Study: Eliminating unnecessary stent procedures could save health care system more than $100 million

November 09, 1999

ATLANTA -- Up to $162 million could be saved annually if cardiologists implant artery tubes called stents into a more select group of patients, according to a new cost analysis performed by Duke University Medical Center cardiologists.

The researchers said the cost savings could be achieved without compromising the quality of patient care.

Stents are tiny metal tubes implanted in the artery immediately after an angioplasty to help prevent the artery from renarrowing, a process known as restenosis. In an angioplasty procedure, a tiny balloon is inflated at the site of an arterial blockage, cracking and displacing the plaque and restoring blood flow to the heart.

As the popularity of stenting has grown, many cardiologists now automatically implant a stent, even when an excellent result is achieved with the balloon alone. Stents are used in more than 500,000 procedures in the United States every year.

"We have shown that there is a group of patients whose arteries are very unlikely to renarrow after angioplasty and who get stent-like results without needing the stent," said cardiologist Dr. Warren Cantor, who led the analysis. "The amount of potential health care savings range from $114 million to $162 million."

Cantor prepared the results of his analysis for presentation Wednesday at the annual scientific sessions of the American Heart Association. The study was supported by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada.

Previous studies by the same Duke team found that approximately one in 12 patients may not need stents because their vessels are very unlikely to renarrow after balloon angioplasty. The researchers determined this after an analysis that showed that those patients least likely to have renarrowing of the artery had "stent-like" results (less than 30 percent residual narrowing) immediately after balloon inflations. They also had three common characteristics: they were men, their vessels had shorter atherosclerotic lesions, and the location of the lesion involved was not at the top of the left anterior descending artery (LAD), the artery that supplies blood to the front of the heart.

In their analysis, the researchers pooled the results of seven different angioplasty trials and an angioplasty registry totaling 5,143 patients. They then compared what the costs would be of pursuing each of the following three treatment strategies:"Based on the combination criteria, about 8 percent of the patients wouldn't need a stent, at a savings of $114 million per year," Cantor said. "If the decision to stent was based solely on how the vessel looked immediately after angioplasty, 18 percent of patients wouldn't require stenting, at a savings of $162 million."

The benchmark for clinical success of these procedures is whether or not the treated vessels renarrow and the patient needs another artery-opening procedure, whether it be angioplasty or coronary artery bypass surgery. In this analysis, the combination group had a 14 percent revascularization rate six months after the procedure, similar to that seen with stent insertion.

"We were pleased to find that relatively simple criteria could identify patients at very low-risk for requiring repeat revascularization after treatment with balloon angioplasty alone," Cantor said. "Although only a small proportion of patients are in this very low-risk group, the potential cost savings are substantial."

Before the advent of stents, up to one-third of all patients who received an angioplasty needed another angioplasty or a bypass operation after six months due to restenosis. Since the introduction of stents in the United States, less than 10 years ago, the restenosis rate has been nearly cut in half.

While stents have markedly reduced the rate of restenosis, Cantor said stents have their own drawbacks. When restenosis does occur within a stent, it is more difficult to treat. Also, there is a slight (1 percent) risk of clot formation in the stent, which could lead to myocardial infarction. Joining Cantor in the analysis were Dr. Michael Sketch, Dr. Eric Peterson, Dr. Robert Califf, Dr. Magnus Ohman, Patricia Cowper and Anne Hellkamp.

Duke University Medical Center

Related Angioplasty Articles from Brightsurf:

Ticagrelor was not superior to clopidogrel to reduce heart attack risk during angioplasty
A new study found the rate of heart attack and severe complications before, during or soon after elective surgery to open a blocked artery was similar between patients treated with clopidogrel and those who received the more potent antiplatelet medication ticagrelor.

Study finds significant variability in doctors' angioplasty death rates
Some doctors have higher or lower than expected death rates from coronary angioplasty procedures, also known as percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI); however, doctors should not be judged solely on the rate of patients who die from the procedure.

Beta-blockers following angioplasty show little benefit for some older patients
Following coronary angioplasty, beta-blockers did not significantly improve mortality rates or reduce the number of future cardiovascular incidents for older patients with stable angina but no history of heart attack or heart failure, according to a study published today in the JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions.

Sleep disorders may predict heart events after angioplasty
People who have had procedures to open blocked heart arteries after acute coronary syndrome (ACS) may have a higher risk of death, heart failure, heart attack and stroke if they have sleep disorders, such as sleep apnea, compared to those who don't.

Reasons for hospital-level variations in bleeding post-angioplasty are unclear
The use of bleeding avoidance strategies has only a modest effect on the variation in bleeding rates post-angioplasty among hospitals performing this procedure, leaving about 70 percent of the causes for this variation unexplained, according to a study published today in JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions.

US prediction models for kidney injury following angioplasty hold up in Japan
Models developed by the American College of Cardiology NCDR CathPCI Registry to predict the likelihood of angioplasty patients developing acute kidney injury and acute kidney injury requiring dialysis have proven to be effective among patients in Japan.

IV beta blockers before angioplasty are safe, but offer no clinical benefit
Giving intravenous beta blockers before performing a coronary angioplasty in patients who had experienced the deadliest form of heart attack -- ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) -- was safe but did not reduce heart attack severity or improve blood flow from the heart's main pumping chamber, according to research presented at the American College of Cardiology's 65th Annual Scientific Session.

Life-threatening bowel ischemia can often be treated by balloon angioplasty
Acute mesenteric ischemia (AMI) can be successfully treated with endovascular therapy such as balloon angioplasty, according to research from the University of Eastern Finland.

Radial access used less than femoral approach for emergency angioplasty
Although using the radial artery as the access point for angioplasty has been linked to reduced bleeding compared to use of the femoral artery, only a small number of high-risk heart attack patients who undergo rescue angioplasty -- emergency procedures following failed therapy with clot-busting drugs -- are treated by radial access, according to a study published today in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology: Cardiovascular Interventions.

Use of rarely appropriate angioplasty procedures declined sharply
The number of angioplasty procedures classified as rarely appropriate declined sharply between 2010 and 2014, as did the number of those performed on patients with non-acute conditions, according to a study published today in the Journal of the American Medical Association and simultaneously presented at a meeting of the American Heart Association in Orlando.

Read More: Angioplasty News and Angioplasty Current Events is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to