Study finds pay-for-performance now common among US HMOs

November 01, 2006

Boston, MA -- Pay-for-performance plans, which aim to improve the value of health care by paying providers based on quality and cost measures, have been a hotly debated topic in recent years. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) is considering adopting pay-for-performance for physicians and health plans, and the private sector has been implementing these plans around the country. But until now, there hasn't been a systematic study of how much national penetration these plans have among commercial HMOs in the U.S. In a new study, researchers from the Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH) have found that pay-for-performance plans are increasingly common--their survey found that 52.1% of health plans representing 81.3% of people enrolled in HMOs used pay-for-performance programs in 2005. The study also identified important details about these programs and the types of commercial HMOs that are implementing them.

"This is the only national estimate we have of pay-for-performance and thus the best information on current models for private health plans and agencies such as Medicare as they move toward adoption of pay-for-performance," said Meredith Rosenthal, associate professor of health economics and policy at HSPH and lead author of the study.

The study appears in the November 2, 2006, issue of The New England Journal of Medicine.

Rosenthal, Dr. Arnold Epstein, chair, Department of Health Policy and Management and the study's senior author, and colleagues surveyed health plans, including doctors and hospitals, offering commercial HMO products, between July 2005 and January 2006. The 242 plans responding to the survey represented 81.3% of people enrolled in HMOs. The respondents provided information about the characteristics of their health plans, including whether primary-care physicians (PCPs) were required for enrollees, how they were paid by plans for primary care, and the use of bonuses or penalties related to performance. For example, health plans were asked whether physicians were paid bonuses based on their provision of recommended preventive treatments or their performance on patient surveys and similarly whether hospitals were paid in part based on meeting standards for patient safety, such as having a computerized medication system in the hospital.

Respondents also provided information on the types of performance indicators they used, such as clinical quality, use of information technology and patient satisfaction.

Some of the highlights of the survey: The authors believe the findings can serve as a useful resource for CMS as it goes about designing pay-for-performance programs for Medicare. For example, currently Medicare doesn't require recipients to choose a primary-care physician. The survey showed that HMOs that similarly don't require many of their members to select a PCP were less likely to use pay-for-performance. That finding may reflect that, when there are many doctors involved with a patient's care, it may be difficult to attribute performance to a single doctor or group. CMS may need to consider the challenges of implementing pay-for-performance in the absence of a PCP requirement.

Another study finding was that HMOs tend to pay medical groups for performance rather than individual doctors. Medicare, for the most part, does not contract with groups; it may need to do so to take full advantage of pay-for-performance.

The authors note some limitations of the study, including that the findings are applicable only to HMOs, not to preferred-provider organizations, in which pay-for-performance is less prevalent.

"Our data show that pay-for-performance has become a widespread phenomenon in the HMO sector. As the design of Medicare pay-for-performance moves forward, this national snapshot of commercial payers' programs provides both a template and context for Medicare's own efforts," said Rosenthal.

Dr. Epstein added, "It is clear from our study that we are now rapidly gaining experience with pay-for-performance in the commercial HMO sector. Nevertheless, instituting pay-for performance will be a challenge for Medicare as the most commonly used commercial models will require substantial modification to fit the Medicare environment."
The study was supported by a grant from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.

Harvard School of Public Health is dedicated to advancing the public's health through learning, discovery, and communication. More than 300 faculty members are engaged in teaching and training the 900-plus student body in a broad spectrum of disciplines crucial to the health and well being of individuals and populations around the world. Programs and projects range from the molecular biology of AIDS vaccines to the epidemiology of cancer; from risk analysis to violence prevention; from maternal and children's health to quality of care measurement; from health care management to international

Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health

Related Public Health Articles from Brightsurf:

COVID-19 and the decolonization of Indigenous public health
Indigenous self-determination, leadership and knowledge have helped protect Indigenous communities in Canada during the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, and these principles should be incorporated into public health in future, argue the authors of a commentary in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal)

Public health consequences of policing homelessness
In a new study examining homelessness, researchers find that policy such a lifestyle has massive public health implications, making sleeping on the street even MORE unhealthy.

Electronic health information exchange improves public health disease reporting
Disease tracking is an important area of focus for health departments in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Pandemic likely to cause long-term health problems, Yale School of Public Health finds
The coronavirus pandemic's life-altering effects are likely to result in lasting physical and mental health consequences for many people--particularly those from vulnerable populations--a new study led by the Yale School of Public Health finds.

The Lancet Public Health: US modelling study estimates impact of school closures for COVID-19 on US health-care workforce and associated mortality
US policymakers considering physical distancing measures to slow the spread of COVID-19 face a difficult trade-off between closing schools to reduce transmission and new cases, and potential health-care worker absenteeism due to additional childcare needs that could ultimately increase mortality from COVID-19, according to new modelling research published in The Lancet Public Health journal.

The Lancet Public Health: Access to identification documents reflecting gender identity may improve trans mental health
Results from a survey of over 20,000 American trans adults suggest that having access to identification documents which reflect their identified gender helps to improve their mental health and may reduce suicidal thoughts, according to a study published in The Lancet Public Health journal.

The Lancet Public Health: Study estimates mental health impact of welfare reform, Universal Credit, in Great Britain
The 2013 Universal Credit welfare reform appears to have led to an increase in the prevalence of psychological distress among unemployed recipients, according to a nationally representative study following more than 52,000 working-age individuals from England, Wales, and Scotland over nine years between 2009-2018, published as part of an issue of The Lancet Public Health journal on income and health.

BU researchers: Pornography is not a 'public health crisis'
Researchers from the Boston University School of Public Health (BUSPH) have written an editorial in the American Journal of Public Health special February issue arguing against the claim that pornography is a public health crisis, and explaining why such a claim actually endangers the health of the public.

The Lancet Public Health: Ageism linked to poorer health in older people in England
Ageism may be linked with poorer health in older people in England, according to an observational study of over 7,500 people aged over 50 published in The Lancet Public Health journal.

Study: Public transportation use linked to better public health
Promoting robust public transportation systems may come with a bonus for public health -- lower obesity rates.

Read More: Public Health News and Public Health Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to