Nav: Home

Higher physician spending linked with fewer malpractice claims, finds US study

November 04, 2015

A higher use of resources by US physicians is associated with a reduced risk of malpractice claims, finds a study published by The BMJ this week.

However, the researchers say it is uncertain whether higher spending is defensively motivated.

Defensive medicine is defined as medical care provided to patients solely to reduce the threat of malpractice liability rather than to further diagnosis or treatment.

In the United States most physicians report practicing defensive medicine to reduce malpractice liability. However, there are no studies of whether greater resource use by physicians - defensively motivated or not - is associated with reduced risk of malpractice claims.

So a team of US-based researchers set out to investigate whether physicians who provide more costly care in a given year are less likely to face malpractice claims the following year.

They linked data on nearly 19 million hospital admissions in Florida between 2000 and 2009 to the malpractice history of over 24,000 physicians in seven specialties.

They also tested whether obstetricians with a greater tendency to perform caesarean deliveries in a given year (commonly considered a defensive practice) had lower malpractice claims the following year.

Differences in patient characteristics and diagnoses were taken into account.

Overall, 4,342 malpractice claims were filed against physicians (2.8% per physician year). Malpractice rates varied across specialty, ranging from 1.6% per physician year in pediatrics to 4.1% per physician year in general surgery and obstetrics and gynecology.

Across all specialties, greater average spending by physicians was associated with reduced risk of incurring a malpractice claim.

For example, in internal medicine, the probability of experiencing an alleged malpractice incident in the following year ranged from 1.5% in the bottom spending fifth ($19,725 per hospital admission) to 0.3% in the top fifth ($39,379 per hospital admission).

Similar associations were seen among pediatricians, surgeons, and obstetricians. Family medicine physicians were the only physicians where this association was not observed.

Furthermore, these relations held after adjusting for patient characteristics and accounting for physician characteristics such as patient mix, clinical skills, or communication skills.

The authors say that this is an observational study so no definitive conclusions can be drawn about cause and effect. They also highlight weaknesses, including the lack of information on illness severity and uncertainty around whether higher spending is defensively motivated.

Nevertheless, they say their findings suggest that greater resource use, whether it reflects defensive medicine or not, is associated with fewer malpractice claims.

This is an important question that explores the contentious issues of defensive medicine and malpractice risk in the U.S. healthcare system, write Tara Bishop and Michael Pesko at Weill Cornell Medicine, New York in an accompanying editorial.

They argue that it's too early to say whether defensive medicine protects doctors against malpractice claims, but say these results "highlight the need for future research in this area."

It may be tempting for physicians to use the results to justify ordering unnecessary tests and procedures in order to reduce their malpractice risk, they explain. Instead, "we should consider Jena and colleagues' study as a contribution to our understanding of malpractice risk."

"The study shows that we need to better understand defensive medicine and how this type of practice impacts both patients and physicians," they conclude.
-end-


BMJ

Related Physicians Articles:

Types and distribution of payments from industry to physicians
In 2015, nearly half of physicians were reported to have received a total of $2.4 billion in industry-related payments, primarily involving general payments (including consulting fees and food and beverage), with a higher likelihood and value of payments to physicians in surgical than primary care specialties and to male than female physicians, according to a study published by JAMA in a theme issue on conflict of interest.
Is higher health care spending by physicians associated with better outcomes?
Higher health care utilization spending by physicians was not associated with better outcomes for hospitalized Medicare beneficiaries in a new article published online by JAMA Internal Medicine.
Time for physicians to prepare for impending appropriate use mandate
Within a year, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) will implement a provision in the Protecting Access to Medicare Act that requires physicians to consult appropriate use criteria using CMS-approved computer-based clinical decision support mechanisms when ordering advanced imaging procedures.
Four Loyola physicians named to Who's Who in Hispanic Chicago
Four Loyola Medicine physicians have been named to Negocios Now's 2016 'Who's Who in Hispanic Chicago.' Loyola has more physicians on the list than any other medical center.
Physicians are more likely to use hospice and intensive care at end of life
New research suggests that US physicians are more likely to use hospice and intensive or critical care units in the last months of life than non-physicians.
Professional burnout associated with physicians limiting practice
At a time when the nation is facing projected physician shortages, a Mayo Clinic study shows an association between burnout and declining professional satisfaction with physicians reducing the number of hours they devote to clinical practice.
By asking, 'what's the worst part of this?' physicians can ease suffering
When patients suffer, doctors tend to want to fix things and if they cannot many doctors then withdraw emotionally.
Physicians in training at high risk for depression
New research from Brigham and Women's Hospital finds that 28.8 percent of trainees screen positive for depression during their residency.
Physicians and burnout: It's getting worse
Burnout among US physicians is getting worse. An update from a three-year study evaluating burnout and work-life balance shows that American physicians are worse off today than they were three years earlier.
American College of Physicians urges physicians to oppose mass deportation
The American College of Physicians (ACP) today called on physicians, individually and collectively, to speak out against proposals to deport the 12 million US residents who lack documentation of legal residency status, citing the adverse impact that mass deportation would have on individuals and the health of the public.

Related Physicians Reading:

The Applicant's Manual of Physician Assistant Programs 2019
by Mark Volpe PA-C (Author), Brittany Hogan PA-C (Author)

The Physician Philosopher's Guide to Personal Finance: The 20% of Personal Finance Doctors Need to Know to Get 80% of the Results
by James D. Turner MD (Author)

A Comprehensive Review for the Certification and Recertification Examinations for Physician Assistants
by Claire O'Connell (Author)

ICD-10-CM 2019 for Physicians Professional with Guidelines
by Optum360º (Author)

Orthopaedics for Physician Assistants: Expert Consult - Online and Print
by Sara D Rynders MPAS PA-C (Author), Jennifer Hart PA-C ATC (Author)

ECG's for the Emergency Physician 1
by Amal Mattu (Author), William J. Brady (Editor)

2017 Physicians' Desk Reference 71st Edition (Physicians' Desk Reference (Pdr))
by PDR Staff (Author)

The Physician (The Cole Trilogy)
by Noah Gordon (Author)

Dear and Glorious Physician: A Novel about Saint Luke
by Taylor Caldwell (Author)

Physicians' Cancer Chemotherapy Drug Manual 2019
by Edward Chu (Author), Vincent T. DeVita Jr. (Author)

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Bias And Perception
How does bias distort our thinking, our listening, our beliefs... and even our search results? How can we fight it? This hour, TED speakers explore ideas about the unconscious biases that shape us. Guests include writer and broadcaster Yassmin Abdel-Magied, climatologist J. Marshall Shepherd, journalist Andreas Ekström, and experimental psychologist Tony Salvador.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#513 Dinosaur Tails
This week: dinosaurs! We're discussing dinosaur tails, bipedalism, paleontology public outreach, dinosaur MOOCs, and other neat dinosaur related things with Dr. Scott Persons from the University of Alberta, who is also the author of the book "Dinosaurs of the Alberta Badlands".