African bone tool discovery has important implications for evolution of human behavior

November 06, 2001

An emerging set of archaeological evidence may answer a key question in the human origins debate by providing proof that not only did early Homo sapiens come "out of Africa," as Homo erectus did, but that they came out fully modern, with fully developed modern behaviors that had evolved much earlier than previously thought. The new evidence includes the recent discovery in a South African cave of a large set of specialized bone tools, all dated at more than 70,000 years old. The discovery conclusively proves that human use of formal bone tool technology is more than twice as old as the previously accepted dates. The advent of bone tools was a major development in human tool technology and is considered by many archaeologists to be a key indicator of "behavioral modernity" in humans.

An analysis of the find, forthcoming in the December issue of the Journal of Human Evolution, argues that this ancient use of bone tool technology, together with related discoveries, has strong implications that "behavioral modernity" first evolved in Africa and has a much longer history than most archaeologists believe.

"The real implications are that there was modern human behavior in Africa about 35,000 years before Europe," said lead author Christopher S. Henshilwood, affiliate archaeologist at Iziko - South African Museum in Cape Town , and adjunct associate professor of archaeology at the State University of New York at Stony Brook.

"What has been suggested up until now is that modern human behavior was a very late occurrence. The implication was that though people were anatomically modern in Africa from about 150,000 to 100,000 years ago, they remained behaviorally non-modern until about 40,000 or 50 000 years ago, when they suddenly changed and then moved into Europe and elsewhere."

The paper, authored by Henshilwood with archaeologists Francesco d'Errico of the Institut de Prehistoire et de Geologie du Quaternaire, Curtis W. Marean of the Institute of Human Origins at Arizona State University, Chicago State University anthropologist Richard G. Milo and archaeologist Royden Yates from Iziko - South African Museum, involves the detailed description of 28 bone tools and related artifacts recovered from Blombos Cave, a cave in a cliff overlooking the Indian Ocean at the extreme southern tip of South Africa. Though other bone tools of similar antiquity have been found previously at other sites in Africa, for example at Katanda in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the Blombos discovery is the first indisputable evidence of an in situ Middle Stone Age bone tool industry. All other Middle Stone Age tools have either been singular finds, or the context has been disputed.

Bifacially flaked stone points, possibly used as spearheads, occur above and within the layers in which the bone tools were found. Archaeological sequences from other sites with bifacial points in the southern Cape date to about 65, 000 years ago, suggesting the bone tools at Blombos are at least as old.

Furthermore, a distinct sterile yellow sand horizon lies above the dark, anthropogenic (human produced) sediments that contain the bifacial points and bone tools, and below dark anthropogenic sediments of more recent age. The sand layer acts as a clear stratigraphic break because any penetration through this yellow sand by younger materials from above would be clearly visible and the sand layers are clearly undisturbed above where many of the bone tools occur.

At other archaeological sites in South Africa, such as at Die Kelders Cave 1, similar dune layers are found and they date to the Last Glacial (roughly 60,000-70,000 years ago) when the ocean withdrew further from the current coastline. On geological grounds, the sand layer at Blombos is almost certainly of similar age, making the bone tools somewhat older. Direct dating of these sterile yellow dune sediments and of burnt stone from the same layers as the bone tools using thermoluminescence methods is well advanced and the results are expected to be released shortly.

According to Marean, bone tools have been seen as one of a variety of significant indicators of modern human behavior because of the greater skill and labor involved in producing them and the shift to more specialized tool manufacture that generally accompanies them.

"In Europe, prior to 35,000 years ago, people did not make formal bone tools," said ASU's Marean. "After that, bone and antler become favorite raw materials, and even stone tools become 'more formal' tools- with regular shapes and specialized uses."

The existence of bone and other "formal" tools has been frequently cited as an important item on the "trait list" - a list of archaeological details traditionally seen as indicators of the presence modern human behavior in stone age and upper Paleolithic populations. Other items on the list include the hunting of large fish, the use of decoration, and the production of art - evidence of symbolic thinking.

The excavations at Blombos Cave and other similar sites have also yielded substantial quantities of ochre, a mineral compound that aboriginal peoples frequently use for body decoration. "More than 8,000 pieces of ochre were brought to the site and were used almost certainly for symbolic purposes," Henshilwood notes. Also found earlier at the site was a fragment of "deliberately engraved bone" (from a report published in Journal of Archaeological Science 28, Henshilwood et al. and a paper by d'Errico et al in Antiquity).

"Based on extensive evidence from European sites, what has been cited repeatedly is that there was an Upper Paleolithic 'symbolic explosion' that archaeologists have said indicates the best recorded beginning of modern human behavior at about 35,000 years ago," said Henshilwood. "The evidence from this cave, together with other evidence coming from other sites, is now starting to say to us that this is very questionable. We're seeing evidence of a comparable change in Africa, but in the Middle Stone Age -- more than twice as far back in time." "The African record is starting to show evidence that is making it look fundamentally different from Eurasia at the time. We're getting a lot of evidence for symboling behavior, and that is almost certainly related to language," said Marean.

Henshilwood and Marean both point out that the Blombos Cave material is likely to be just the beginning of an extensive body of evidence for early behavioral modernity in Africa, as information from a number of current digs begins to be published.

"Right now we are only scraping the surface of information about pre-historic Africa," said Henshilwood. "Europe, has been extensively excavated over the last 70 or 80 years and Europeans have an enormous amount of background information to draw on. Africa is geographically enormous when compared to western Europe, but it has been excavated properly only for a very short period, and very few sites in Africa have really been well-dug."

"I think that when we start to get a big sample, the picture of modern human evolution is going to look very different," said Marean. "A clear picture is emerging. This puts the behavioral evolution in step with the anatomical evolution. "Once again, in terms of human evolution, we are seeing Africa as being precocious: Bipedal hominids evolved in Africa; the first real increase in brain size occurred in Africa; and now, we are beginning to see that the last great advance, the development of modern behavior, was made in Africa as well. Now the question becomes where in Africa did this first begin to happen, and why did it happen?" he said.
This research was supported by grants from the National Geographic Society, the National Science Foundation, the National Research Foundation, the Leakey Foundation, the Anglo-American Chairman's Fund, the Human Services Research Council, the Service Culturel of the French Embassy in South Africa, and the Wenner-Gren Foundation.


Sources: Christopher Henshilwood, 011-47-555-89-323 Curtis Marean, 480-965-7796

Arizona State University

Related Human Evolution Articles from Brightsurf:

Cell-autonomous immunity shaped human evolution
Every human cell harbors its own defenses against microbial invaders, relying on strategies that date back to some of the earliest events in the history of life, researchers report.

Hunter-gatherer networks accelerated human evolution
Humans began developing a complex culture as early as the Stone Age.

Ancient gut microbiomes shed light on human evolution
The microbiome of our ancestors might have been more important for human evolution than previously thought.

Environment, not evolution, might underlie some human-ape differences
Apes' abilities have been unfairly measured, throwing into doubt the assumed belief that human infants are superior to adult chimpanzees, according to a new study by leaders in the field of ape cognition.

Neandertal genes give clues to human brain evolution
A distinctive feature of modern humans is our round (globular) skulls and brains.

Dryer, less predictable environment may have spurred human evolution
Evidence of a variable but progressively drying climate coincides with a major shift in stone-tool-making abilities and the appearance of modern Homo sapiens.

Evolution of psychiatric disorders and human personality traits
How and why human-unique characteristics such as highly social behavior, languages and complex culture have evolved is a long-standing question.

What gorilla poop tells us about evolution and human health
A study of the microbiomes of wild gorillas and chimpanzees offers insights into the evolution of the human microbiome and might even have implications for human health.

Why expressive brows might have mattered in human evolution
Highly mobile eyebrows that can be used to express a wide range of subtle emotions may have played a crucial role in human survival, new research from the University of York suggests.

Interdisciplinary approach yields new insights into human evolution
The evolution of human biology should be considered part and parcel with the evolution of humanity itself, proposes Nicole Creanza, assistant professor of biological sciences.

Read More: Human Evolution News and Human Evolution Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to