Poor education and training fuels reliance on migrant construction workers

October 13, 2010

Major building projects, such as the 2012 Olympics, rely heavily on migrant labour, which has led to strong criticism from trade unions and British workers.

A shortage of skilled British workers is due to the absence of an adequate education and training scheme and poor labour market regulation, according to University of Manchester academic Dr Paul Chan, working with Professor Linda Clarke at the University of Westminster and Professor Andrew Dainty from Loughborough University.

The transient nature of construction work has meant there is little incentive to provide a well-funded, comprehensive vocational education and training (VET) system.

Many other European states have strong VET and apprenticeship programmes that produce workers with a broad range of skills.

Workers trained in Britain, however, tend to be 'single-skilled'. According to the publication, European workers may be preferred for their flexibility and their broad-based skills - even though they may often be classified as less skilled and thus paid at lower rates.

Their availability is currently providing a 'short-term fix' for the industry's problems but is also reinforcing employers' reluctance to provide alternative training for British workers.

On big building sites especially, the 'bogus' self-employment of migrant workers is a problem.

Such situations can result in exploitative hours and pay, and workers forgoing benefits they would be entitled to as a direct employee. Above all, it acts as a disincentive to train and to innovate in an industry desperate for both.

The UK construction industry has come to rely on 'poaching' labour trained and educated at considerable expense elsewhere, in particular in the east European countries, argues Dr Chan and colleagues in the book 'Who needs migrant workers?' by Martin Ruhs and Bridget Anderson.

In a chapter written by Dr Chan and his colleagues, they claim an improved VET system should be central to any policy attempt to 'manage migration'.

Dr Chan, from the School of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, said: "The project-based nature of the construction industry promotes the use of a transient, casual, and self-employed workforce, which erodes the incentive for employers to invest in training.

"Furthermore, years of deregulation have resulted in large-scale self-employment, undermining managerial control and encouraging low-skill, low-wage strategies."

"We need to develop an improved and comprehensive VET system, supported with measures to manage the integration of migrant workers into the sector and to regulate the labour market. These would keep the industry strong and ensure a solid skills base for the future."

"It has been shown in other European countries that, managed effectively, migrant workers can be a force for positive change."

"The fact that many migrants have considerable knowledge and expertise is likely to be critical in establishing an effective VET programme."

University of Manchester

Related Civil Engineering Articles from Brightsurf:

Vaccine opposition online uniting around 'civil liberties' argument
Anti-vaccination discourse on Facebook increased in volume over the last decade, coalescing around the argument that refusing to vaccinate is a civil right, according to a study published today in the American Journal of Public Health.

Study examines how civil wars affect wildlife populations
A new study comprehensively reveals how civil wars impact wildlife in countries affected by conflict.

Scientists trace and identify origin of smallpox vaccine strains used in Civil War
Scientists and historians working at McMaster University, the Mütter Museum and the University of Sydney have pieced together the genomes of old viruses that were used as vaccination strains during and after the American Civil War ultimately leading to the eradication of smallpox.

Genetic identification of human remains from the Spanish Civil War and the dictatorship
The BIOMICs Research Team at the UPV/EHU have published the results of analyses which have enabled the genetic identification of 525 human remains recovered from different mass graves dating from the Spanish Civil War and the subsequent dictatorship.

Music was form of resistance for women during Civil Rights Movement
'Freedom songs' were key in giving motivation and comfort to those fighting for equal rights, in addition to helping empower Black women to lead others when formal leadership positions were unavailable.

1 in 5 civil monetary penalties due to EMTALA violations involved psychiatric emergencies
Nearly one in five civil monetary penalty settlements related to Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) violations involved psychiatric emergencies.

Post-bypass survival linked to civil status and class
Civil status, education, and income are factors shown to be clearly associated with duration of survival after a bypass operation.

Facial recognition software to identify Civil War soldiers
Photo Sleuth may help uncover the mysteries of nearly 4 million photographs of Civil War-era images.

MU scientists use smartphones to improve dismal rating of nation's civil infrastructure
In the United States, aging civil infrastructure systems are deteriorating on a massive scale.

Civil engineers at Concordia University devise a cost-saving solution for cities
Why fix a road today if it's slated to be ripped up for new sewers next summer?

Read More: Civil Engineering News and Civil Engineering Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.