New approach required for obtaining informed consent in less-developed countries

October 24, 2002

Authors of a research letter in this week's issue of THE LANCET highlight the difficulty of obtaining valid consent from people in less-developed countries who are about to participate in medical research.

Few practical guidelines exist on how to ensure that research participants in less-developed countries understand the consent form before enrolment. Daniel W Fitzgerald from Cornell University Medical College, New York, USA, and colleagues compared the understanding of the consent process among prospective participants about to enter an HIV-1 research programme in Haiti; 15 potential participants were given conventional (western-style) explanations from one physician;30 further participants were given three explanatory sessions with the help of a counsellor.

All potential participants were required to score at least 80% in an oral test to assess their understanding of the consent process; only 20% of participants given conventional explanations passed the eligibility test, compared with 80% of people given in-depth explanations by a counsellor, who was a qualified Haitian Social Worker; in-depth explanations included the communication of key messages assisted by visual material, including anatomical diagrams.

Daniel Fitzgerald comments: "We conclude that research participants in a less-developed country can comprehend a complex consent form if sufficient care is taken to provide them with information. However, our findings indicate that the standard consent process of a single meeting between investigator and volunteer might be insufficient, and that new techniques should be developed to improve the informed consent process."

In an accompanying Commentary (p 1266), Paul Farmer from Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA, concludes: "All medical and public-health researchers would like a magic bullet that would make research undeniably ethical. But there is no magic bullet. There is only the complex and difficult process of linking research in resource-poor settings to the services demanded by poor people. The alternative prospect-a world in which medical research is dedicated wholly to the diseases of the affluent-is too painful to contemplate."
Contact: Dr Daniel W Fitzgerald, Division of International Medicine and Infectious Diseases, Cornell University Medical College,
Room A-421, 1300 York Avenue, New York, NY 10021, USA;
T) 212-746-6320;
F) 212-746-8675;

Dr Paul Farmer, Department of Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School,
641 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA 02115, USA;
T) 617-432-3715;
F) 617-432-6045;


Related Medical Research Articles from Brightsurf:

Patients say ask before using medical records for research
A new study led by Michigan Medicine researchers finds that even when patients understand the overall benefit to society, they still want to be able to give consent at least once before their de-identified data is used for research.

Most patients willing to share medical records for research purposes
In a survey, UC San Diego researchers report most patients are willing to share medical records for research purposes, with a few caveats.

Tax hurts investment in medical device research and development
New Iowa State University research shows companies cut funding for research and development in response to a tax imposed on medical devices as part of the Affordable Care Act.

Centralized infrastructure facilitates medical education research
The Council of Academic Family Medicine Educational Research Alliance has enabled a large number of research teams to conduct meaningful scholarship with a fraction of the usual time and energy.

Sex, gender, or both in medical research
Only a minority of medical studies take sex and gender into account when analyzing and reporting research results.

Research!America to honor medical and health research advocacy leaders
Research!America's 21st annual Advocacy Awards will honor outstanding advocates for research whose contributions to health and medicine have saved lives and improved quality of life for patients worldwide.

Ohioans say it is important for the state to lead in education and medical research
An overwhelming majority of Ohio residents say it is important for the state to be a leader in education (89 percent) and in medical and health research (87 percent), according to a state-based public opinion survey commissioned by Research!America.

Medical research influenced by training 'genealogy'
By analyzing peer-reviewed scientific papers that examined the effectiveness of a surgical procedure, researchers at University of California, San Diego School of Medicine provide evidence suggesting that the conclusions of these studies appear to be influenced by the authors' mentors and medical training.

Diversity in medical research is a long way off, study shows
Despite Congressional mandates aimed at diversifying clinical research, little has changed in the last 30 years in both the numbers of studies that include minorities and the diversity of scientists being funded, according to a new analysis by researchers at UCSF.

Research!America to honor leaders in medical and health research advocacy
Research!America's 20th annual Advocacy Awards will honor exceptional advocates for research whose achievements in their fields have brought hope to patients worldwide.

Read More: Medical Research News and Medical Research Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to