Terrorism risk insurance program benefits taxpayers, policyholders, RAND study finds

October 10, 2007

Taxpayers save money and businesses are better protected with the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act (TRIA) in place than if the act is allowed to expire, according to a RAND Corporation study issued today.

The analysis found that TRIA, authorized by Congress following the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, allows the insurance industry to play a larger role in compensating losses caused by smaller -- and presumed more likely -- terrorist attacks by transferring some of the risk for the largest attack to the government.

The study, which is the first to consider the effect of TRIA on government assistance for uninsured loses after an attack, shows that taxpayers are better served if TRIA remains in effect rather than being allowed to expire by Congress.

The study also says that taxpayers and policyholders could also benefit if the law were expanded to better address nuclear, chemical, biological and radiological (NCBR) attacks.

The study was conducted by the RAND Center for Terrorism Risk Management Policy. RAND is a nonprofit research organization.

Legislation is currently being considered by Congress that would extend and modify TRIA. The proposed legislation would require insurers to offer coverage for NCBR attacks and includes several additional provisions that transfer some of the risk for attacks on the scale of 9/11 or larger to the government.

The RAND study compares the performance of the current TRIA program and several alternative government interventions in the market for terrorism insurance over a wide range of scenarios.

Among the key findings: "Overall, TRIA improves the functioning of private insurance markets and ultimately saves the taxpayers money because it transfers risk for the largest terrorist attacks to the government," said Lloyd Dixon, a RAND economist and study co-author. "In return, the insurance industry is able to play a larger role in compensating losses caused by smaller, and more likely, attacks."

Dixon said a gap remains in the nation's ability to manage terrorism risk because the coverage for nuclear, biological, chemical, and radiological attacks is rarely available even with the current TRIA program. Thus, the RAND study examined possible changes to TRIA that would require insurers to offer policies that cover losses due to both conventional and NBCR attacks.

The study, "The Federal Role in Terrorism Insurance," finds that increasing assurances that insurers will not be liable for insured losses over the current $100 billion TRIA cap and lowering the amount that insurers would have to pay before government support would be available (the so-called "deductible") could improve outcomes for a program requiring insurers to offer policies that cover both conventional and NCBR attacks.

"Hardening the cap and reducing the deductible are both important to getting the best result from a TRIA program that includes NCBR coverage," said study co-author Robert Lempert. "It's a robust strategy that effectively addresses the existing insurer uncertainty over how exposed they are to losses over the cap."
Other authors include Tom LaTourrette and Robert T. Reville.

The RAND Center for Terrorism Risk Management Policy conducts research to inform public and private decision-makers on economic security issues created by the threat of terrorism. The center is a partnership of the RAND Institute for Civil Justice, the RAND Infrastructure, Safety and Environment unit, and Risk Management Solutions, the world's leading provider of models and services for catastrophe risk management.

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit research organization providing objective analysis and effective solutions that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors around the world.

RAND Corporation

Related Risk Articles from Brightsurf:

Early life risk factors predict higher obesity and cardiometabolic risk
Early life risk factors in the first 1000 days cumulatively predict higher obesity and cardiometabolic risk in early adolescence, according to new research led by the Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute.

None of the most common blood pressure medications increased the risk of depression, some lowered the risk
Among the 41 most common blood pressure medications, none of them raised the risk of depression, according to an analysis from Denmark.

Lung-specific risk factors may increase hip fracture risk in individuals who smoke
Smoking has been linked to a higher risk of bone fractures.

Genetic risk scores may improve clinical identification of patients with heart attack risk
Researchers at Mass General and the Broad Institute have found that applying polygenic risk scores can identify patients at risk of a heart attack who may be missed in standard clinical evaluations.

New risk prediction model could identify those at higher risk of pancreatic cancer
A risk prediction model that combined genetic and clinical factors with circulating biomarkers identified people at significantly higher than normal risk of pancreatic cancer.

Risk of HIV-related heart disease risk varies by geography, income
People living with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection are at higher risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) compared to people without HIV.

Genetic study provides most comprehensive map of risk to date of breast cancer risk
A major international study of the genetics of breast cancer has identified more than 350 DNA 'errors' that increase an individual's risk of developing the disease.

New risk scores help physicians provide better care for high-risk pulmonary patients, study finds
Study of more than 17,000 patients finds new laboratory-based method of estimating outcomes for patients with a severe pulmonary disorder that has no cure can help physicians better provide proper care, referrals, and services for patients at the end of life.

Researchers develop model to predict suicide risk in at-risk young adults
New research from Pitt's School of Medicine shows that fluctuation and severity of depressive symptoms are much better at predicting risk of suicidal behavior in at-risk young adults.

High-risk sexually transmitted HPV virus associated with increased CVD risk
Infection with high-risk strains of the human papillomavirus (HPV), which have been linked to cancer, might increase the risk of heart and blood vessel or cardiovascular disease, especially among women with obesity or other cardiovascular risk factors.

Read More: Risk News and Risk Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.