Iowa State psychologist is conducting 2 new studies on eyewitness misidentifications

November 09, 2009

AMES, Iowa -- Our memories play tricks on all of us, sometimes preventing us from remembering important details. But when that happens to an eyewitness in a criminal case, Gary Wells says it could be a matter of life and death for the identified suspect.

That's why Wells, a Distinguished Professor of psychology at Iowa State University who developed the dominant theory of how mistaken identifications occur, has begun work on two new studies to explore the thought processes of eyewitnesses when their memory fails as they still try to identify the perpetrator of a crime.

"We've reached a point where to make more advances [in eyewitness identification accuracy], we've got to understand theoretically more of these mistakes," said Wells, who was featured on CBS News' "60 Minutes" earlier this year for his previous eyewitness misidentification research. "That's because we can improve things [in police procedures], but if we're going to improve them even further -- which is the goal -- we need to develop a better theoretical understanding of what's going on."

Wells is in the first year of a four-year study funded by a National Science Foundation grant to examine what happens when the witness to a crime tries to identify a perpetrator after his or her memory has failed. Researchers are gathering pilot data from Iowa State students, but they plan to extend their sample beyond campus to possibly include subjects gathered in an airport.

Six experiments are underway, first to determine how primary memory works when it's successful, and then what happens when secondary memory kicks in.

"Instead of the person sort of bailing out when memory fails and saying 'Gee, I don't know' or 'I guess I'm not going to identify anyone,' secondary processes kick in," Wells said. "And rather than the primary processes, which are automatic, these secondary processes require more thinking. We call them deliberative. People tend to be more conscious of these. They're engaged in a process of reasoning and they tend to be more verbal. So people tend to articulate, we believe, these processes -- and they tend to be the dangerous ones [in terms of misidentification]."

The first experiment will gather baseline data when eyewitnesses are able to easily identify the correct perpetrator to a simulated crime. The other five experiments then force recognition to fail either by altering the initial eyewitness experience, delaying the testing, creating memory interference through the use of additional pictures in the lineup, or taxing the retrieval of memory by altering the images.

"We attempt to make recognition -- this sort of 'Aha! That's the guy' experience -- fail," Wells said. "And by doing it in these various ways, we can then study how it fails and hopefully why the subjects nevertheless attempt to make an identification."

He also is the lead researcher on another study -- funded through private contributors and supported by The Innocence Project in New York, The American Judicature Society, The Police Foundation in Washington, D.C. and the Center for Modern Forensics Practices at John Jay College in New York City -- that is gathering data from real eyewitnesses to serious crimes as they attempt to indentify perpetrators through photo lineups. Wells said data is being collected through police departments in Tucson, Ariz., and will soon begin in San Diego and Austin, Texas.

The study, which Wells says is the first of its kind in this setting, provides eyewitnesses a laptop that takes them through the photo lineup procedure without police assistance. The laptop will determine whether eyewitnesses will be shown photos one at a time, or all at once on the same screen. It will also document their actions as they go through the identification process.

"We want to find out which works best: for the witness to see all people [photos] at once, which we believe is a problem; or for them to see them one at a time and have to make a decision on each one before getting to the next," Wells said. "One of the nice things about the laptop administering these lineups is that we will be able to know exactly how long they'll be looking at each picture. We'll know how long it takes them to make an identification. And, of course, we'll have clean records of exactly what they did."

Wells estimates it will take approximately four years to complete data-collection in this study. And he emphasizes it's not designed to diminish the value of eyewitness identifications, but rather make them more reliable.

"We know we have a real problem," Wells said. "There are now 260 or so exonerations based on forensic DNA testing and three out of every four of those are cases of mistaken eyewitness identifications."

Iowa State University

Related Memory Articles from Brightsurf:

Memory of the Venus flytrap
In a study to be published in Nature Plants, a graduate student Mr.

Memory protein
When UC Santa Barbara materials scientist Omar Saleh and graduate student Ian Morgan sought to understand the mechanical behaviors of disordered proteins in the lab, they expected that after being stretched, one particular model protein would snap back instantaneously, like a rubber band.

Previously claimed memory boosting font 'Sans Forgetica' does not actually boost memory
It was previously claimed that the font Sans Forgetica could enhance people's memory for information, however researchers from the University of Warwick and the University of Waikato, New Zealand, have found after carrying out numerous experiments that the font does not enhance memory.

Memory boost with just one look
HRL Laboratories, LLC, researchers have published results showing that targeted transcranial electrical stimulation during slow-wave sleep can improve metamemories of specific episodes by 20% after only one viewing of the episode, compared to controls.

VR is not suited to visual memory?!
Toyohashi university of technology researcher and a research team at Tokyo Denki University have found that virtual reality (VR) may interfere with visual memory.

The genetic signature of memory
Despite their importance in memory, the human cortex and subcortex display a distinct collection of 'gene signatures.' The work recently published in eNeuro increases our understanding of how the brain creates memories and identifies potential genes for further investigation.

How long does memory last? For shape memory alloys, the longer the better
Scientists captured live action details of the phase transitions of shape memory alloys, giving them a better idea how to improve their properties for applications.

A NEAT discovery about memory
UAB researchers say over expression of NEAT1, an noncoding RNA, appears to diminish the ability of older brains to form memories.

Molecular memory can be used to increase the memory capacity of hard disks
Researchers at the University of Jyväskylä have taken part in an international British-Finnish-Chinese collaboration where the first molecule capable of remembering the direction of a magnetic above liquid nitrogen temperatures has been prepared and characterized.

Memory transferred between snails
Memories can be transferred between organisms by extracting ribonucleic acid (RNA) from a trained animal and injecting it into an untrained animal, as demonstrated in a study of sea snails published in eNeuro.

Read More: Memory News and Memory Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to