Affordable Care Act Medicare payment reforms improve patient experiences

October 29, 2014

Beneficiaries enrolled in Accountable Care Organizations, a payment model that allows provider groups to share in the savings when they reduce Medicare patient spending and improve quality of care, reported improved satisfaction with their care in the first year of the program.

Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs), a key Medicare payment reform component of the Affordable Care Act, are designed to improve patient experience and quality of care and to reduce health care spending. The two ACO programs under the ACA, the Pioneer program and the Medicare Shared Savings Program, launched in 2012, expanded rapidly through 2013 and 2014, and now serve about 5.6 million Medicare beneficiaries, representing about 11 percent of the Medicare population.

This study, conducted by researchers in the Harvard Medical School Department of Health Care Policy, is the first to measure the early impact of the program on the experiences of patients enrolled in ACOs. The findings are published today in the New England Journal of Medicine.

"As payment moves away from fee-for-service toward incentives to limit health care spending, we found no evidence of deteriorating patient experiences in ACOs. In fact, ACOs achieved meaningful improvements for patients in some key areas," said lead author of the study J. Michael McWilliams, associate professor of health care policy and medicine at HMS and Brigham and Women's Hospital. "The improvements that we found in patient experiences constitute important initial progress in fostering high-quality, patient-centered care in Medicare."

The improvements were concentrated in areas that organizations may more easily modify though the implementation of new scheduling, referral or information systems. For example, beneficiaries served by ACOs reported significant improvements in timely access to care, perceived coordination of their care and access to their medical information.

In contrast, there were no significant improvements in how ACO patients rated their individual physicians or their physicians' communication skills. Improvements in those areas may be harder to achieve and slower to manifest because they require changes in physician behavior, the authors wrote.

The greatest improvements occurred among the most medically complex quarter of patients, those with multiple illnesses who are the focus of ACO efforts to improve quality and lower costs. In this group, improvements in overall ratings of care were equivalent to moving an ACO from average performance to being in the top 4 to 18 percent of ACOs.

The ACO programs operate in the traditional Medicare fee-for-service model, where providers are paid for each medical service they provide. In order to save costs, physician groups and hospitals in an ACO must provide fewer or lower-cost services. If the care that they cut is important to patients, patient experiences could suffer. If the care is important to patient health, other quality metrics and patient outcomes could deteriorate. Thus, Medicare ACO contracts include incentives both to slow spending and improve quality of care, including several measures of patient experience.

Using Medicare claims and linked data from the Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS) survey, an ongoing nationwide survey of patient experiences in Medicare, the researchers compared the patient satisfaction of 32,000 beneficiaries served by ACOs with those of 250,000 beneficiaries served by other providers. Comparing demographically and geographically matched groups, they estimated the change in patient experience that couldn't be attributed to other ongoing changes in the health care system.

Taken with preliminary reports from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services that suggest some evidence of modest financial savings from the ACO program, the researchers said that their findings suggest that ACOs might be a viable way to realize benefits for patients while controlling spending.

"While these early findings are encouraging, there is a pressing need for regulatory and legislative changes to strengthen ACO incentives, expand provider participation in new payment models and address potential downsides of provider integration, such as higher prices," McWilliams said. "Our study suggests a promising start, but there is a long road ahead."
This research was funded by grants from the National Institute on Aging (P01 AG032952), John and Laura Arnold Foundation, Doris Duke Charitable Foundation (Clinical Scientist Development Award #2010053) and Beeson Career Development Program (National Institute on Aging K08 AG038354 and the American Federation for Aging Research).

Written by Jake Miller

Harvard Medical School

Related Medicare Articles from Brightsurf:

Falling Medicare reimbursement rates for orthopaedic trauma
The amount Medicare reimburses for orthopaedic trauma surgery has fallen by nearly one-third over the past two decades, reports a study in the Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma.

Medicare coverage varies for transgender hormone therapies
A new study has shown substantial variability in access to guideline-recommended hormone therapies for older transgender individuals insured through Medicare.

Medicare changes may increase access to TAVR
The number of hospitals providing TAVR could double with changes to Medicare requirements.

Inequitable medicare reimbursements threaten care of most vulnerable
Hospitals, doctors and Medicare Advantage insurance plans that care for some of the most vulnerable patients are not reimbursed fairly by Medicare, according to recent findings in JAMA.

Medicare may overpay for many surgical procedures
For most surgical procedures, Medicare provides physicians a single bundled payment that covers both the procedure and related postoperative care over a period of up to 90 days.

Only 1 in 4 Medicare patients participate in cardiac rehabilitation
Only about 24% of Medicare patients who could receive outpatient cardiac rehabilitation participate in the program.

How common is food insecurity among Medicare enrollees? 
Nearly 1 in 10 Medicare enrollees age 65 and over and 4 in 10 enrollees younger than 65 with long-term disabilities experience food insecurity.

Medicare for All unlikely to cause surge in hospital use: Harvard study
Despite some analysts' claims that Medicare for All would cause a sharp increase in health care utilization, a new study finds the two biggest coverage expansions in US history -- Medicare and the ACA -- caused no net increase in hospital use.

Critical heart drug too pricey for some Medicare patients
An effective drug to treat chronic heart failure may cost too much for senior citizens with a standard Medicare Part D drug plan, said a study co-authored by a John A.

Research suggests strategy for more equitable Medicare reimbursement
Those who were enrolled in both Medicare and Medicaid were sicker, had more cognitive impairments and difficulty functioning, and needed more social support than those who were not enrolled in both government programs, Saint Louis University research found.

Read More: Medicare News and Medicare Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to