Historian traces the origins of rent control in World War I-era New York

October 21, 2013

CAMBRIDGE, Mass -- In 1920, a Bronx district court judge named William E. Morris heard a series of cases that aroused his ire. Morris was a tough Army veteran: While serving under Gen. George Custer in 1876, he had survived wounds at the infamous Battle of Little Bighorn. But decades later, these cases kept getting under his skin.

When one lawyer in Morris' courtroom announced he would file for a writ of mandamus, to force an immediate hearing, Morris threatened to punch him, shouting, "I'll mandamus you in the nose." When another lawyer threatened an appeal of a Morris ruling, the judge responded, "Go to the Supreme Court. Go to hell."

What subject could have so angered this judge? For those who have lived in New York and certain other high-rent districts, the answer may come as no surprise: It was rent control.

In a place where, then as now, real estate was highly coveted, the state of New York had just instituted the precursor to the rent-control policies that still exist today. Tempers flared; tenants went on strike; emotions boiled over in courtrooms. But a new legal idea had been implemented, and would even be upheld by the Supreme Court, granting rights to a group -- tenants -- who had not previously enjoyed such a foothold in cities.

This battle for control of urban space is the subject of a new book by MIT historian Robert Fogelson, "The Great Rent Wars," newly published by Yale University Press. Fogelson reconstructs the little-known circumstances that led to the creation of rent control in New York (and elsewhere), and in so doing uses history to let us consider anew the way that interests, money, and popular sentiment collide in American politics.

"I had no idea there was rent control as early as there was in New York and other cities," says Fogelson, who grew up in a rent-controlled apartment in New York. "I'm interested in telling the story and trying to figure out what inspired people to act in the way they did."

How World War I lowered the rent

Rent control in the United States has its origins in World War I, which directed material resources away from housing, and soon led to an acute shortage of new buildings in New York.

"These great rent strikes were largely a consequence of the almost complete cessation of residential construction during and after World War I," says Fogelson, a professor of urban studies and history. "Builders stopped building. Investors stopped investing. The result of this was a very serious housing shortage." The city's vacancy rate dropped to a fraction of 1 percent.

As a consequence, rents soared, and a new social movement cropped up: Renters started organizing rent strikes to protest the punitive monthly housing costs they faced.

"The most active strikes were in working-class neighborhoods," Fogelson says; they often occurred in Jewish immigrant neighborhoods such as Brownsville and Williamsburg in Brooklyn. "Women played a large role, staffing the picket lines, fighting with landlords, trying to head off the police." Women had organized strikes against the garment manufacturers, he adds, and now "applied some of the same tactics to landlords and housing."

In light of this unrest, New York's state legislature took action. Although then controlled by Republicans, who traditionally favored building owners, the legislature passed a rent-control program designed to keep costs down and limit baseless evictions. Facing the same general circumstances, similar laws were passed elsewhere in the country, including Washington, D.C.

Surprisingly, New York's legislature failed to create a board to oversee the implementation of its new laws. That left enforcement of rent control to the city's 50 municipal court judges. Some, like Morris, were sympathetic to tenants; others, to owners. All were in new legal territory.

"The municipal court judges had to deal with problems the likes of which they'd never seen before," Fogelson says: Did residential rent control apply to a resident who had started a home-based business? What was a reasonable rent? The result was a patchwork of rulings.

The 'emergency' ends

The rent-control regime lasted until 1929, when New York City's housing "emergency" was deemed over, and the state laws expired. A building boom in the mid-1920s had helped ease the housing crunch, at least for the well-off.

"The idea was that the market is now capable of dealing with housing," Fogelson notes. Yet the rent-control concept lingered on. It was revived during World War II, and remains today, sometimes in the form of "rent stabilization" laws that limit rent increases.

Fogelson shuns direct comparisons between the rent-control wars of the 1920s and any current housing issues in New York. Still, he notes, even the developer-friendly New York of today has not erased all support for rent control.

"The tenants still have a fair amount of clout," Fogelson says. However, he adds, the original working-class drive for rent control was abetted by support from a middle class that was hit by the housing crisis of the late 1910s. Then, when the housing stock expanded, "Politically it was harder to make the case to keep rent control," Fogelson says.
-end-
Written by Peter Dizikes, MIT News Office

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Related History Articles from Brightsurf:

Reconstructing global climate through Earth's history
Accurate temperature estimates of ancient oceans are vital because they are the best tool for reconstructing global climate conditions in the past.

The colorful history of plastids
Emerging genome data provides new insight into plastid evolution.

The magnetic history of ice
The history of our planet has been written, among other things, in the periodic reversal of its magnetic poles.

Researchers map the evolutionary history of oaks
Oaks have a complex evolutionary history that has long eluded scientists.

Ancient Roman port history unveiled
A team of international researchers led by La Trobe University and the University of Melbourne have, for the first time worldwide, applied marine geology techniques at an ancient harbour archaeological site to uncover ancient harbour technologies of the first centuries AD.

The ancient history of Neandertals in Europe
Parts of the genomes of two ~120,000-year-old Neandertals from Germany and Belgium have been sequenced at the MPI for Evolutionary Anthropology.

A history of the Crusades, as told by crusaders' DNA
History can tell us a lot about the Crusades, the series of religious wars fought between 1095 and 1291, in which Christian invaders tried to claim the Near East.

The history of humanity in your face
The skull and teeth provide a rich library of changes that we can track over time, describing the history of evolution of our species.

Retrieving climate history from the ice
In the context of a major European Union project, experts from 14 institutions in ten European countries have spent three years combing the Antarctic ice, looking for the ideal site to investigate the climate history of the past 1.5 million years.

Rivers raged on Mars late into its history
A new study by University of Chicago scientists catalogued these rivers to conclude that significant river runoff persisted on Mars later into its history than previously thought.

Read More: History News and History Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.