Race And Class Intelligence Gaps Groups Narrowed

November 07, 1997

ITHACA, N.Y. -- Intelligence test scores of Whites compared with African Americans, and of the members of high compared with low socio-economic groups, are not growing ever wider. This is contrary to often-reported arguments that Americans are getting dumber because low-IQ parents are outbreeding high-IQ parents. Rather, upon closer look, these scores point to a growing convergence, report two Cornell University developmental psychologists who are experts in intelligence assessment and types of intelligence.

In comprehensive analyses of national data sets of mental test scores (including tests containing verbal analogies, vocabulary, mathematics, science, writing and spatial reasoning) for American students, Wendy M. Williams and Stephen J. Ceci, both in the Department of Human Development at Cornell, write in the November 1997 issue of the scholarly journal American Psychologist that "there is no compelling evidence supporting the hypothesis that a dysgenic (negative) trend is at work, undermining Americans' intellectual capital." Williams is an associate professor of human development, and Ceci is the Helen L. Carr Professor of Developmental Psychology, both in the College of Human Ecology at Cornell.

Such dysgenic trends received wide publicity in 1994 with the publication of The Bell Curve by R.J. Herrnstein and C. Murray, which argued that demographic pressures were exerting such strong downward influence on cognititve ability in this country that dire negative social consequences would ensue.

Williams and Ceci, however, re-examined the data and looked at a broader base of tests that reflect cognitive ability; they focused on batteries of mental tests that are statistically comparable to IQ tests, as well as on IQ tests themselves. Their findings do not support suggestions put forth in The Bell Curve. Specifically, they report:

-- Racial differences in intelligence narrowed by about half between 1970 and 1988 and have since remained fairly constant;

-- Socio-economic (SES) class differences between the upper and lower thirds have continued to decline gradually since 1932. IQ scores between these two groups have, in fact, converged about 25 percent in the past 50 years or so.

-- PSATs (Preliminary Scholastic Assessment Tests), which are given to representative samples of high school juniors (as opposed to the self-selected high school seniors who take the SATs) reflect relatively stable score differences between the top and bottom quarters since 1961.

"It's true that SAT scores have declined rather precipitously in recent years," Williams concedes. "Yet, there are good reasons for the decline having nothing to do with dysgenic trends. Specifically, more high school seniors take the SATs now because more colleges require it. In the past, the group of seniors who took the test were self-selected, smaller and more elite."

And she points out, while SAT scores were declining, PSAT scores were climbing and were not influenced by sampling fluctuations due to self-selection. (Since 1965, virtually all high school juniors have taken the PSAT.)

"The most dramatic convergence of scores, however, has been in racial differences in IQ during the 1970s and 1980s, which we think were due to non-genetic factors," Williams said. "During this period, our country spent substantially more for education targeted at minorities, and at the same time, the educational attainment of minority parents increased enormously and their families grew smaller."

Williams and Ceci point out that the closing of the racial gap was due to gains in test scores by black students, not from reductions in white students' scores. The stability of the racial gap since the late 1980s is of concern since the gap has not closed further; but there is no evidence for "the suspicion that dysgenesis is taking place," the Cornell psychologists write. "If there are dysgenic pressures at work in society, then they are being more than offset by the positive pressures," says Ceci.

Williams and Ceci also examined changes in the average scores between brightest and dullest students to determine whether the gap between students at the top and bottom of the distribution is growing. Despite the more diverse pool of students taking the SAT today -- i.e., a less selective, more economically diverse population -- the gap between the top and bottom groups has not widened. Neither the top nor the bottom has varied significantly in either direction since 1976.

"In sum, we have found no compelling evidence supporting the hypothesis that dysgenic pressures are at work, undermining Americans' intellectual capital," the Cornell intelligence experts conclude. "In the battle to control the hearts and the minds of American educational policy-makers and opinion shapers in the mass media, it seems imperative that the combatants temper their passions with a close inspection of the data."


Cornell University

Related Intelligence Articles from Brightsurf:

Human intelligence just got less mysterious says Leicester neuroscientist
NEUROSCIENCE EXPERTS from the University of Leicester have released research that breaks with the past fifty years of neuroscientific opinion, arguing that the way we store memories is key to making human intelligence superior to that of animals.

Artificial intelligence (AI)-aided disease prediction
Artificial Intelligence (AI)-aided Disease Prediction https://doi.org/10.15212/bioi-2020-0017 Announcing a new article publication for BIO Integration journal.

New roles for clinicians in the age of artificial intelligence
New Roles for Clinicians in the Age of Artificial Intelligence https://doi.org/10.15212/bioi-2020-0014 Announcing a new article publication for BIO Integration journal.

Classifying galaxies with artificial intelligence
Astronomers have applied artificial intelligence (AI) to ultra-wide field-of-view images of the distant Universe captured by the Subaru Telescope, and have achieved a very high accuracy for finding and classifying spiral galaxies in those images.

Using artificial intelligence to smell the roses
A pair of researchers at the University of California, Riverside, has used machine learning to understand what a chemical smells like -- a research breakthrough with potential applications in the food flavor and fragrance industries.

Artificial intelligence can help some businesses but may not work for others
The temptation for businesses to use artificial intelligence and other technology to improve performance, drive down labor costs, and better the bottom line is understandable.

Artificial intelligence for very young brains
Montreal's CHU Sainte-Justine children's hospital and the √ČTS engineering school pool their expertise to develop an innovative new technology for the segmentation of neonatal brain images.

Putting artificial intelligence to work in the lab
An Australian-German collaboration has demonstrated fully-autonomous SPM operation, applying artificial intelligence and deep learning to remove the need for constant human supervision.

Composing new proteins with artificial intelligence
Scientists have long studied how to improve proteins or design new ones.

Artificial intelligence and family medicine: Better together
Researcher at the University of Houston are encouraging family medicine physicians to actively engage in the development and evolution of artificial intelligence to open new horizons that make AI more effective, equitable and pervasive.

Read More: Intelligence News and Intelligence Current Events
Brightsurf.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.