Nav: Home

Meniscus injury: Real surgery or sham surgery -- which is better for patients?

November 05, 2015

Patients with meniscus lesions benefit from a combination of sham surgery and physiotherapy just as much as from a real surgical procedure-- this was the conclusion reached in the Finnish FIDELITY study published in 2013. Ever since then, there has been considerable discussion about the benefits of meniscus surgery compared with physiotherapy. After all, about 300,000 meniscus procedures were performed in Germany in 2013. The question is: Should the non-surgical approach be preferred over surgical treatment or are there still advantages offered by surgery. To find out, Wolf Petersen, Andrea Achtnich and co-authors reviewed the current literature on the treatment of meniscus lesions and evaluated the advantages and disadvantages of each approach in their original article published in Deutsches Ärzteblatt International (Dtsch Arztebl Int 2015; 112: 705-13).

The Berlin-based orthopedic surgeons analyzed six randomized studies to establish which management approach--surgical or physiotherapy-- provides the greatest benefits to patients with meniscus tears. Almost all of these studies demonstrated comparable outcomes for the two treatment options. However, in about half of the studies there were some patients who did not respond to physiotherapy. These were then switched to the surgical study arms. After surgery, the outcomes achieved in these patients were comparable to those of the other patients who underwent surgery. Based on the data of these studies, the authors arrived at the conclusion that patients with a flap tear may not benefit from physiotherapy but may do so from arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. For this group of patients, surgery may be the treatment option to be recommended. However, targeted studies would need to be performed in the future to support such recommendation.

Deutsches Aerzteblatt International

Related Surgery Articles:

Bullies and their victims more likely to want plastic surgery
11.5 percent of bullying victims have extreme desire to have cosmetic surgery, as well as 3.4 percent of bullies and 8.8 percent of teenagers who both bully and are bullied -- compared with less than 1 percent of those who are unaffected by bullying.
Methadone may reduce need for opioids after surgery
Patients undergoing spinal fusion surgery who are treated with methadone during the procedure require significantly less intravenous and oral opioids to manage postoperative pain, reports a new study published in the May issue of Anesthesiology, the peer-reviewed medical journal of the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA).
New, persistent opioid use common after surgery
Among about 36,000 patients, approximately 6 percent continued to use opioids more than three months after their surgery, with rates not differing between major and minor surgical procedures, according to a study published by JAMA Surgery.
Refusing access to surgery recovery area at a UK hospital unless WHO Safe Surgery Checklist is fully complete
New research showing that refusal to allow surgery teams to take the patient to the recovery room after surgery unless the full WHO Safe Surgery Checklist has been complete is a highly effective way to improve use of the checklist.
Robotic surgery just got more autonomous
Putting surgery one step closer into the realm of self-driving cars and intelligent machines, researchers show for the first time that a supervised autonomous robot can successfully perform soft tissue surgery.
More Surgery News and Surgery Current Events

Best Science Podcasts 2019

We have hand picked the best science podcasts for 2019. Sit back and enjoy new science podcasts updated daily from your favorite science news services and scientists.
Now Playing: TED Radio Hour

Do animals grieve? Do they have language or consciousness? For a long time, scientists resisted the urge to look for human qualities in animals. This hour, TED speakers explore how that is changing. Guests include biological anthropologist Barbara King, dolphin researcher Denise Herzing, primatologist Frans de Waal, and ecologist Carl Safina.
Now Playing: Science for the People

#534 Bacteria are Coming for Your OJ
What makes breakfast, breakfast? Well, according to every movie and TV show we've ever seen, a big glass of orange juice is basically required. But our morning grapefruit might be in danger. Why? Citrus greening, a bacteria carried by a bug, has infected 90% of the citrus groves in Florida. It's coming for your OJ. We'll talk with University of Maryland plant virologist Anne Simon about ways to stop the citrus killer, and with science writer and journalist Maryn McKenna about why throwing antibiotics at the problem is probably not the solution. Related links: A Review of the Citrus Greening...