatment of depression.

A biological mechanism for depression
Researchers report that in depressed individuals there are increased amounts of an unmodified structural protein, called tubulin, in lipid rafts compared with non-depressed individuals.

Depression in adults who are overweight or obese
In an analysis of primary care records of 519,513 UK adults who were overweight or obese between 2000-2016 and followed up until 2019, the incidence of new cases of depression was 92 per 10,000 people per year.

Why stress doesn't always cause depression
Rats susceptible to anhedonia, a core symptom of depression, possess more serotonin neurons after being exposed to chronic stress, but the effect can be reversed through amygdala activation, according to new research in JNeurosci.

Which comes first: Smartphone dependency or depression?
New research suggests a person's reliance on his or her smartphone predicts greater loneliness and depressive symptoms, as opposed to the other way around.

Depression breakthrough
Major depressive disorder -- referred to colloquially as the 'black dog' -- has been identified as a genetic cause for 20 distinct diseases, providing vital information to help detect and manage high rates of physical illnesses in people diagnosed with depression.

CPAP provides relief from depression
Researchers have found that continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) treatment of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) can improve depression symptoms in patients suffering from cardiovascular diseases.

Read More: Depression News and Depression Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.